News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by llbbdd on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:36AM (#44872456)
They should just do the same thing many governments the world over have done - adopt a version of the US constitution. Easy, clean, and only massively ironic.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by gargan on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:18AM (#44873014)
Biggest mistake the Americans did was codify their constitution. I'll probably be pilloried for that but look at the evidence:

- US is about to have military on the streets during peacetime with no terror threat within a codified constitution

- UK has had military on the streets in response to terrorism in Northern Ireland (a real threat) and not for decades. The UK constitution is uncodified and spread over many (10+?) documents ranging from Magna Carta in the 1200s to the Bill of Rights in the 1600s to documents written in the 1800s and then more modern Acts of Parliament.

Importantly the UK constitution can slowly change which means the UK has never had a revolution and never will do. Whereas the US constitution is rigid which achieves the opposite: when it does change it'll be dramatic and as a result of another violent revolution.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by danlitt on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:14AM (#44873307)
Why do you think that the UK having an unwritten constitution means that revolution cannot happen? Of course putting aside the fact we did have a revolution in the 1600s, and the almost constant revolution happening in Ireland until the 1930s. A fluid constitution is no use when the government is intransigent, and very little can protect a democracy from half the voters voting for a coup.

A written constitution only really protects (or affects at all) the things it very specifically enumerates. And when I look at the judicial tools we have that do bind the government (the ECHR for instance) they seem on the whole to make a good difference. A UK constitution that enshrined certain rights (healthcare, free speech, and so on) would make me feel a lot more secure about what future governments could do. It might also provide a better example than the American constitution in the respects it is lacking.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by gargan on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:53AM (#44873948)
The revolution in the 1600s was reversed - as far as I know the UK is the only country in the world to have reversed a revolution.

If you want more healthcare security you're more likely to get that in an uncodified system like the UK. Yes your healthcare rights can be reversed but better that, than never happening at all like in the US.

A codified system also hands vast power to lawyers. The US is a lawyer's paradise of everyone suing everyone, rising political violence due to inflexibility, and more risk of revolution.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by danlitt on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:01PM (#44881775)
> Yes your healthcare rights can be reversed but better that, than never happening at all like in the US.

Do you really think that the thing standing in the way of universal healthcare in the US is its codified constitution? When I look at the constitutional cases that result in lawsuits in the US, they are almost universally cases that move the dial in favour of people's freedoms. Liberally interpreted, the US has been dragged, kicking and screaming, into the 21st century in many respects. The undermining of civil liberties we see in the US right now are in spite of the constitution, not because of it (and you can tell, because everyone opposing it is appealing to the constitution, and everyone supporting the coup is ignoring it).

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by juniperus on Saturday August 16, 2025 @02:23AM (#44920736)
only country to reverse a revolution? uhh, that's almost like a required stage of every revolution, haha. it's almost more remarkable when a revolution sticks.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by pastage on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:15AM (#44873319)
While the US consitition is not agile a like a git log of a popular js project it does have over 10k declined PRs, I think the record is 100 years waiting for review. It does change, it has to change.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by DaiPlusPlus on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:20AM (#44873735)
If it were a public repo it would have been forked a long time ago.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by 3acctforcom on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:41PM (#44880215)
It was, repeatedly. It's a very important historical document that defined negative rights (congress shall pass no law) and inspired most modern constitutions.

The problem is the US never bothered to address it's technical debt, so it's patch on patch on patch. An updated constitution would probably cut through a lot of the bullshit in American politics, e.g. the interstate commerce clause being the entire justification for the federal government lol.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Saline9515 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:44AM (#44873133)
Political systems do not exist in a vacuum, but integrate into a specific ethnic, cultural and geographic landscape. In a nation of immigrants with frequent demographic changes, having a written constitution anchors the country and prevents some capture of the government.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by gargan on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:59AM (#44873217)
The UK and US are both equally nations of immigrants in 2025 at about 16% of the population being born abroad. The UK constitution is written but uncodified and unites the country under the King. The constitution can slowly change to deal with immigration, but in the US they're stuck with either what you have or violent revolution...
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Saline9515 on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @11:32AM (#44889798)
I was referring to when the political systems were set in place. When the UK became a parliamentary monarchy, no one could dream of becoming "a nation of immigrants," while in the case of the US, it was obvious that it was and would be for the next century, at least.

The US political regime was designed for stability by lawyers, which has worked quite well for the country so far. In the case of the UK, the lack of a constitution can also be quite dangerous as it allows abuse and doesn't guarantee any protection of basic rights or even democracy. This can work well if the country is mono-ethnic, with elites and plebeians sharing a common culture. It can also easily derail in pluri-cultural settings where ethnicities compete against each other to impose their standards or acquire resources from the state. This is what happens in Africa, for instance, and one of the reasons for the weakness of the state there.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mlindner on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:13AM (#44873301)
> - US is about to have military on the streets during peacetime with no terror threat within a codified constitution

I think you'll find that this doesn't happen, just like every other extreme prediction that people have made about this administration. At this point the media has extreme "boy who cried wolf" syndrome regarding this administration, but they don't seem to care.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by ceejayoz on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:39AM (#44873857)
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mlindner on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @06:30AM (#44886714)
It didn't happen in LA though. They were put around federal buildings to protect them, not in the streets. The ones in the streets were the LA police.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by diordiderot on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:40AM (#44875488)
You can amend the constitution. Its been done many times
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by vkou on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:10AM (#44872973)
The US constitution that's clear as mud about questions like "Is it possible for the president to do something illegal?" and "Does any part of the 14th amendment actually mean anything"?

That US constitution?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by clarionbell on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:28AM (#44873399)
Constitution is pretty clear on that question. The problem is that in order to persecute president you need congress to act.

The constitution simply doesn't account for a situation, when congress willingly ceases vital functions. To be fair, it took over 200 years for this edge case to occur.

If this was a software we would marvel at its stability.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by foldr on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:30AM (#44873802)
200 years isn’t a very long time in British historical terms.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by vkou on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:02AM (#44873995)
> Constitution is pretty clear on that question.

Given that all three branches of government seems to be moving in lockstep on it, (with the military, the secret police, and the police all behind them), you are right - it is clear on that question.

It's clear to all them that, no, anything he does goes, and no, the 14th doesn't actually mean anything.

That's not how I parse it from a cursory reading, but who am I to nay-say the king?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by bratbag on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:20AM (#44875318)
Pass.

Im glad not to be confined by historical rules invented by people who could not hope to predict the future, and would not choose to put that kind of burden on my descendents.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by diordiderot on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:39AM (#44875475)
Amendments can be made with a super-majority's approval