News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by hamdingers on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @07:45PM (#45830039)
> But it rolled in so rapidly that it was universal before we had the chance to push back.

This can't be it. I was in high school when smartphones were coming out and there was zero tolerance for them or any other electronic devices (dumbphones, ipods, palm pilots, etc) in the classroom.

I don't know when or why it happened but allowing smartphones in school was a conscious choice and a policy change.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by pessimizer on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @07:52PM (#45830087)
Upper-middle class parents addicted to constant communication with their children started complaining about their kid's not being allowed to carry their phones, nearly at the level of implying it was a human rights violation. They combined this with worries about school shootings (that cellphones haven't ever helped with to my knowledge, unless having live recordings of children being murdered is help.)

After they got it, it was instantly allowed everywhere. It was another result of the "activism" of the same suburban let me speak to your manager class that has been ruining everything for the past 20 years.

edit: A lot of parents are constantly texting back and forth with their kids all day. It's basically their social media, especially if they don't have any friends, and I bet in plenty of cases a huge burden to the children.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by thelock85 on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:22PM (#45831011)
This.

Schools are not employers that can implement take it or leave it policies. You need coordination and agreement between school leadership, district leadership, staff, and most critically parents to put your foot down on anything while also working to ensure basic safety and decent academic outcomes.

Now that the ills of social media and screen time are mainstream knowledge, it’s easier to make a common sense argument without much pushback.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by p00dles on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:46PM (#45831162)
Ugh this is so tragic but I think correct
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by japhyr on Thursday November 06, 2025 @07:01AM (#45834281)
I started teaching in the 90s, and left classroom teaching in 2019. This is how I saw it play out in every school I was aware of.

People think "just ban phones". But there are so many factors at play, it has to be a coordinated effort across an entire school. And everyone has to play along. Any policy is only as good as its enforcement, and enforcement is hard.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by paulddraper on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @08:49PM (#45830489)
Agreed.

There existed a period of time where handheld communication devices existed and were banned.

Sometime later, someone somewhere made a conscious choice to change policy. It didn’t just happen.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by therein on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @08:55PM (#45830516)
> someone somewhere

Must have been a powerful person.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by obscurette on Thursday November 06, 2025 @01:04AM (#45831987)
They were. I was there in edu conferences, training sessions and other events years ago and could observe all this massive FUD which appeared – "smartphones are the future", "all communication will be in social media in the future", "books will not matter", "privacy will not matter", "if we ban smartphones, we will handicap our children" etc. People didn't know better and there was genuine fear in education. Or actually, it's still very much there.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by cameron_b on Thursday November 06, 2025 @09:14AM (#45835469)
This is a huge factor, and heavily influenced by the purveyors of the technologies involved. A factor I hadn't realized that is implicated in this transition is the shift from the Teacher-led classroom to the device-led classroom. The teacher is no longer seen as the expert, the interpreter, the model figure of the subject when the laptop or tablet is the delivery tool. Students learn that the teacher is a facilitator, likely not up to date on the latest changes to the app interface, and not an authority on the subject.

Device-delivery instead of teacher-delivery puts the student first, even when the student knows nothing, and has zero impulse control.

So instead of modelling a productive and enriching data accessing environment, we're actually just tearing down the walls of the school and asking teachers to babysit the mayhem.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by zhivota on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @11:34PM (#45831513)
Pretty simple really, we're basically all [1] addicted to smartphones, so we basically all [1] advocated for this. After all, to admit it was a problem for our kids, we'd have to also admit it could be a problem for ourselves.

Even I find myself holding onto my phone during most of the day when not on my computer, I don't even know why. It's an incredibly addictive piece of technology.

[1] - to a first order of approximation, yes I know you're the exception

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by nandomrumber on Thursday November 06, 2025 @03:33AM (#45832871)
Did we ever allow the students to smoke in the classroom?
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by deaux on Thursday November 06, 2025 @04:05AM (#45833060)
We allowed teachers to smoke in the classroom, so in some sense..
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by DANmode on Thursday November 06, 2025 @03:04PM (#45839705)
Teacher gets the lion’s share of the nicotine, kids get all of the rest, essentially.

Raw deal.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by lobf on Thursday November 06, 2025 @03:42AM (#45832916)
We allowed it in designated areas outside the classroom between classes…
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by wongarsu on Thursday November 06, 2025 @06:03AM (#45833838)
My school even had a gazebo on the school yard so smokers didn't have to stand in the rain. They literally spent money to accommodate smokers.

Of course by the time I was there smoking on school grounds was prohibited, so smokers had to go just beyond the gate. Which students were not allowed to, but few teachers were willing to enforce that

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by Yeul on Thursday November 06, 2025 @08:35AM (#45835067)
In the class room? No. But students could smoke during breaks at the schoolyard.

Funny that we as a society were winning for a while until somebody invented vapes.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by mschuster91 on Thursday November 06, 2025 @09:05AM (#45835383)
In the classroom not, but during my youth in Germany, the smokers had their own smoker's corner with an ashtray until smoking age was raised from 16 to 18 and the smokers had to go out of the schoolyard (i.e. they had to walk 5 meters more, lol).
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by WorldMaker on Thursday November 06, 2025 @02:06PM (#45839001)
In the 1970s some "Vocational" High Schools allowed it (if the students were past the legal age).
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by benchly on Thursday November 06, 2025 @04:33AM (#45833221)
What's missing from the initial comparison is the fact that smartphones opened up all sorts of conveniences, which is partly what makes them so addictive. Rock music, D&D, etc, these other things that were crusaded against offered no convenience for all, so a conservative mind saw no value in it and attacked it as something that warps or rots young brains. Smartphones obviously do that and worse, but because they offer all sorts of helpful tools in our daily lives, we let it slide.

