How do you think this works in reality when the people getting sanctioned are trying to bypass the sanctions by creating shell companies and false identities? You either have a totally ineffective sanctions regime because it can be trivially be bypassed by setting up new shell companies, or a vaguely effective one because banks are deputized to figure out whether their customers are sanctioned or not. Luckily we have the latter.
I'm objecting to the notion that mega corp ad networks are the best organization to determine what is truth vs. propaganda in our society.
I've been criticized before for not fighting back. I had other struggles at the time. Leave me alone about that. I made the right call for myself.
Which is how we know that it's a trash fire that should be stamped out rather than causing it to spread.
Advertising is a commercial activity, so it should be reasonable to follow the money and find the advertiser. If necessary, add more requirements for advertisers to be identified/indetifiable so that suits can be served.
1. Section 230
Production cost of "content" approaches zero (it's outsourced to www users^FN1). Intermediaries interlope between www users, i.e., the producers and consumers, in order to dominate^FN2 and control distribution
Some have suggested the ads will become the "content". Consider "influencers"
https://www.digitalnewsreport.org/essays/2015/attitudes-to-a...
2. "Underegulated" programmatic, targeted advertising
No meaningful federal regulation
For example, proposals for "self-regulation" with no private right of action (compare with the direction Europe has taken regarding data collection)
https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/why-data-not-...
FN1. Or "AI" trained with the work of www users
FN2. Via anti-competitive conduct
The first pillar enables construction of the second. "Big Tech" could never produce its _own_ content sufficient to draw the traffic needed to yield the outsized returns that it does from "advertising services"
Perhaps a crack in either of these pillars might eventually lead to the downsizing of "Big Tech"
It doesn't seem like that big a step to apply a similar standard to advertising platforms. Advertisers have failed to selfregulate the ads they choose to publish and it is infeasible to use the court system to judicate every false ad (that would be millions of court cases). Ergo you do the obvious which is to make the advertiser name a human editor who holds legal responsibility for published ads (on behalf of the company).
Now you can sue the advertising company (eg. Google) for millions of false advertisements at once.
I can't sue a publisher for running an ad that was libel. I sue the advertiser who created the libel.
I assumed the US had something similar, but seems I was wrong.
However, our laws mean that Google, Meta, etc. are not legally responsible for the content of the ads they run. The creator of the ad is.
And it is shockingly easy to construct a legal entity that is unaccountable.
This would prevent foreign ads targeting domestic users, and/or give you an organization to sue domestically. In this case, it's likely that the Israeli govt would work through a US based org, and that in court that case would likely fail for free speech rights. Though a case/org in another nation might not hold up under that nation's laws.
The reality is that ads are the primary vehicle for malicious content, whether it be malware, scams, or deception, on the web.
Google, as well as Meta, has demonstrated they do not take adequate measure to block said malicious content. This can lead to tangible real effects, such as getting scammed and losing your life savings.
Therefore, every web user should use a strict ad blocker per FBI recommendations. This is no longer a business question or a free-speech question, it is a computer system security question.
In that context, what google chooses to allow and what they ban is newsworthy. In this specific case, even moreso, since the ads violate google’s own rules.
Google doesn't really want scam ads. It doesn't make a lot of sense to penalize them for removing some of them just because their process isn't perfect; removing them doesn't have to be banned.
But if you make not removing them mandatory, you're replacing the justice system with a private corporation, which is pretty crazy. If the police accuse you of a crime, they have to prove it to a judge and jury. You can appeal to a higher court. Google doesn't have that. And if you add liability for not removing something, they're going to err on the side of removing things they ought not to, with no recourse for the victims. Competitor wants you out of the search results? Report it to Google and you're out, because they get a billion complaints and removing them by default is safer than getting prosecuted for missing a real one.
The correct solution is to let Google remove things that are bad without punishing them for not being perfect -- maybe even err on the side of imposing (civil) liability for removing things they shouldn't instead of not removing things they should -- and rely on the criminal justice system for going after the criminals.
Forcing ad networks to be the main arbiters of what is true vs. propaganda is a huge step towards an Orwellian society.
* some policies related to the concept of truth are one dealing with scams or fraudsters. Even then, it's only the scope of "does this advertiser actually provide the service they claim to be" or not, which is way more objective than anything related to war, religion, or the middle east.
From the article:
> The ad mimicked a UN website but actually linked to an Israeli government page
You don't need to judge wether the information linked is true to judge whether the ad misrepresents what users will find behind the link. If Pepsi made ads using a fake Coca Cola website to redirect to pepsi products, they would run afoul of google's policy regardless of your opinion on Pepsi.
Whether you think this enforcement choice is legitimate or not, as you said, it's clearly an editorial choice from google, and there's no reason it should escape public scrutiny and, if needed, regulation.
* from my PoV, US history books taught in classrooms deny or downplay the genocide of native American people, so of which were my ancestors. But I don't want society to try and use mega corps to push my PoV.
This has been in place for as long the war has been going on.
It is really scary that people are pushing for Google and Meta to be the arbiter of truth. I don't think people realize what they are asking for. Western civilizations have a tradition of liberal free speech, and allowing the courts to sort out the specifics of what speech causes harm to what parties (libel, etc).
There are already laws on the books for false advertising. In the US, the FTC is one who prosecutes those laws, not Google or Meta!
full disclosure: I work on Ads at Google. You really don't want to privatize the prosecution, judgement, jury, and execution of speech laws to mega corps (and I am usually pro-privatization on most topics).