News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by drnick1 on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @04:20AM (#45808970)
Some people still say that 1080p is plenty, whether for reading text or watching videos (including gaming), but anyone who has used a 4K monitor knows that text looks far clearer and games look far more realistic and detailed at 4K. And the same will probably be true when 4K becomes truly mainstream on desktops.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by epolanski on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @04:59AM (#45809200)
> but anyone who has used a 4K monitor knows that text looks far clearer and games look far more realistic and detailed at 4K

It depends on the distance really.

Text at a desktop at an arms distance max, possibly on 24"+ will be noticeably better.

I have a 34" inches ultra wide 1440p and I definitely would love higher pixel density.

But start getting 24" or less and 1440p vs 4k are borderline marketing.

People do swear to be able to see the difference, yet I remember they random tested some 120+ gamers who were shown the same TV with different output res, and the distribution of guesses had a very minor slight advantage for the 4k, well in the realm of errors, and it obviously dropped to non existence with just few centimeters of distance more.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by orbital-decay on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @05:56AM (#45809581)
It also heavily depends on the content being displayed. You might not be able to tell any difference in a typical game frame or a movie, but a 1px black on white line still activates your cones while being way below the minimum angular resolution you can see. You can see stars for the same reason.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by reactordev on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @07:41AM (#45810272)
People forget this. Our eye resolution is infinity. Our focal length is different.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by spoiler on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:47AM (#45810983)
I don't think it's actually infinit, but it's probably very high! We do have little receptors (cones) in our eyes (retina) that react chemically to light. So the density is the resolution (and different cone types react to different wavelengths, which is why some people are coloured blind, for example)!
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by epolanski on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @09:19AM (#45811321)
Well, technically speaking:

- we are all colorblind, as we only see a very small part of the light spectrum

- there are no two individuals that perceive colors in the same way in the world as the receptor distribution changes by person to person (actually, even day by day on a single-individual basis)

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by IAmBroom on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:34PM (#45815013)
> we are all colorblind, as we only see a very small part of the light spectrum

That's not what "colorblind" means. Are we also all deaf, because we can't hear sounds outside a certain frequency range?

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by IAmBroom on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @09:02AM (#45811128)
You seem to not understand those terms at all.

Our resolution varies across our FOV, but is best measured in the center of vision. (Ironically, we can potentially see smaller objects away from the center, but... biology is analog, not digital, and weird.)

Focal length is merely the conversion factor from physical resolution at the receiver side to angular resolution in the real world. It varies, but not by much, eye to eye, with vision aids (glasses, etc.), and (very trivially) with distance to the object. So, it's basically a constant.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by reactordev on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @09:13AM (#45811257)
I’m pretty sure you just confirmed that focal length varies. So I stand by my statement. Our rods and cones enable us to see great detail and yes, it’s more concentrated in the center of field of view, but if we’re talking pixels… 567MP is what people claim. I know it’s a lot higher. Pilots are able to spot specks at 4nm. Astronauts can see objects that are just a speck at 50nm. Our actual eye resolution is insane when paired with the right focal length.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by epolanski on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @09:51AM (#45811652)
I wrote a longer post, but I'll keep it short: you can't compare 100 small res cameras + an inference engine that combines the samples together (our brain with low res foveal samples) on the same metrics you'd judge a single camera with 100x more res. They simply see, resolve and process things differently.

To stick with your example: the pilots that "see" aircraft at 4 nautical miles don't "see" them because their foveas have super human pixel density. But because high-contrast very low res foveal samples + contextual inference + motion + time, give more time to the brain to infer the presence of the aircraft. But if you had the ability to stop the motion and image the very same aircraft would "disappear".

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by IAmBroom on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:31PM (#45814989)
I confirmed it varies trivially. That means it effectively doesn't vary.

Your statement about resolution being infinite is laughably wrong. I assume you don't even understand what "infinite" means.

You wrote two sentences that are both wrong.

Also, your understanding of resolution is lacking. Our eyes aren't uniformly covered at all. The MP amount you claim is "virtual", for want of a better word. It's like taking an SD (480p) video for one second, combining it with AI, and extrapolating a 500MP single photo. It's very like that, in practice.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by orbital-decay on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @09:24AM (#45811386)
Resolution allows you to pick up different image features, it's not infinite. A zebra pattern will eventually merge into a solid gray color upon shrinking, that's your actual resolution limit. But a single dot or a line surrounded by enough background will still be visible way below this limit because it has enough energy difference to activate a photoreceptor, even though you won't be able to tell its true size or thickness.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by 1718627440 on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @10:06AM (#45811823)
There is also overlap between these ranges. At some distance you can choose whether you want to perceive a zebra pattern as gray or as pattern.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by IAmBroom on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:33PM (#45815002)
And if you look away to something else in your FOV, your brain redecides for you!
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by 4kchiefofstaff on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @10:09AM (#45811856)
I see easily a difference on text rendering on a mac os retina display (3k on 14") vs. 4k 27" oled. 1080p is horrible obvious on basically every display size i own.

And my smartphone or my DSLR take pictures with more than 4k, you can see the image sharpness difference also immediately.

What content is left? Games, but they also have text. Higher resolution, less antialising needed.

