News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by JKCalhoun on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:23AM (#45857257)
"At the heart of the stock stumbles, there appears to be a growing anxiety about the AI business, which is massively expensive to operate and doesn’t appear to be paying off in any concrete way."

I wonder if this is a thing the U.S. should be worrying about with regard to China taking the lead. As long as the U.S. is … idling … it seems it could catch up—if in fact there is any there there with AI.

But I've been told by Eric Schmidt and others that AGI is just around the corner—by year's end even. Or, it is already being demonstrated in the lab, but we just don't know about it yet.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by gishh on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:29AM (#45857317)
Catch up to what? LLMs have clearly stalled in terms of advancement, they just kind of sort of get a little bit different at this point. Not even better, just different.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by epolanski on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:32AM (#45857355)
I don't see that stall.

All of the tools I use get increasingly better every quarter at the very least (coding tools, research, image generation, etc).

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by Bender on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:53AM (#45858077)
It probably depends on the topics people are interacting with. I've spent the last few days teaching Grok how to manage iptables and nftables when all I wanted was to translate my u32 module rules into nftables and I was being lazy, something the provided translate scripts can not do. Grok would confidently give me an answer, I would say that is wrong and it would admit straight away it was wrong and would confidently give me another wrong answer and I would teach it the right answer after a bit of bumbling on my part. It feels worse than being an editor on serverfault but that's just the silly topics I play with. It could be that most topics it does fine but that has not been my experience thus far. At the end of the day I would have been better off just sticking with the man pages and tcpdump.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by Bender on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:49AM (#45866387)
Adding today I tested some u32 nftable equiv rules and ran into similar issues on chatgpt. Provided I set chatgpt what OS+version and nftables version I am using it will get some of the IP header locations correct but it still gets the syntax wrong for the older version of nftables that Alpine ships with. Sometimes it does get the older syntax right, sometimes not. If I correct it chatgpt it will agree that is a safer method so I should probably start by saying to use the older methods.

Both Grok and ChatGPT appear to have learned from the same sub-optimal locations.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by afavour on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:46AM (#45857482)
As always it’s hype vs reality. Today we’re told AGI is just around the corner. It isn’t. You’re right that a lot of tools are improving iteratively and that’s great but the hyped up valuations we’re seeing are valuing coding assistants, they’re valuing a fictional reality where AGI solves everything and the first one there gets all the rewards.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by epolanski on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:54AM (#45857558)
I haven't said a word about hype nor AGI, I merely said that LLM evolution in the tools available right now, not in the future has neither plateaued nor stalled.

I'm not expressing any judgement on the economics of it.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:31AM (#45857346)
Where does this view come from? I’m not aware of any real evidence for this. Also consider our data center buildouts in 26 and 27 will be absolutely extraordinary, and scaling is only at the beginning. You have a growing flywheel and plenty of synthetic data to break the data wall
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by candiddevmike on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:33AM (#45857358)
We need a fundamental paradigm shift beyond transformers. Throwing more compute or data at it isn't pushing the needle.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by marcosdumay on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:45AM (#45857475)
Just to point, but there's no more data.

LLMs would always bottleneck on one of those two, as computing demand grows crazy quickly with the data amount, and data is necessarily limited. Turns out people threw crazy amounts of compute into it, so the we got the other limit.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by Mistletoe on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:55AM (#45857564)
Yeah I’m constantly reminded of a quote about this- you can’t make another internet. LLMs already digested the one we have.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bigyabai on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:46AM (#45857493)
Synthetic data works.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by marcyb5st on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:03AM (#45857630)
There's a limit to that according to: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07566-y . Basically, if you use an LLM to augment a training dataset it will become "dumber" every subsequent generation and I am not sure how you can generate synthetic data for a language model without using a language model
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by yorwba on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:36AM (#45857950)
Synthetic data doesn't have to come from an LLM. And that paper only showed that if you train on a random sample from an LLM, the resulting second LLM is a worse model of the distribution that the first LLM was trained on. When people construct synthetic data with LLMs, they typically do not just sample at random, but carefully shape the generation process to match the target task better than the original training distribution.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @05:34PM (#45860659)
Epoch has a pretty good analysis of bottlenecks here:

https://epoch.ai/blog/can-ai-scaling-continue-through-2030

There is plenty of data left, we don’t just train with crawled text data. Power constraints may turn out to be the real bottleneck but we’re like 4 orders of magnitude away

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:36AM (#45857395)
And you don’t think that’s already happening? Also where is your evidence for this?
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bigyabai on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:46AM (#45857486)
> Also where is your evidence for this?

