News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by karlgkk on Thursday November 20, 2025 @01:04AM (#45989461)
“ I am just really bored by Lisp Machine romantics at this point: they should go away. I expect they never will.”

What? They’re awesome. They present a vision of the future that never happened. And I don’t think anyone serious expects lisp machines to come back btw.

Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by viccis on Thursday November 20, 2025 @01:41AM (#45989655)
>They present a vision of the future that never happened

Hauntology strikes again

Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by larsbrinkhoff on Thursday November 20, 2025 @01:43AM (#45989664)
See also:

Amiga romantics.

8-bit romantics.

PDP-10 romantics.

Let them stay. Let them romantizice. <glasses tint="rose">

Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by f1shy on Thursday November 20, 2025 @02:25AM (#45989904)
Without those people lots of history (and hence knowledge) would be lost. I’m happy they are around.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by khazhoux on Thursday November 20, 2025 @02:59AM (#45990124)
As an Amiga romantic, I’d say we have no illusions about a late-80s Amiga being a good idea if it existed today. But it captured my imagination (and at just the right age) like nothing else.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by ErroneousBosh on Thursday November 20, 2025 @04:35AM (#45990817)
You're using an 8-bit machine right now.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by jdougan on Thursday November 20, 2025 @06:37AM (#45991567)
Smalltalk romantics
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by DonHopkins on Thursday November 20, 2025 @09:40AM (#45993015)
NeWS romantics.

NeXTSTEP romantics.

ITS romantics.

https://donhopkins.medium.com/the-x-windows-disaster-128d398...

>Unfortunately, NeWS and NeXTSTEP were political failures because they suffer from the same two problems: oBNoXiOuS capitalization, and Amiga Persecution Attitude(TM).

It's classic ESR that he shoplifted the ostensibly trademarked term "Amiga Persecution Attitude(TM)" from my Unix-Haters handbook X-Windows Disaster chapter without giving credit, and put it into his corrupted version of the New Hackers Dictionary, incorrectly mutated to "Amiga Persecution Complex", then he rudely redefined it negatively and inaccurately as "The disorder suffered by a particularly egregious variety of bigot".

There's absolutely nothing wrong with feeling persecuted when you really are, and Amiga users had a great thing going but got shit on all the time. Ironic that ESR would name-call perfectly respectable Amiga users "disordered egregious bigots", when they were totally justified to feel persecuted, while ESR's own actual bigotry runs so deep and wide and mean that it's the main thing he's known for now, so much that Thomas Ptacek actually raised $100,000 for charity to stop himself from tweeting vile ESR quotes.

https://github.com/PDP-10/its/blob/master/doc/humor/jargon.6...

Besides ESR's notorious politics and racism and sexism and homophobia (and noxious body odor), he hijacked the original Jargon File from the MIT-AI Lab, and polluted it with his vile ideology and made-up terms that hackers never used, and even tried to redefine what a hacker is, and himself as a hacker, which he definitely is not.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43139165

>It doesn't help that his infamous "Sex Tips for Geeks" essay comes off like it was written by Pepé Le Pew.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20382529

>And he hijacked the Hacker's Dictionary and proceeded to inject a bunch of his ideological words and definitions in, that in no way represent the hacker community around the early ARPANET and MIT-AI lab from which it came.

https://medium.com/@donhopkins/mit-ai-lab-tourist-policy-f73...

>And as if hijacking the Hacker's Dictionary wasn't enough, he tried to hijack and corrupt the very meaning of the word "hacker" itself, by presuming to define what a hacker is, by preaching to people about how to become a hacker, by blatantly misrepresenting himself as a great hacker and respected leader of the open source community, even though his programming chops are lackluster and outdated, his social skills are deceptive and manipulative, and his hacker spirit is mean, vindictive, and envious of RMS.

>And then there's his death threat to Bruce Perens that he tried to excuse by explaining that he was only trying to "defame" him.