The most frustrating thing about this type of discussion is: Its 2025! 4k displays exist for how much in consumer space? 10 years by now?

8k is also nice. Might actually be something i don't pay extra for, but supporting 8k opens up so many possibilities. Like controling 4 4k displays without issues (demo walls, event setups etc.) or just 2 or 3 24/27" displays on your desk.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by epolanski on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @01:33PM (#45814334)
27" is huge.

I remember comparing 4k macbook with my 1440p samsung, both 14" and it was impossible to say at that screen size.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by drnick1 on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @01:50PM (#45814547)
It isn't huge. On a large desk, my 32" 4K display is great, and easily substitutes two smaller monitors for productivity tasks. It's also very immersive for gaming, even more so now that you have OLED options.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by my123 on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:07AM (#45809633)
Maybe for gaming but at 24 inches for desktop monitor I see a sizeable difference for text rendering.

Looks like good anti-aliasing for text to look better on lower DPI display is slowly getting the bitrot treatment...

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by epolanski on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:35AM (#45809793)
I personally struggle at 1440p vs 4k as soon as you get at 27" mark, but I'm generally at a 70/80 centimeters (2.5 feet in american units) distance from my screen.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by onion2k on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:49AM (#45809887)
This is hard to gauge though because it's rarely only a change from 1080p to 4k. The screen tech often changes from LCD to LED (or microLED, or OLED), there's all manner of motion smoothing added, sometimes higher refresh rates, and so on.

Anecdotally I was at a family Christmas where relatives were watching some home videos that were encoded at 480p on a flash drive on a new TV, and they all said that the quality of the 4K picture was amazing despite the fact they were all watching 480P video (without upscaling because I'd turned it off.) To be fair it did look better than an old TV, but not because of the resolution.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by mytailorisrich on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:02AM (#45810532)
I have a 34" 4K TV and from the couchthere is a difference between 1080p and 4K on it. 4K is crisper whether on Netflix or YouTube. Only potential variable, I think is the codec and compression used on each resolution.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by IAmBroom on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @09:03AM (#45811146)
There is less blending at the edges of high contrast, so some edges wil likely seem sharper.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by wronex on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:53AM (#45809912)
I find it fascinating that the same is true for frame rate. Some people think 60Hz is OK, while anyone who has tried a 120Hz screen will agree it is infinitely smoother. The same is true again for a 240Hz screen. I have yet to try a 480Hz screen but imagine the jump will be equally impressive.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by throawayonthe on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @07:08AM (#45810011)
i was going to say it likely would not be as impressive because the frame times would decrease by a lesser fraction, but then i found this article, interesting: https://blurbusters.com/massive-upgrade-with-120-vs-480-hz-o...
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by fnands on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @04:53AM (#45809162)
Yeah, I think diminishing returns kick in at some point.

Going from 1080p to 1440p feels like a huge improvement. Going from 1440p to 4k (aka 2160p) is a little bit sharper. I don't think the jump from 4k to 8k will improve things that much.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by bombcar on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @05:17AM (#45809309)
I can tell the difference between 1080p (or upscaled 1080p) and 4k on a 50" screen at "living room" distances, but it's nowhere near as obvious as SD to DVD was.

At "laptop" screen distances the difference between my Retina display and non-retina external monitors is quite noticeable; so much so that I run 4k in 1080p mode more and more.

8k is going to require those curved monitors because you'll have to be that close to it to get the advantage.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by close04 on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:11AM (#45809658)
> I can tell the difference between 1080p (or upscaled 1080p) and 4k

Are you talking about the resolution of the video or of the screen itself? Lower resolution video looks worse also because of the compression. I saw bigger difference from video compression than from screen resolution. E.g. good 1080p video looked better than bad 1080p video on any screen and resolution.

I have a 43" 4k monitor at ~1m distance and when I use the computer set up with 100% scaling it looks bad, I see pixelation... and "subpixelation". On a different computer connected to the same screen but something like 150% scaling it's like night and day difference. Everything looks smooth, perfect antialiasing.

This is the money picture [0]. Above a certain distance any improvement is imperceptible. But don't compare compressed video on a screen, it will add quality issues that influence your perception.

[0] https://media.springernature.com/full/springer-static/image/...

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by bombcar on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:29AM (#45810801)
It’s most noticeable with animation that has text-like lines, in my experience.

For plain video, 1080p at high enough bitrate is fine.

Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by ant6n on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @05:46AM (#45809519)
DVDs are SD, with 480 pixels of resolution for ntsc.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by bombcar on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:01AM (#45809603)
Yeah I meant VHS → DVD (which was noticeable), and also SD → HD (1080p) which was again noticeable.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by eterevsky on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @05:21AM (#45809343)
Probably not for 32” monitor, but I think 8k would be noticeably better for a 43”.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by pfortuny on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:07AM (#45809631)
Actually, just going from 1080 to QHD (1200?? I don't remember) has made my work so much pleasant.
Re:Resolution limit of the eye – how many pixels can we see? by bookofjoe on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:21AM (#45810722)
Vision Pro — for me — differentiates itself from all other screens in its ability to render closeups of the human face. The 6k detail is staggering.