News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by ethbr1 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @07:19AM (#45731416)
You're holding up a perfect status quo that doesn't correspond to reality.

Countries vary, but in the US and many places there's a shortage of quality therapists.

Thus for many people the actual options are {no therapy} and {LLM therapy}.

> This is why we have safety regulations, why we don't let people drive cars that haven't passed tests, build with materials that haven't passed tests, eat food that hasn't passed tests.

And the reason all these regulations and tests are less than comprehensive is that we realize that people working, driving affordable cars, living in affordable homes, and eating affordable food is more important than avoiding every negative outcome. Thus most societies pursue the utilitarian greater good rather than an inflexible 'do no harm' standard.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by alex-moon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:12AM (#45731773)
You understand that what you're saying is equivalent to: "starving people should simply eat vermin and bugs off the street"? I don't have any patience for this line of argumentation myself. I've seen it used to justify appalling things, especially in the domain of housing.
Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by jack_tripper on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @07:49AM (#45731623)
>Countries vary, but in the US and many places there's a shortage of quality therapists.

Worse in my EU country. There's even a shortage of shitty therapists and doctors, let alone quality ones. It takes 6+ months to get an appointment for a 5 minute checkup at a poorly reviewed state funded therapist, while the good ones are either private or don't accept any new patients if they're on the public system. And ADHD diagnosticians/therapists are only in the private sector because I guess the government doesn't recognize this as being a real mental issue worthy of your tax Euros.

A friend of mine got a more accurate diagnosis by putting his symptoms in ChatGPT than he got from his general practitioner. I also wasted a lot of money on bad private therapists that were basically just phoning in their job, so to me, the bar seems pretty low, since as long as they pass their med-school exams and don't kill too many people through malpractice, nobody checks up on how good or bad their are at their job (maybe some need more training, or maybe some don't belong in medicine at all).

Not saying all doctors are bad (I've met few amazing ones), but it definitely seems like the healthcare systems are failing a lot of people everywhere if they resort to LLMs for diagnosis and therapy.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by kakacik on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:19AM (#45731842)
Not sure where you are based, but in general GPs shouldn't be doing psychological evaluation, period. I am in Europe, and this is the default. If you live in utter shithole (even if only health-care wise), move elsewhere if its important for you - it has never been easier, Europe is facing many issues and massive improvement of healthcare is not in the work pipeline, more like the opposite.

You also don't expect butcher to fix your car, those are as close as above (my wife is a GP so I have a good perspective from the other side, including tons of hypochondriac and low-intensity psychiatric persons who are an absolute nightmare to deal with and routinely overwhelm the system so that there isn't enough resources to deal with more serious cases).

You get what you pay for at the end, 'free' healthcare typical for Europe is anyway still paid for one way or another. And if the market forces are so severely distorted (or bureaucracy so ridiculous/corrupt) that they push such specialists away or into another profession, you get healthcare wastelands you describe.

Vote, and vote with your feet if you want to see change, not ideal state but thats reality.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by lxgr on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:19PM (#45734875)
> I am in Europe, and this is the default.

Obligatory reminder that Europe is not a homogeneous country.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by jack_tripper on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @09:25AM (#45732597)
>but in general GPs shouldn't be doing psychological evaluation, period. I am in Europe, and this is the default.

Where did I say GPs have to do that? In my example of my friend's being misdiagnosed by GPs, it was about another issue, not mental, but it has the same core problem of doctors misdiagnosing patients worse than a LLM bring into questions their competence or that of the health system in general if a LLM can do better than someone who spent 6+ years in med school and got a degree to be a licensed MD to treat people.

>You also don't expect butcher to fix your car, those are as close as above

You're making strawmen at this point. Such metaphors have no relevance to anything I said. Please review my comment through the lens of the clarifications I just made. Maybe the way I wrote it initially made it unclear.

>You get what you pay for at the end

The problem is the opposite, that you don't get what you pay for, if you're a higher than average earner. The more you work, the more taxes you pay, but get the same healthcare quality in return as unskilled laborer who is subsidized.

It's a bad reward structure to incentivize people to pay more of their taxes into the public system, compounded by the fact that government workers, civil servants, lawyers, architects, and other privileged employment classes of bureaucrats with strong unions, have their own separate heath insurance funds, that separate from the national public one that the unwashed masses working in the private sector have to use, so THEY do get what THEY pay for, but you don't.

So that's the problem with state run systems, just like you said about corruption, that giving the government unchecked power over large amounts of people's taxes, allow the government to manipulate the market and choosing winners and losers based on political favoritism and not on the fair free market of who pays the most into the system.