When I was in high school in the 90's, the famed Texas Instruments calculators were often banned in some maths classes because, as was said at the time, we were "not going to be walking around with a computer in our pockets all the time," so we needed to learn to do the work. By the time my younger brother passed through the same classes, they were required to have a graphing calculator because it actually helped kids complete the work. And play Dope Wars.

While we do tend to overreact to new tech, ways of thinking, games, music, etc, there's something inherently oily and snakelike about a thing that brings convenience to our lives the way smartphones or cell phones did. They slip in, comfortably at times, settling into our habits and routines while simultaneously altering them. We end up manipulated by it and before we know it, we can't set it down. In the case of smartphones, our data became the commodity, a mere decade or two after we were worried about tracking devices in cars or phone lines being tapped. But the smartphones kept delivering on their promises, which kept us hooked.

As someone who recovering from alcoholism, I struggle to call our love of smartphones an addiction, but if it helps people be aware of the dangers, by all means, use the term. To me, the problem of smartphones is manipulation at the deepest cognitive levels. We started offloading some thinking to them and who could blame us? We had the store of human knowledge in our pockets! We could play a game instead of sitting idle on the train, gamble with online casinos to try and win some extra cash that week, keep up with the Joneses on Facebook or get into a heated debate on Twitter during our lunch break, check banking, stocks and eBay sales, etc. We no longer had to carry a separate device to photograph or record the moment. The list goes on and on. But in the end, it altered our behavior just enough that we allow ourselves to be controlled by it, monitored by it, and bought and sold by it.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by hshdhdhehd on Thursday November 06, 2025 @09:04AM (#45835368)
Yeah I used to finish my job on a computer and go use another computer for fun. The smart phone is just a smaller one of tbose.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by bavell on Thursday November 06, 2025 @09:08AM (#45835419)
HA I think I still have dope wars on my old college TI-84. Thanks for the blast of nostalgia!
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by DANmode on Thursday November 06, 2025 @03:02PM (#45839679)
Came to comment “Ours were banned because we wrote scripts to show ‘MEMORY CLEARED’ before exams, and played Pokémon on the motherfucker”.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by DavidPiper on Thursday November 06, 2025 @01:44AM (#45832204)
Hey, we must have been in high school at the same time. I saw the same thing going through my final years. But when I went back to visit the school a few years after I left... Things were very different.

I'd say there was definitely a grace period (roughly iPhone -> iPhone 4 maybe?) where device addiction wasn't yet normalised, and the real world hadn't ceded control yet. Not sure what happened at the school level after that, but somewhere along the way phones (devices as they were called then) everywhere all the time became very normal.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by 7thaccount on Thursday November 06, 2025 @07:32AM (#45834505)
Even dumb phones like that Nokia everyone had or the Motorola Razr were banned. You had to have them powered off and in your backpack.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by miki123211 on Thursday November 06, 2025 @07:42AM (#45834585)
TBH, I think banning smartphones in class is entirely justified and reasonable.

Banning smartphones completely (including during breaks / lunch)? A different matter entirely.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by tda on Thursday November 06, 2025 @09:31AM (#45835661)
If you haven't been to a school recently where >99% of kids all direct >99% percent of their attention during breaks I can see where you are coming from. But I was at a highschool with a lax phone policy (allowed in breaks etc), and I was amazed and appalled. A no-phones policy is really important to me, because there seems to be no middle ground possible.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by gilbetron on Thursday November 06, 2025 @08:39AM (#45835107)
The pandemic induced the major change. Schools were forced to put everything online, and so screens became the default learning environment. What's the difference between them being on a laptop/chromebook/tablet and a phone? Not really that much. Plus parents allowed their kids get phones at a younger age to keep track of them. Now we are trying to claw it back, but the big problem is that the parents are the ones preventing it. They need to be constantly attached to their kids. Our son is 16 and while he loves screens, he also is enjoying kids spending less time on them at school so he can chat with people more.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by Spooky23 on Thursday November 06, 2025 @08:42AM (#45835135)
Parents are insane and demand access to their kids at all times.

My son goes to a private school, and I was on the board of trustees when we basically did the same thing the NYS requires three years ago. The drama and insanity was beyond anything I expected. One parent left me a three minute voicemail excoriating me as being no better than a school shooter - in the event of an emergency her son would die alone, because of me. (I introduced the motion and was called out in the minutes)

It’s great that the state passed a pretty sane law on the matter. Crazy people already think the governor is <insert terrible thing>, and the school boards can just nod, point to Albany and get on with their business.

There is leeway as well, our school (and some others that I know of), allow 7th graders and up to email parents via GMail. So little Tommy can keep folks in the loop about scheduling changes or whatever.

Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again by jpster on Thursday November 06, 2025 @11:42PM (#45843611)
Well, in the era of school shootings, some parents argued that a phone could be a literal lifeline to their parents and a way to say their last goodbyes if the worst happened. It doesn’t really stand up when you compare the likelihoods of a school shooting (rare) to phone-induced educational and social regressions (almost certain). But it was an evocative argument and it worked to a large degree.