The fact that "scaling laws" didn't scale? Go open your favorite LLM in a hex editor, oftentimes half the larger tensors are just null bytes.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:57AM (#45857588)
Show me a paper, this makes no sense of course scaling laws are scaling
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by ModernMech on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:36AM (#45857388)
Let me put it this way: when ChatGPT tells me I've hit the "Free plan limit for GPT-5", I don't even notice a difference when it goes away or when it comes back. There's no incentive for me to pay them for access to 5 if the downgraded models are just as good. That's a huge problem for them.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by riffraff on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:43AM (#45857448)
Ditto for Gemini Pro and Flash, which I have on my phone.

I've been traveling in a country where I don't speak the language and or know the customs, and I found LLMs useful.

But I see almost zero difference between paid and unpaid plans, and I doubt I'd pay much or often for this privilege.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:43AM (#45857447)
This based on any non anecdotal evidence by chance?
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by ModernMech on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:48AM (#45857508)
Of course not but explain how I am ever going to pay OpenAI, a for-profit company any dollars? Sam Altman gets explosive angry when he's asked about how he's going to collect revenue, and that is why. He knows when push comes to shove, his product isn't worth to people what it costs him to operate it. It's Homejoy at trillion dollar scale, the man has learned nothing. He can't make money off this thing which is why he's trying to get the government to back it. First through some crazy "Universal Basic Compute" scheme, now I guess through cosigning loans? I dunno, I just don't buy that this thing has any legs as a viable business.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by noir_lord on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:58AM (#45857598)
Sell at a loss and make it up in volume.

It's been tried before, it generally ends in a crater.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:37PM (#45861714)
I think you’re welcome to that opinion and are far from alone but (1) I am very happy to pay for Claude, even $200/mo is worth it and (2) idk if people just sort of lose track or what of how far things have come in the span of literally a single year, with the knowledge that training infra is growing insanely and people are solving on fundamental problem after another.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by ModernMech on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:07PM (#45862271)
We live in a time when you can't even work for an hour and afford to eat a hamburger. You having the liquid cash to spend $200 a month on a digital assistant is the height of privilege, and that's the whole problem the AI industry has.

The pool of people willing to pay for these premium services for their own sake is not big. You've got your power users and your institutional users like universities, but that's it. No one else is willing to shell out that kind of cash for what it is. You keep pointing to how far it's come but that's not really the problem, and in fact that makes everything worse for OpenAI et al. Because, as they don't have a moat, they don't have customer lock-in, and they also soon will not have technological barriers either. The models are not getting good enough to be what they promise, but they are getting good enough to put themselves out of business. Once this version of ChatGPT gets small enough to fit on commodity hardware, OpenAI et al will have a very hard time offering a value proposition.

Basically, if OpenAI can't achieve AGI before ChatGPT4-type LLM can fit on desktop hardware, they are toast. I don't like those odds for them.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by _aavaa_ on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:40AM (#45857429)
It is a problem easily solved with advertising.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by ModernMech on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:43AM (#45857454)
No, because as the history of hardware scaling shows us, things that run on supercomputers today will run on smartphones tomorrow. Current models already run fairly well on beefy desktop systems. Eventually models the quality of ChatGPT 4 will be open sourced and running on commodity systems. Then what? There's no moat.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by treis on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:12AM (#45857691)
10-20 years of your data in the form of chat history

Billions of users allowing them to continually refund their models

Hell by then your phone might be the OpenAI 1. The world's first AI powered phone (tm)

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by overfeed on Saturday November 08, 2025 @12:53PM (#45858517)
> The world's first AI powered phone