Maybe Switzerland managed to nail it with their individual private system, but I don't know enough to say for sure.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by spookie on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @07:49AM (#45731618)
Ok then, the LLMs must pass the same tests and be as regulated as therapists.

After all, it should be easy peasy (:

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by paulcole on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @07:55AM (#45731650)
If the choice is between no food and food then your standard for food goes way down.
Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by jodrellblank on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:19AM (#45731840)
I haven’t clicked the article but you and the other arguers in this thread are arguing as if 21 million people are asking for therapy, going to a therapist, and being forced to talk to ChatGPT instead of a human while someone unspecified claims it is a human-level therapist.

I doubt that is happening, and that instead people are informally talking to it at home or on their phones - so what specifically are you asking to regulate?

Are people not allowed to talk to their friends in the pub about suicide because the friends aren’t therapists? Not allowed to write to Agony Aunts because they’re not a regulated industry? Not allowed to ring the Samaritans because they’re volunteers and not medically qualified? Not allowed to talk to priests or other religious community leaders about their problems for the same reason?

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by baobun on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:17PM (#45737572)
> Are people not allowed to talk to their friends in the pub about suicide because the friends aren’t therapists?

I don't see anyone in thread arguing that.

The arguments I see are about regulating and restricting the business side, not its users.

If your buddy started systematically charging people for recorded chat sessions at the pub, used those recordings for business development, and many of their customers were returning with therapy-like topics - yeah I think that should be scrutinized and put a lid on when recordings show the kind of pattern we see in OP after their patrons suicide.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by nelox on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @09:14AM (#45732466)
What tests? The term “therapist” is not protected in most jurisdictions. No regulation required. Almost anyone can call themselves a therapist.
Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by criddell on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @10:01AM (#45733032)
In every state you have to have a license to practice.

The advice to not leave the noose out is likely enough for ChatGPT to lose it's license to practice (if it had one).

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by terminalshort on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @11:00AM (#45733734)
LLMs can pass the bar now, so I don't think they would have any problems here.
Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by alex-moon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:43AM (#45732098)
I don't accept the unregulated and uncontrolled use of LLMs for therapy for the same reason I don't accept arguments like "We should deregulate food safety because it means more food at lower cost to consumers" or "We should waive minimum space standards for permitted developments on existing buildings because it means more housing." We could "solve" the homeless problem tomorrow simply by building tenements (that is why they existed in the first place after all).

The harm LLMs do in this case is attested both by that NYT article and the more rigorous study from Stanford. There are two problems with your argument as I see it: 1. You're assuming "LLM therapy" is less harmful than "no therapy", an assumption I don't believe has been demonstrated. 2. You're not taking into account the long term harm of putting in place a solution that's "not fit for human use" as in the housing and food examples: once these things become accepted, they form the baseline of the new accepted "minimum standard of living", bringing that standard down for everyone.

You claim to be making a utilitarian as opposed to a nonmaleficent argument, but, for the reasons I've stated here, I don't believe it's a utilitarian argument at all.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by malka1986 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @10:48AM (#45733593)
> I don't accept the unregulated and uncontrolled use of LLMs for therapy for the same reason I don't accept arguments like "We should deregulate food safety because it means more food at lower cost to consumers"

That is not the argument. The argument is not about 'lower cost', it is about availability. There are not enough shrinks for everyone who would need it.

So it would be "We should deregulate food safety to avoid starving", which would be a valid argument.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by freedomben on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @10:34AM (#45733416)
I think the reason you don't believe the GP argument, is because you are misunderstanding it. The utilitarian argument is not calling for complete deregulation. I think you're taking your absolutist view of not allowing llms to do any therapy, and assuming the other side must have a similarly absolutist view of allowing it to do any therapy with no regulations. Certainly nothing in the GP comment suggests complete deregulation as you have said. In fact, I got explicitly the opposite out of it. They are comparing it to cars and food, which are pretty clearly not entirely deregulated.
Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by terminalshort on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @10:59AM (#45733721)
I bet you don't accept that because you can afford the expensive regulated version.
Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by ethbr1 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:45PM (#45738047)
> "We should waive minimum space standards for permitted developments on existing buildings because it means more housing." We could "solve" the homeless problem tomorrow simply by building tenements (that is why they existed in the first place after all).

... the entire reason tenements and boarding houses no longer exist is because most governments regulated them out of existence (e.g. by banning shared bathrooms to push SFHs).

You can't have it all ways.

strict minimum regulation : availability : cost

Pick 2.

Re:OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about s... by butlike on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @04:38PM (#45738823)
Small edit:

> ... the entire reason tenements and boarding houses no longer exist

... the entire reason tenements and boarding houses no longer exist _where you live_