News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by stevesimmons on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:44AM (#45536605)
Same for me...

I had been tracking Datastar for months, waiting for the 1.0.0 release.

But my enthusiasm for Datastar has now evaporated. I've been bitten by the open-source-but-not-really bait and switch too many times before.

Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by CuriouslyC on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:03AM (#45537968)
As someone who wants to write open source but needs to be able to capture some financial value from doing that to be able to make it sustainable, what model do you prefer?

My current thoughts lean towards a fully functional open source product with a HashiCorp style BSL and commercial licensing for teams above a size threshold.

Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by danryan on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:08AM (#45538006)
Sell support.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by 1dom on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:19AM (#45538675)
I can't imagine that works very well for relatively small, simple, functional or intuitive projects though. Incentives wise, is it possible to sell reverse support: extracting payment for all the times the product works so well that support isn't needed?
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by sudodevnull on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:57AM (#45539126)
That doesn't work. My day job is at scenario working on NATS and I can tell you 99.9% of people don't pay for support
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by CuriouslyC on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:07AM (#45539267)
As a NATS user, I can say that's mostly because it just works and when it doesn't it's pretty easy to figure out :)
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by sudodevnull on Friday October 10, 2025 @11:22AM (#45540050)
yep, and you'd think someone that has seen that would pick a different model... idk, ngmi
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by abirch on Friday October 10, 2025 @11:16AM (#45539985)
Selling support can be rough. I talked with the developer of PyMol.

Many corporations wouldn't buy licenses and those that would pay for support wanted support for hardware that was 2 or 3 generations old.

Gentle reminder: please encourage your corporation to pay for open source support whenever possible.

Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by mekoka on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:48AM (#45539709)
Some solo dev projects are used as a platform to sell books, training, ads, speaking engagement, consulting, and development.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by bdcravens on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:57AM (#45539805)
I think the open core model is fine, and the most financially sustainable. Just be up front about it from day 1. I don't think the honor system for licensing will get you the results you're wanting.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by zem on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:05PM (#45544343)
it depends strongly on why you want to write open source. if you like the idea of putting source code out into the world for other people to use and benefit from then go ahead and use whatever mix of open source and proprietary code you like, just be up front that that's what you are doing.

if you want to promise open source software simply to attract the mindshare and users who habitually ignore anything that isn't open source, trying to capture financial value may well be infeasible unless some rare confluence of stars lines up for you. the key is in the word "capture" - capturing the value implies making sure it goes to you rather than to someone else, and that means imposing restrictions that will simply piss those same users off.

Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by osigurdson on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:31AM (#45537672)
Maintainers need a way to maintain during the day - not just evenings and weekends. Otherwise it eventually dies.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by imjonse on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:13AM (#45538061)
Does HTMX have a pro version? Is it dead?
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by intrasight on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:58AM (#45538488)
Far from dead. Usage is growing.

HTMX is a single htmx.js file with like 4000 lines of pretty clearly written code.

It purports to - and I think succeeds - in adding a couple of missing hypermedia features to HTML.

It's not a "framework" - good

It's not serverside - good

Need to add a feature? Just edit htmx.js

Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by sgt on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:32AM (#45539551)
Some people will get a fit once they find out it's JS, and not TypeScript.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by zenmac on Saturday October 11, 2025 @07:59AM (#45548467)
No body is preventing them to write a layer of ts definition on top of the js. Check out postgres.js
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by sudodevnull on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:57AM (#45539138)
Yes look at the active issues on GitHub. There's hundreds and some going back years with no traction.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by yawaramin on Saturday October 11, 2025 @01:47AM (#45546908)
I don't think open issues is a fair way to judge project liveness. TypeScript also has hundreds of open issues going back years with no traction. Is TypeScript dead?
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by sudodevnull on Saturday October 11, 2025 @10:36AM (#45549482)
Yes, issues that are years old show me the commitment level. Not a knock against HTMX but a clear sign of priorities. Carson is free to meme all day and talk about other projects. It's very clear where he stands and that's fine
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by yawaramin on Saturday October 11, 2025 @11:48AM (#45550060)
It was a rhetorical question; the answer is no, old issues with no updates don't necessarily indicate anything about the health of the project. Different people have different project management styles. You use your style for your project, and Carson uses his for htmx. There's no one correct way to manage an issue backlog.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by ncruces on Saturday October 11, 2025 @06:47PM (#45553322)
My project is really healthy then, as I summarily close issues as “not planned” rather than leave them open.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by recursivedoubts on Sunday October 12, 2025 @09:12AM (#45558009)
this year I created and released fixi.js, created the montana mini computer (https://mtmc.cs.montana.edu), published an paper on hypermedia via the ACM, got hyperscript to 1.0, released 3 versions of htmx, reworked all the classes that I teach at montana state and am planning on releasing a java-based take on rails that I'm building for my web programming class

i am also the president of the local youth baseball program and helped get BigSkyDevCon over the hump

i think you'd be surprised at how little time i actually spend on twitter

Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by sudodevnull on Sunday October 12, 2025 @02:08PM (#45560366)
as always, my issue is never with how you spend your time. you are a giver of gifts and I wish more people that relied on HTMX stepped up to make it better. in no way should anything be expected of you. How you spend your time is obviously your call. MIT is MIT
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by osigurdson on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:21PM (#45543926)
It will be, eventually, unless a maintainer is able to maintain during the day. It doesn't matter what the source of free time is however: retired, rich, runs a company from their open source project, paid by somebody else, etc., but full time job + open source maintainer = dead project, eventually.
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by recursivedoubts on Sunday October 12, 2025 @08:41AM (#45557829)
htmx isn't dead, but, from a semantic stand point, it's pretty done:

https://htmx.org/essays/future/

there are bugs, but we have to trade off fixes against potentially breaking users sites that depend on (sometimes implicitly) the current behavior

this makes me very hesitant to make changes and accept PRs, but i also feel bad closing old issues without really diving deep into them

such is life in open source

Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by sudodevnull on Friday October 10, 2025 @11:21AM (#45540044)
source is MIT, do what you want. The team found certain plugins to be anti-patterns and support burdens. You can find the old plugins in the repo source, feel free to fork from there!
Re:I Switched from Htmx to Datastar by agos on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:04PM (#45543773)
Wait so you pay to use the anti patterns? That’s a new one.