Do you remember the Facebook phone? Not many people do, because it was a failed project, and that was back when Android was way more open. Every couple of years, a tech company with billions has the brilliant idea: "Why don't we have a mobile platform that we control?", followed by failure. Amazon is the only qualified success in this area.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by treis on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:19PM (#45862610)
I agree that a slight twist on android doesn't make sense. A phone with a in integrated LLM with apps that are essentially prompts to the LLM might be different enough to gain market share.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by overfeed on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:51PM (#45862989)
HP, Microsoft, and Samsung all had a go with non-Android OSes.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by skywhopper on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:45AM (#45857481)
There is zero evidence that synthetic data will provide any real benefit. All common sense says it can only reinforce and amplify the existing problems with LLMs and other generative “AI”.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:47AM (#45857495)
Sounds like someone has no knowledge of the literature, synthetic data isn’t like asking ChatGPT to give you a bunch of fake internet data.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by OtherShrezzing on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:39AM (#45857416)
> But I've been told by Eric Schmidt and others that AGI is just around the corner—by year's end even

It was this time last year we were told “2025 will be the year of the agent”, with suggestions that the general population would be booking their vacations and managing their tax returns via Agents.

We’re 7 weeks from the end of the year, and although there are a few notable use cases in coding and math research, agents haven’t shown to be meaningfully disruptive of most people’s economic activity.

Something most people agree is AGI might arrive in the near future, but there’s still a huge effort required to diffuse that technology & its benefits throughout the economy.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by delaminator on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:34AM (#45857370)
> "At the heart of the stock stumbles, there appears to be a growing anxiety about the AI business, which is massively expensive to operate and doesn’t appear to be paying off in any concrete way."

And stock holders realized this last week, all at the same time?

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by riffraff on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:44AM (#45857464)
Well, a WSJ article came out last week, showing OpenAI lost 12B dollars last quarter.

https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/stock-market-today-dow-sp-5...

I'm not saying this triggered a sell off, but it is indicative of perception changes.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by delaminator on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:00PM (#45867548)
Which is quite a chunk. But that's one player and it's not even listed, so it can't be sold off.

AMZN is +10% in the last month, -1% last week.

The same AMZN the powers Anthropic.

This Amazon PR video was doing the rounds this same week.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0TnHSRNqDqM

6,435 views Oct 29, 2025

Project Rainier is one of the world’s largest AI compute clusters. The collaborative infrastructure innovation delivers nearly half a million Trainium2 chips, with Anthropic scaling to more than one million chips by the end of 2025.

I'm still bullish

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by coliveira on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:37AM (#45857402)
This is standard media lingo to try to give a reason for a move that has been decided by the big players. Yes, because only when these large funds decide to make a move together you can get this magnitude of movement (it's not done by mom and pop investors).
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by shortrounddev2 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:30AM (#45857332)
Why do we even want AGI so badly? It seems like a cataclysmic technology. Like after we invent it, market cap and stocks and money wont mean anything anymore
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:33AM (#45857357)
Why do people think this is any different than other major economic revolutions like electricity or the Industrial Revolution? Society is not going to collapse, things will just get weirder in both unbelievably positive ways and then also unbelievably negative ways, like the internet.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by wartywhoa23 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:44AM (#45857459)
The question is why must the humankind strive for unbelievably positive things at the expense of being forever plagued with unbelievably negative?

I'd much rather live in a world of tolerable good and bad opposing each other in moderate ways.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:46AM (#45857488)
Right let’s not have done the Industrial Revolution or the Internet or electricity
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by wartywhoa23 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:54AM (#45857560)
If that undoes the suffering of dozens of millions of human beings killed and maimed in WWI and WWII enabled by the Industrial Revolution, let us have not!
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by shortrounddev2 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:30AM (#45857893)
I think the value of the internet has proven to be pretty dubious. It seems to have only made things worse
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by ToValueFunfetti on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:52AM (#45857547)
Electricity doesn't remove the need for human labor, it just increases productivity. If we produced AGI that could match top humans across all fields, it would mean no more jobs (knowledge jobs at least; physical labor elimination depends on robotics). That would make the university model obsolete- training researchers would be a waste of money, and the well-paid positions that require a degree and thus justify tuition would vanish. The economy would have to change fundamentally or else people would have to starve en masse.

