Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by itopaloglu83 on Sunday October 26, 2025 @07:53AM
(#45711004)
Let’s be a huge burden to local utilities that prices skyrocket, make everyone else pay for the infrastructure cost, and then act surprised when people vote to block us.
Yes, we do need the data centers, but people have a saying too.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by Yeul on Sunday October 26, 2025 @12:18PM
(#45713039)
I don't mind Amazon using the water if they pay for it just like the rest of us.
Unfortunately companies tend to negotiate special deals. And for what? How many local people actually get jobs in a date centre? A few security guards, cleaners and gardeners?
I've seen these things they do everything remote and if that doesn't work they fly in a team.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by rangestransform on Sunday October 26, 2025 @03:04PM
(#45714374)
Even them paying for it shifts the demand curve and makes it expensive for everyone else in the short term, and local government will abuse bureaucracy to make damn sure “short term” is long
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by egorfine on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:55AM
(#45721690)
> Yes, we do need the data centers, but people have a saying too.
Think of the airports. Do we need them? Absolutely. Do people have a say? Yes they do. And that's the problem: they will always say sure but not in my backyard. Obviously no one wants an airport nearby, that's understandable. So in the end expanding an airport (and thus economy) becomes basically impossible.
But in case of airport there is at least a clear case to make. DataCenters? Not so much. Laymen are unable to make an educated decisions here hence they will always vote no.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by bfkwlfkjf on Sunday October 26, 2025 @07:52AM
(#45710995)
> Asked about the leaked document, Amazon spokesperson Margaret Callahan described it as “obsolete” and said it “completely misrepresents Amazon’s current water usage strategy”.
> “A document’s existence doesn’t guarantee its accuracy or finality,” she said. “Meetings often reshape documents or reveal flawed findings or claims.”
Here's a person trained to speak in half truths. Am I the only one to find this revolting? Please tell me I'm not alone.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by rcxdude on Sunday October 26, 2025 @12:19PM
(#45713040)
Maybe, but it is entirely possible that someone put together some numbers and got them completely wrong, in which case those statements sound pretty reasonable. They could be misleading or outright false, but we don't know that either way based on those statements.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by terribleperson on Sunday October 26, 2025 @12:44PM
(#45713240)
We can make assumptions, however.
The claims made by the document referred to in the article are potentially harmful to Amazon. If they were untrue and the truth painted Amazon in a better light, they would likely be willing to counter the article with information of their own.
That they instead respond with a total non-answer is a signal that either the document is accurate, or the truth is worse.
Re:Amazon strategised about keeping its datacentres' full wa...
by ETH_start on Sunday October 26, 2025 @12:41PM
(#45713206)
What would help is an analysis of second order benefits of having a data center, both for the locality and the nation at large. Any realistic analytical framework will acknowledge that all industry incurs some costs, but often still has a net beneficial impact on society due to the positive effect it has on income.
Yes, we do need the data centers, but people have a saying too.
Unfortunately companies tend to negotiate special deals. And for what? How many local people actually get jobs in a date centre? A few security guards, cleaners and gardeners?
I've seen these things they do everything remote and if that doesn't work they fly in a team.
Think of the airports. Do we need them? Absolutely. Do people have a say? Yes they do. And that's the problem: they will always say sure but not in my backyard. Obviously no one wants an airport nearby, that's understandable. So in the end expanding an airport (and thus economy) becomes basically impossible.
But in case of airport there is at least a clear case to make. DataCenters? Not so much. Laymen are unable to make an educated decisions here hence they will always vote no.
> “A document’s existence doesn’t guarantee its accuracy or finality,” she said. “Meetings often reshape documents or reveal flawed findings or claims.”
Here's a person trained to speak in half truths. Am I the only one to find this revolting? Please tell me I'm not alone.
Unfortunately, most of those people aren't elected.
Because their current water use is much higher?
("Strategy" is a meaningless word here.)
The claims made by the document referred to in the article are potentially harmful to Amazon. If they were untrue and the truth painted Amazon in a better light, they would likely be willing to counter the article with information of their own.
That they instead respond with a total non-answer is a signal that either the document is accurate, or the truth is worse.
Why arent these just closed systems?