Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again
by thelock85 on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:22PM
(#45831011)
This.
Schools are not employers that can implement take it or leave it policies. You need coordination and agreement between school leadership, district leadership, staff, and most critically parents to put your foot down on anything while also working to ensure basic safety and decent academic outcomes.
Now that the ills of social media and screen time are mainstream knowledge, it’s easier to make a common sense argument without much pushback.
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again
by p00dles on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:46PM
(#45831162)
Ugh this is so tragic but I think correct
Re:NY smartphone ban has made lunch loud again
by japhyr on Thursday November 06, 2025 @07:01AM
(#45834281)
I started teaching in the 90s, and left classroom teaching in 2019. This is how I saw it play out in every school I was aware of.
People think "just ban phones". But there are so many factors at play, it has to be a coordinated effort across an entire school. And everyone has to play along. Any policy is only as good as its enforcement, and enforcement is hard.
After they got it, it was instantly allowed everywhere. It was another result of the "activism" of the same suburban let me speak to your manager class that has been ruining everything for the past 20 years.
edit: A lot of parents are constantly texting back and forth with their kids all day. It's basically their social media, especially if they don't have any friends, and I bet in plenty of cases a huge burden to the children.