My reasoning is that it reaches too far without a safety net of a business model. Assuming Dalton is being truthful in his post, he's not cutting prices because he "didn't get traction" he's cutting prices because his business model is out performing his expectations, and rather than go for a higher net early on he's re-investing that margin into growing the user base.
Tent is going 'old school' like the old IETF protocols, that means waiting for adoption, having a variety of implementations, establishing a consensus, moving forward. That works great in a green field situation, but this isn't it. Look at the OpenMoko effort, free Phone OS, build it and they will come? No. Reaching too far without a model to nourish early adoption and growth. Influential? Sure but killer? Not so much.
Dalton has something which Tent does not, people willing to spend money to use it. That is why I think Tent will be a memory long before we see the end of App.net.
The HN/Reddit crowd is still a fairly closed crowd and no one else I know has even really mentioned App.net. Any time I bring up App.net it's met with the same "Twitter clone" skeptics.
I think it's a decent idea, but it's not really solving a hard problem. It's not feeding off of demand for a problem, but off of popularity from the HN hivemind; a crowd known for following trends over execution. I'm just a developer so I don't know much about running a business, but I cannot see how this can be sustainable when tech crowds are prone to move onto the next thing so quickly.
My observation was that App.net has paid users, enough of them to sustain growth apparently. Fundamentally people being paid to provide something do a better job than people who aren't paid to provide something (helps with the inevitable haters) In my experience paid users are a stronger signal than 'vision' or 'reach' as predictors of success.
We'll get a far better reading of the service once that year is up. In my experience of using annual subscription services/products the hype tends to fizzle out when the core group decide whether their initial investment was worth it. Given its current state I doubt it'll topple its closed competitors in twelve months and I see a large section of its core users ditching it for the next flavour of the week.
It reminds me a lot of MyFootballClub, a website that bought a English football team in the lower leagues with the promise of the community being completely responsible for player contracts, transfers and day-to-day running of the football club. A lot of people coughed up the cash for the site to buy Ebbsfleet United, but after a year most of them realised that what they were sold wasn't necessarily what they got and most decided not to renew. It's not an exact comparison, but I'll give App.net at least another year before I decide whether it's worth my time any more than Twitter.
I expect it will be all about the client capture, which is to say compelling client experiences based on App.net which will drive new development their way.
2009: App.net will be done in a matter of months; the reason is OneSocialWeb
2005: App.net will be done in a matter of months; the reason is Appleseed
Why is this time different?
I did just listen to some guy tell me why he should get paid for 3 minutes. So that's something.
Yawn.
http://www.informationweek.com/development/open-source/tent-...
Please get off the "twitter clone" smackdown ... it's lame. App.net is a trustworthy "blackbox" which allows ANY social construct. It dovetails with Tent.
People are building Tor concepts, non-Zynga collaborative games, new messaging protocols, etc in App.net ... beyond twitter is easy. Indeed, it's hard to keep up with all the API enhancements, and the new developer ideas. My personal goal inside App.net is a construct which brings down the GFW (firewall) of China. (Im fluent in 中文, 25+ years).
No advertisements, paying developers well. Integrity about the future ecosystem. With a $1 million in the bank, one of the best geek hangouts on earth, and world-class integrity ... it ain't going away in months.
You'd be better off predicting that it's a heady time for new social protocols.
I don't get it. What's the advantage of this over regular internet? You use someone else's servers?
The reason is Tent. If Tent drops the ball and doesn't fully execute the idea, someone else will. Their idea is bigger, better and far better maps onto the interest of various 3rd parties (such as hosted service providers) that wouldn't hesitate to support it. Commoditizing the social services is a great idea with balls and vision. Creating a paid Twitter clone is not.