And yeah pretty much. I don’t know anything about anything but it feels like there is a hierarchy (norm? At least what they are trying to enforce) of US > Five Eyes > other Western Intel (France, etc) > Pakistan/Russia/Etc > China/North Korea/Iran; and Israel falls somewhere in that mix as a maverick. Of course in practice it doesn’t work out this way.
Reminds me of the recent news that the US will ban Chinese components from undersea cables, globally: https://asia.nikkei.com/content/99550c9ade243fe057e8a2ba6f29...
Imagine if there were movements in Switzerland to move to certain areas to push out the speakers of some local dialect, and literally organized home-buying in groups to get them out?
Objecting to calling Israel the west is at least as weird as including it in the context of this conversation.
It's a tilted west.
Look, I know it's cultural much more than geographical. But Australia can easily be both. It's not actually a counterexample.
What are we even talking about anymore? This sub thread is a weird digression on if it’s normal to include Israel in the phrase “western intelligence”. The US collaborates more with 5 eyes nations (2 of which are is the South Pacific) and Israel, be it Mossad or Unit 8200 than it does with France.
My contention is that the phrase Western Intelligence is a cultural signifier that has nothing to do with geography. And that pointing out that Israel is not in the west (while not doing the same for New Zealand) is more strange than including them by default.
The cultural qualifier you speak of is only in the sense that how Israel operates mimics how America and Australia operated in the 1800s, except with 21st century weapons. Like colonial America, Israel is a religious ethnostate, controlling territories where millions have no voting or citizenship rights, whose land can be taken by force and freely offered to settlers that fit the desired characteristics of the ethnostate.
The west's relationship with Israel is largely the same approach it had for apartheid South Africa, military support for which only declined once the Soviet Union's threat to the western order faded.
"There's a thought among the public that if you don't work in a sensitive area that the PRC might be interested in for its traditional espionage activities, then you are safe, they will not target you," [deputy assistant director for the FBI's cyber division] said, during a Thursday interview with The Register. "As we have seen from Salt Typhoon, this is no longer an assumption that anyone can afford to make."(Some high value people do seem to be targeted for even more intensive spying.)
What norms are he referring to?