On iOS, you cannot install any apps without an Apple Account, and even some preinstalled apps (like Pages, Numbers, Keynote, GarageBand, iMovie) cannot be used before you assign them to an Apple Account.
On Android, you can install any app from any third-party store without having any accounts. There's a store called Aurora Store that even lets you install apps from Google's Play Store without an account as well, so, you can even install all the mainstream apps, all without any accounts.
Meanwhile, they protect vast amounts of your data with encryption, especially if you opt in to the most protection.
I don't have any wish to promote Apple, but those are not comparable. Even though I have hated Apple's closed App Store policy.
If they were playing fast and loose with cryptography and encryption, we'd have a lot more exploits in the open.
A zero day remote attack on an iOS device is worth so much money that you have to be _really_ ethical as a hacker not to sell it and report it to Apple for a small reward instead.
The last time one was deployed "publicly" was against Jeff Bezos (or his wife) - one of the top10 richest people in the world anyway. And then it was patched for everyone.
They don't need a 0 day to compromise your device, they can just choose to do it at any point. You're simply trusting they don't.
It’s kind of what they do.
Again, you're just trusting Apple not to do that. Please bear in mind that if the government asks, it's not like they have a choice.
Apple is the only one building stuff so that they can't fold, even if they wanted to.
You can turn on the extra protections and encryptions yourself at the cost of user experience.
Its not a user interface problem either, that's just a lame excuse. iMessage is end to end encrypted and is arguably one of the most pleasant to use messengers.
It's virtually impossible to sideload anything on an iOS device without extensive developer know-how; but for Apple itself to do a targetted attack, would be a trivial task.
Android is the privacy heaven by comparison.
It's relatively trivial to get started with F-Droid and Aurora Store, and then you can install whichever apps you need, without providing any identifying information system-wide, without needing anything beyond the Android device itself.
No PCs, no mandatory 0days, no exploits, no specific software/hardware requirements, no warez, no copyright infringement, just pure free software and a few warning dialogues from Google about the dangers of installing the third-party apps, before you can do whatever you wish with the hardware you paid for, on any Android device of any vendor.
While it is true that close to all companies will comply with lawful orders (but not EVERY company, FWIW: Lavabit famously shut down instead of handing over SSL keys to feds), it is possible to design systems in such a way as to protect FAR more user data privacy than Apple does. Case in point: review the contents of Signal's subpoena response a few years ago:
- https://signal.org/bigbrother/cd-california-grand-jury/
This isn't a sham privacy claim like the kind made by Apple that requires you to trust the provider, either. Signal's clients are famously open source - something Apple does not do for pretty much any part of iOS or Mac OS:
- https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android
- https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-iOS
- https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Desktop
Additionally, most of the Signal server's source code (nix the anti-spam components) is open source, as well as the libsignal library used across the clients and server alike:
- https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Desktop
- https://github.com/signalapp/libsignal
Apple could be this transparent if they wanted to. They choose not to be, because the truth is, they do not actually care about user privacy, they are constantly collecting massive amounts of telemetry, user data, and user metadata from every single device they make, and they have been proven to share this data extensively with the federal government via the Snowden leaks, even in spite of the few actions they take publicly to maintain the marketing illusion of being a company that cares about user privacy, such as in the wake of the San Bernardino shooting.
The TSA performs security theater, where they take the harder route, yet fail to even detect, let alone stop 95%+ of yesterday's threats, to say nothing of today's or tomorrow's threats:
- https://www.theverge.com/2015/6/1/8701741/tsa-screenings-hom...
Apple performs privacy theater, where they take the harder route, yet extensively log user data and share it with federal intelligence agencies:
- https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/06/us-tech-giants...
As for the deeper why: it's more important to the US government for passengers to feel safe than it is for passengers to actually be truly safe.
Likewise, it's more profitable for Apple to make its customers feel their data is private than it is for Apple to make their customers data actually be truly private.
Apple is not privacy-preserving company.
Apple is marketed as a privacy-preserving company.
Less than for an Android 0day then. Yes, it's quite telling.
An iOS 0day would be far more valuable, confirmed by the rest of the thread above.
The rest of the thread above is merely the delusions of an Apple fanboy, followed by dozens of people listing out reasons why an iPhone is more vulnerable to attacks, both from external actors _and_ from Apple collecting massive amounts of data and having total remote control of "your" device.
Which means that targetted attacks are trivial if the attacker possesses the resources.
I thought Google recently announced changes to this requiring a developer account to side load.
Hopefully, they'll see just how ineffective their measures are, and abandon before applying the plans to the rest of the world.
Why do we consider user installation of software abuse? Plenty of people install software from non-play repositories simply to prevent Google from getting data about their app profile.
I disagree that such protections (at the expense of the power users) are necessary, but, OTOH, you cannot just ignore such issue existing in the first place, because it does exist, and Google already does have the tools to combat it (by scanning all apps regardless of origin, and blocking malicious ones).
How did you decide that this one thing alone makes Apple's entire privacy approach far worse than Google's? Everything else doesn't matter anymore?
I can't really think of anything worse as far as privacy is concerned. Can you?
Also regarding the App Store, you don’t have to enter a credit card, you can make an account with a new email address.
Apple has really questionable security as well. There's lots of people who have reported Apple randomly asking for Apple Account passwords all of a sudden in popups, on both iOS and macOS, the same way as malware would; or forcing password resets every day or every week.
BTW, do you know how many customer accounts did Apple terminate in 2024? It's 128'961'839 — nearly 129 million customer accounts terminated in just one year.
I don't think they even need to do that. They are in control of the encryption process and obviously already process the data to create a persona of the user (after which it is no longer considered "user data")
If Apple never decrypts a user's data, then this debate will never resolve, because there will always be people who insist that Apple's teetering on the precipice of logging decryption keys and decrypting a user's data – or worse, that they've already done it and we're just waiting for another heroic whistleblower to reveal their corruption.
> Remember, Apple is the same company that cooperated with the NSA to secretly log and feed user data to the NSA starting back in 2012, as revealed by Snowden's heroic disclosure of the PRISM program (which was ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge).
PRISM compelled Apple to provide the NSA with access to cloud data they already held under FISA orders. Apple was not installing spyware on people's devices as you seem to be implying.
Cloud data that's supposedly encrypted with encryption keys Apple pinky promises they don't have, right?
>Apple was not installing spyware on people's devices as you seem to be implying. I am very clearly not implying this is currently happening - just that there is nothing theoretically preventing this from happening, and the company already has a history of secretly cooperating with illegal government surveillance programs to provide cleartext user data - user data that they love to present an image of protecting vigorously.
Remember, Apple is the same company that cooperated with the NSA to secretly log and feed user data to the NSA starting back in 2012, as revealed by Snowden's heroic disclosure of the PRISM program (which was ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge).
Apple's privacy-protecting image is nothing more than marketing.