That said, I think rg is pretty well known to linux daily-drivers and they just wanted to share something quickly for powerusers who want to check their workspaces quickly. Probably better to just instruct n00bs to use grep than install a whole cli tool for searching
Come to think of it, I wonder if a 2-phase attack could be planned by an attacker in the future: Inject malware into a package, flood guidance with instructions to install another popular tool that you also recently compromised... lol
> Unfortunately, in the world of software there are bad actors that bundle malware with their apps. Even so, Homebrew Cask has long decided it will not be an active gatekeeper (macOS already has one) and users are expected to know about the software they are installing. This means we will not always remove casks that link to these apps, in part because there is no clear line between useful app, potentially unwanted program, and the different shades of malware—what is useful to one user may be seen as malicious by another.
---
So there might be pull requests, but Brew's official stance is that they do not actively moderate casks for malware. I guess there's something built into the MacOS packaging step that help mitigate the risk, but I don't know much about it outside playing w/ app development in XCode.
Like ... npm?
Everybody knows npm is a gaping security issue waiting to happen. Repeatedly.
It’s convenient, so it’s popular.
Many people also don’t vendor their own dependencies, which would slow down the spread at the price of not being instantly up to date.
npm sold it really hard that you could rely on them and not have to vendor dependencies yourself. If I suggested that a decade ago in Seattle, I would have gotten booed out of the room.
Yet here we are. And this is going to get massively worse, not better.
I mean, I believe you, but the person you are replying to obviously believes that they are similar. Could you explain the significant differences?
> Unfortunately, in the world of software there are bad actors that bundle malware with their apps. Even so, Homebrew Cask has long decided it will not be an active gatekeeper (macOS already has one) and users are expected to know about the software they are installing. This means we will not always remove casks that link to these apps, in part because there is no clear line between useful app, potentially unwanted program, and the different shades of malware—what is useful to one user may be seen as malicious by another.
It takes like 2 years to get up to date packages. This isn't NPM.
https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/understanding-red-hats-respon...
https://lists.debian.org/debian-security-announce/2024/msg00...
(I get that the same can be said for said for npm and the packages in question, but I don’t really see how the context of the thread matters in this case).