If we produced ASI, things would become truly unpredictable. There are some obvious things that are on the table- fusion, synthetic meat, actual VR, immortality, ending hunger, global warming, or war, etc. We probably get these if they can be gotten. And then it's into unknown unknowns.

Perfectly reasonable to believe ASI is impossible or that LLMs don't lead to AGI, but there is not much room to question how impactful these would be.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by bubblelicious on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:54PM (#45861379)
I disagree, you have to take yourself back to when electricity was not widely available. How much labor did electricity eliminate? A LOT I imagine.

AI will make a lot of things obsolete but I think that is just the inherent nature of such a disruptive technology.

It makes labor cost way lower for many things. But how the economy reorganizes itself around it seems unclear but I don’t really share this fear of the world imploding. How could cheap labor be bad?

Robotics for physical labor lag way behind e.g. coding but only because we haven’t mastered how to figure out the data flywheel and/or transfer knowledge sufficiently and efficiently (though people are trying).

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by ToValueFunfetti on Sunday November 09, 2025 @05:25PM (#45869807)
>How much labor did electricity eliminate? A LOT I imagine.

90% or even 99.9% are in an entirely separate category from 100%. If a person can do 1000x labor per time and you have a use for the extra 999x labor, they and you can both benefit from the massive productivity gains. If that person can be replaced by as many robots and AIs as you like, you no longer have any use for them.

Our economy runs on the fact that we all have value to contribute and needs to fill; we exchange that value for money and then exchange that money for survival necessities plus extra comforts. If we no longer have any value versus a machine, we no longer have a method to attain food and shelter other than already having capital. Capitalism cannot exist under these conditions. And you can't get the AGI manager or AGI repairman job to account for it- the AGI is a better fit for these jobs too.

The only jobs that can exist under those conditions are government mandated. So we either run a jobs program for everybody or we provide a UBI and nobody works. Electricity didn't change anything so fundamental.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by skywhopper on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:47AM (#45857499)
The promise of AGI is that no human would have a job anymore. That is societal collapse.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by cess11 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:58AM (#45857596)
Famously expressed as 'socialism or barbarism' by Rosa Luxemburg, who traced it back to Engels.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by shortrounddev2 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:29AM (#45857887)
Because if you replace all of humans with machines, what jobs will be left?
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by BeFlatXIII on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:59AM (#45858129)
> Like after we invent it, market cap and stocks and money wont mean anything anymore

For those of us who survive the transition, good.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by loeg on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:57AM (#45857580)
AGI level isn't necessarily superhuman or "singularity." It's just human-level. That alone wouldn't make money meaningless.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by shortrounddev2 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:29AM (#45857879)
If it can displace all of knowledge work the way that machines displaced manual labor, then the economy is pretty much fucked, right?
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by loeg on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:31PM (#45861136)
Is there no manual labor anymore? Was the economy fucked by the industrial revolution? It's hard to say how transformative it will be; we're all just kind of speculating.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by shortrounddev2 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:53AM (#45866434)
Automation of manual labor has annihilated some communities in the united states
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by loeg on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:10PM (#45867090)
There are still tons of manual labor jobs, though. Machines did not displace all manual labor, as your earlier comment implied. And the economy was not fucked by automation.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by izacus on Friday November 14, 2025 @02:29AM (#45924703)
You seem to be fundamentally failing to grasp how many communities were destroyed by the changes you're downplaying and how much that is a root cause for political instability you're living through in US.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by marcyb5st on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:38AM (#45857413)
But imagine how much money will it create for shareholders for a little bit /s

Seriously though, there's a part of me that hopes that the technology can help with technological advancement. Fusion, room temperature superconductors, working solid state batteries, ... which will all help in leaping ahead and make sure everyone on the planet has a good life. Is the risk worth it? I don't know, bit that's my reason for wanting AGI

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by skywhopper on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:49AM (#45857516)
Why do you think AGI would help develop things that are mainly limited not by ideas, but by the time and resources it takes to do the experiments and engineering in the real world?
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by skywhopper on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:44AM (#45857466)
I don’t think anyone should be worried about AGI except for all the money, energy, and focus that’s being wasted chasing it. It’s not anywhere close, and the sooner we realize that and start focusing on actual problems, the better off we’ll be.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by techblueberry on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:31AM (#45857342)
What if we already have AGI. What if it is ChatGPT 5. What then?

https://aimagazine.com/articles/openai-ceo-chatgpt-would-hav...