>In 1999, Debian developer Bruce Perens published an "email threat" that he allegedly received from Raymond. Raymond then "clarified" that he only meant to defame Perens. From this we can assume that he is batshit insane and will fucking kill and or write to anyone that says anything about him or his software. If you are lucky you might get an O'Rielly book about you.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12320606

>Except that he's made a career of trying to pose as a hacker, define what a hacker is, tell people how to become a hacker, viciously attack the person, the philosophy and the life's work of one of the world's leading and most respected, influential and successful (if not quirky) hackers, and even hijack and distort the definition of the very words in the hacker's dictionary to reflect his own extremist political ideology, which most certainly does not align with the non-bigoted ideology in the Hacker's Manifesto that we're discussing.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36919981

https://www.dourish.com/goodies/jargon.html

>"This file, jargon.txt, was maintained on MIT-AI for many years, before being published by Guy Steele and others as the Hacker's Dictionary. Many years after the original book went out of print, Eric Raymond picked it up, updated it and republished it as the New Hacker's Dictionary. Unfortunately, in the process, he essentially destroyed what held it together, in various ways: first, by changing its emphasis from Lisp-based to UNIX-based (blithely ignoring the distinctly anti-UNIX aspects of the LISP culture celebrated in the original); second, by watering down what was otherwise the fairly undiluted record of a single cultural group through this kind of mixing; and third, by adding in all sorts of terms which are "jargon" only in the sense that they're technical. This page, however, is pretty much the original, snarfed from MIT-AI around 1988."

Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by vrighter on Friday November 21, 2025 @04:25AM (#46002795)
All of those are systems small enough that all their details could fit inside one human brain. That is a very intoxicating feeling, at least for me.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by smm11 on Friday November 21, 2025 @11:47AM (#46006123)
OpenDoc
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by mghackerlady on Thursday November 20, 2025 @01:14AM (#45989516)
I'm honestly surprised nobody tried to capitalize on the early 2000s Java hype by making some kind of Java box (there were a few things labeled as a Java OS or a Java workstation but none of these were really a "Java Machine")
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by dehrmann on Thursday November 20, 2025 @02:38AM (#45989983)
Coincidentally on the front page, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45989650

ARM also used to have opcodes for Java: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jazelle

Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by mghackerlady on Thursday November 20, 2025 @08:52AM (#45992536)
Haha, I was the one who submitted it after going down a rabbit hole from this :)
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by lukego on Thursday November 20, 2025 @01:19AM (#45989538)
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by mghackerlady on Thursday November 20, 2025 @01:52AM (#45989710)
I was aware of these, it's kinda what I meant by "None of these were really Java Machines". They were just shitty sparc machines that had Java OS in flash. It didn't have some kind of Java co-processor and still relied on a JVM. Java OS was pretty neat but I wouldn't really consider it a "Java OS" since it was basically just a microkernel that bootstrapped a JVM from what I've read. An actual Java machine IMO would have to at least have some kind of Java co-processor and not rely on a software based JVM
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by colinstrickland on Thursday November 20, 2025 @01:55AM (#45989732)
Sun also tried, and failed, to bring to market, a microprocessor architecture for running Java on metal - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MAJC
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by calgoo on Thursday November 20, 2025 @02:07AM (#45989800)
In theory you could say that simcards were / (are?) Tiny java on a chip machines.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by mepian on Thursday November 20, 2025 @04:45AM (#45990876)
Azul Systems was making Java machines a while ago.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by rjsw on Thursday November 20, 2025 @09:34AM (#45992964)
There were attempts to create a "Java Machine". Apart from JOP that is mentioned in another comment there were other systems that had a whole OS written in Java, a stub interrupt handler written in assembler would call into Java for any event.
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by bigfishrunning on Thursday November 20, 2025 @02:54PM (#45996873)
There were a lot of efforts to accelerate the JVM in hardware, the one i remember is the ARM "Jazelle" extension https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jazelle
Re:The lost cause of the Lisp machines by richardjdare on Thursday November 20, 2025 @07:58AM (#45992098)
For me whats inspiring about lisp machines is not any particular implementation detail, but the very idea that working with a computer can be this immersive, holistic experience where everything is accessible and workable through a single, but multidimensional human affordance; language. That the APIs and code within a computer system can be the ergonomic inward counterpart to rich accessible user interfaces, just as a man works with his hands and looks with his eyes, but easily turns inward to think and imagine. This is what I felt when I got that leaked Genera image going in a linux VM several years ago.

Its fair enough to say that lisp machines had this or that hardware limitation, or that they weren't really compatible with market needs, but to criticize 'lisp machine romantics' like this article does is to fail to understand what really motivates romanticism. Maybe you have to be a romantic to really get it. Romanticism is abstract, its about chasing feelings and inspirations that you don't really understand yet. Its about unrealized promises more than its about the actual concrete thing that inspires them.

(I'm also an Amiga romantic, and I think what inspires me about that machine is equally abstract and equally points to a human attitude towards making and using software that seems sadly in decline today)