News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by brudgers on Thursday September 06, 2012 @10:13AM (#4484184)
A willingness to apologize is one feature of companies which treat the B2C market as if it were B2B. It's been a core of principle of Microsoft (e.g. their fixing of the Xbox's Red Ring of Death). Compare this with Apple's "Hold Differently" in regard to the iPhone 4 or their simply ignoring the manipulation of the Star Trek and sending the New York Times flash animation down the memory hole in regards to the iPad.

Nokia doing so in this case shows why there is such potential for their partnership with Microsoft over the long term. Both companies have similar approaches to the consumer market.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by podperson on Thursday September 06, 2012 @10:33AM (#4484269)
Microsoft denied the red ring of death problem for months:

"In the early months after the console's launching, Microsoft stated that the Xbox 360's failure rate was within the consumer electronics industry's typical 3% to 5%."

Third parties have determined it was somewhere between 20 and 40%.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xbox_360_technical_problems

Apple responded to "antennagate" within two weeks iirc.

As for Nokia: they faked the stills and video, got caught on the video and confessed. But it turns out they faked the stills too:

http://sefsar.com/nokia-faked-the-still-photos-too

If Nokia were such a great company they would have come clean all at once.

I can't find a link, but I remember hilarious comparisons of earlier Nokia demo videos to the actual devices, so it's not like this is something Nokia (a) just started doing or (b) just accidentally did this once.

All this does is reflect very well on Apple by comparison.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by sliverstorm on Thursday September 06, 2012 @11:39AM (#4484575)
The antenna problem can be clearly demonstrated by anybody with that model iPhone, a finger, and a few minutes.

The RRoD cannot be clearly demonstrated in a few minutes. Presumably Microsoft needed to carefully verify these claims by studying the market and reported failure rates before acknowledging it publicly.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by podperson on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:36PM (#4484943)
I have an iPhone 4 (which I pre-ordered) and as soon as I read about antennagate I spent quite a bit of time trying to replicate it and could not.

If you're selling tens of thousands of a product with a high brick rate you will have very good stats very quickly.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by 89a on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:13PM (#4484809)
> The antenna problem can be clearly demonstrated by anybody with any phone, a finger, and a few minutes.

FTFY

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by luser001 on Thursday September 06, 2012 @01:17PM (#4485160)
AFAIK the root cause of the iPhone 4 problem is due to closing the loop of the antenna using your finger to complete the loop (converting the metal from a line into a circle, thereby degrading its antenna characteristics).

You should be able to do this only on phones which have an external unsheathed antenna. Which other ones are there?

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by X-Istence on Thursday September 06, 2012 @03:15PM (#4485704)
I had an older Nokia phone that had the antenna near the bottom of the device (to keep it away from your head), and when you had your hand on the device like you would hold an iPhone (fingers on one side, thumb on the other side) you would lose signal strength rapidly.

The same issue was evident in various blackberry devices.

Unfortunately the human body simply is a fantastic sink for RF frequency do the fact that we are mostly made out of water and salt. Yes, the iPhone is simpler in that it allows you to close the loop, but the issue can be found in multiple phones.

Sheathing or no sheathing, humans are hard to transmit through.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by M4v3R on Thursday September 06, 2012 @11:11AM (#4484448)
Here's the video (Nokia N97 ad with commentary): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJpEuMidcSU&feature=youtu...
Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by coob on Thursday September 06, 2012 @10:19AM (#4484212)
"Hold Differently" is a gross misrepresentation of the iPhone 4 antenna issue.

What actually happened: A full fledged press conference by the CEO himself basically saying: "This happens to all smartphones, we made it worse by marking the spot, we think performance is still acceptable but if you don't, here have a free bumper as it reduces the problem".

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by Karunamon on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:07PM (#4484771)
here have a free bumper as it reduces the problem

That's a huge oversimplification. The free bumpers didn't go out until the outrage level became too much to ignore.

And at first, it was ignored, or at the very least handwaved with "stop holding it that way". I very vividly remember the videos on Apple's site which showed signal degradation of competing smartphones when held a certain way.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by moe on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:06PM (#4484758)
What actually happened: We did no wrong ... but here have a free bumper

And of course this all happened out of pure love and altruism from Apple. Not like it had anything to do with a class action lawsuit or something...

http://news.cnet.com/8301-27076_3-57380685-248/settlement-re...

Looks like the reality distortion field is still going strong, even post-Steve.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by Cushman on Thursday September 06, 2012 @01:04PM (#4485095)
Maybe this is a stupid question, but what does a lawsuit settled in 2012 have to do with an announcement made in 2010?
Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by moe on Thursday September 06, 2012 @03:39PM (#4485811)
The outcome was predictable when it started. Apple's "full fledged keynote" was a maneuver to deflect PR damage.

And obviously they succeeded; Many people know about the keynote but don't know that it was an attempt to pre-empt a lawsuit.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by brudgers on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:10PM (#4484790)
However, "Hold Differently" is a close approximation of Apple's initial response (via leaked email). It was only after continued pressure from consumers and in the tech press that Apple acknowledged the issue and took steps to make their customers whole.

In Nokia's case, they quickly apologized for something which didn't affect anyone.

Re:Nokia apologises for 'faked' Lumia smartphone advert by thmzlt on Thursday September 06, 2012 @10:59AM (#4484390)
"we produced a video that simulates what we will be able to deliver with OIS"

So I'm going to build a crappy car, demo it using a Ferrari engine and tell I was trying to simulate the engine feature in my car. Doesn't sound like an apology to me.