Edit: this was serious, if I read the Wikipedia definition of AGI, ChatGPT meets the historical definition at least. Why have we moved the goal posts?

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by junon on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:34AM (#45857365)
Sam is wrong here, AGI has never had a clear definition, this there's no "we have" or "we haven't". I'd say most agree we're still a ways off.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by techblueberry on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:40AM (#45857423)
I mean 20 years ago it was intelligence that could be used in multiple domains; the ability to reason in natural language. Which is what we have? Really, beyond this fantastical; AGI is when we have luxury automated space communism, I sort of legitimately don’t understand why ChatGPT 5 isn’t AGI. (Other than the fact that it would be super disappointing, which is maybe my point) Maybe it’s AGIv1? Maybe it’s AGI with an IQ of 47? But it’s super bipolar since it can also talk like someone with an IQ of 150x
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by acdha on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:46AM (#45857487)
Lack of reasoning or true understanding. It’s not just that it’s like IQ 47 but that it’s unreliable and inconsistent so you can’t safely deploy it in adversarial contexts.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by techblueberry on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:48AM (#45857509)
Humans with true intelligence are unreliable and inconsistent, why would AGI be different?
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by acdha on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:58AM (#45857595)
AGI wouldn’t be, LLMs are because they’re still far from that level.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by loeg on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:58AM (#45857594)
20 years ago, sub-human levels were extremely optimistic. The context has changed.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by JKCalhoun on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:34AM (#45857928)
I agree, we've been moving the goal posts. I think that the Turing Test was the first casualty of LLM ascendency.

But I also think it's natural to move the goal posts.

We try to peer at the future and what would convince us of machine intelligence. Academia finally delivers and we have to revise what we mean by intelligence.

If one, settling a pillow by her head,

Should say: "That is not what I meant at all;

That is not it, at all."

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by skywhopper on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:52AM (#45857539)
This is Wikipedia’s definition “[AGI] is a type of artificial intelligence that would match or surpass human capabilities across virtually all cognitive tasks.”

GPT-5 is nowhere close to this. What are you talking about?

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by techblueberry on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:08AM (#45857658)
ChatGPT wrote this, but it is basically the argument I’m making:

1. Functional Definition of AGI

If AGI is defined functionally — as a system that can perform most cognitive tasks a human can, across diverse domains, without retraining — then GPT-4/5 arguably qualifies:

It can write code, poetry, academic papers, and legal briefs.

It can reason through complex problems, explain them, and even teach new skills.

It can adapt to new domains using only language (without retraining), which is analogous to human learning via reading or conversation.

In this view, GPT-5 isn’t just a language model — it’s a general cognitive engine expressed through text.

Again I think the common argument is more a religious argument than a practical one. Yes I acknowledge this doesn’t meet the frontier definition of AGI, but that’s because it would be sad if it was the case, not because there’s any actual practical sense that we’ll get to the sci-fi definition. This view that ChatGPT is already performing most tasks reasonably at the edge of beyond human ability is true.

Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by tim333 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @02:43PM (#45859366)
People have different takes but the economically important point is when you can have AI do the jobs rather than having to hire humans. We are not there yet. GPT-5 is good at some things but not others.
Re:$1T in Tech Stocks Sold Off as Market Grows Skeptical of AI by techblueberry on Saturday November 08, 2025 @03:39PM (#45859764)
That’s a good goal, but why is that “AGI”? Why is AGI a socio-political-economic metric and not a technical one, and if it is a socio-political-economic metric, than is just fantasy? Why are we spending trillions of dollars on something we can’t define in technical terms?