Japan: 20%
China: 20%
India: 13%
UK: 24%
Italy: 26%
Germany: 26%
France: 30%
Then there's Canada of course... 50% with a proposal to make it 66% in 2026. Let's see how that works out!
https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/questions-and-answers-on-the-ne...
Edit: unautocorrect
As happens in any market with limited supply, which generally means desirable land and luxury goods.
Why can't they tax something that _cant_ be moved elsewhere, like property ownership?
1. Because any tax has to be politically palatable to voters, so therefore needs to exclusively target non-voters.
2. Because even if the above is satisfied, there are a large number of voters whose livelihoods are catering to non-voters.
but in general the US tax rate on the middle class is low compared to Europe
Nothing at all supports that "the rich move their wealth somewhere else"
Lack of housing because it's a profitable investment class that rises in value due to lack of supply? Obviously it's the fault of NIMBYs alone and not political policy pushed by lobbying groups.
Healthcare too expensive? Totally not the fault of private equity bleeding care networks dry and public health insurance companies denying coverage to fund share buybacks and CEO raises, so it must be nurses striking for pay or the government for paying too little on Medicare.
The point is that if enough rich countries said "fuck this shit, pay up and fuck off out of politics forever", the rich can't leave. They're stuck here, on Earth, with the poors. That's not going to change anytime soon, so the only thing stopping these countries from reigning the issue in is cowardice.
Penalized by group action against defectors.
Which is to say something like this should come from the WTO, or not at all.
Anything less has too great incentives for defection.
But do you have actual evidence that we need it? (Instead of just "nice to have".) Because everybody just repeats that without evidence, like the OP.
There are plenty of reasons to expect the OP's prediction not to hold. I don't know how things play out in practice, and I don't think I've ever seen anybody that knows it.
Also your UK link does not support your argument:
> Weaker-than-expected tax liabilities from additional rate taxpayers are not necessarily an indicator of an unexpectedly low yield from the 50p rate. Incomes for those earning above £150,000 could be depressed for other reasons. For example, high income earners are more likely to derive a higher proportion of income from savings, dividends and other investments – and these have been much weaker in recent years than employment income.
a tax credit of more than 130K USD ... for most expats this seems like completely negating their US taxe burden, no?
Sure you can move cash away but even that can be taxed with an 'exit' tax.
The only reason it doesn't work is because the will is not there to make it:
1. Unexpected
2. With no baked in loopholes
Come to our country - have our police and courts and soldiers protect you wealth - all for free.
Oh - and because you are not paying tax - can I borrow some of that wealth please so I can pay for the stuff I'm providing for you free - I'll give you a healthy return.
The rich benefit the most from civilisation - and it costs - you can't just keep running from country to country hollowing it out for ever - eventually there will be nowhere left you can free ride.
Oh and in terms of the charts where you increase a particular tax and revenue goes up in the short term and down later - that's because people adapt - they find new ways to avoid tax ( yep including to pretend to have left the country ).
Just bwcause they run, that's not a reason to stop pursing them.
Better then nothing
Or in the case of Abramovich - allegedly create a whole circular set of sham companies to avoid paying VAT on your super yacht.
See https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2025-06-19/cyp...
You've fallen victim to the false dichotomy. I don't see anyone argue the wealthy shouldn't pay any tax at all.
This renders the 2nd paragraph wrong. And then 3rd paragraph wrong too.
> you can't just keep running from country to country hollowing it out for ever - eventually there will be nowhere left you can free ride.
Depends how much time it takes to run from one country to another, and what you mean by "for ever" - if it takes you a year to move from one country to another and you live for 100 years, you need 100 countries. Pardon my humorous remark, I know this is not the point; but the actual argument is easier to counter: we don't have a single government for the Earth. We don't have a united dominating force to unify taxes in one civilization and sanction or isolate from the other civilizations for hosting the rich.
IMO the education is poor, producing stupid societies electing the governments which are incompetent, corrupt and largely sympathizing with the rich.
And sure - while you could move from one country to another like a parasite finding a new host, and cycle around as the original host recovers - the key questions is whether that results in a few people owning more and more as a result, and paying a lower and lower marginal rate until civilisation collapses. ( or the rich decide to take the rains of power instead to keep the society they benefit from so hugely afloat ).
> IMO the education is poor, producing stupid societies electing the governments which are incompetent, corrupt and largely sympathizing with the rich.
I think you underestimate the level to which the rich judicously share their wealth in order to influence people and policy.
But besides raising capital, taxation reduces wealth inequality, which is itself beneficial as it makes society more democratic. Reducing wealth inequality reduces the concentration of power, which is better for everyone (except for the 1%).
Still, when redistributing wealth, it’s prudent to address the risk of capital flight. It’s not an insurmountable challenge. Policy can address it through: 1) financial controls 2) coordinated international efforts to raise taxes on the wealthy, and 3) harsher measures like nationalization and capital levies.
Yes, the results are always the same: Europe consistently runs lower budget deficits, yet provides greater benefits to their citizens. How awful for them.
https://www.cato.org/blog/spending-debt-oecd
https://oecdstatistics.blog/2023/02/02/sizing-up-welfare-sta...
France: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/dec/31/france-drops-7...
UK: https://obr.uk/box/effect-of-the-additional-rate-of-income-t...
Sweden: https://eml.berkeley.edu/~saez/course/seimAEJ17wealth.pdf
It's interesting to note that even when these tax schemes were repealed, the damage had already been done and the wealth did not return.
Here's a real plan for America:
Step 1: have a tax rate that's a little less than our peers
Step 2: return spending to pre-Covid rates circa 2019