News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by andsoitis on Friday August 01, 2025 @10:37AM (#44757420)
it turns out that AI at this level is very expensive to run (capex, energy). my bet is that AI itself won't figure out how to overcome these constraints and reach escape velocity.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by crowcroft on Friday August 01, 2025 @10:42AM (#44757500)
Mainframes are the only viable way to build computers. Micro processors will never figure out how to get small and fast enough for personal computers to reach escape velocity.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by andsoitis on Friday August 01, 2025 @11:21AM (#44758162)
Why do you think the analogy hold?
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by suddenlybananas on Friday August 01, 2025 @11:40AM (#44758442)
Well it's an analogy, that's a water-tight argument.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by crowcroft on Friday August 01, 2025 @02:48PM (#44760810)
Hardware typically gets faster and cheaper over time. Unless we hit hard a wall because of physics then I don't see any reason that won't continue to be true.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by ben_w on Saturday August 02, 2025 @06:50AM (#44766497)
The factories to make the better chips are themselves increasingly expensive; this is acceptable when their cost of construction can be amortised over more devices, but we're already at the point where the global poor get smartphones before safe water, so further factory cost increases can't really be assumed to be amortised better.

That said, current LLMs are not compute constrained, they're RAM and bandwidth constrained, so a (relatively) cheap factory that's dedicated just to filling a datacenter with hardware designed specifically for one particular AI architecture, that's something I think is plausible. As @tome accidentally reminded me about recently, the not-Musk Groq (https://groq.com/) is all about this.

Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by twobitshifter on Friday August 01, 2025 @12:26PM (#44759054)
our minds are incredibly energy efficient, that leads me to believe it is possible to figure out, but it might be a human rather than an AI that gives us something more akin to a biological solution.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by klabb3 on Friday August 01, 2025 @02:48PM (#44760815)
This could fix my main gripe with The Matrix. ”Humans are used as batteries” always felt off, but it totally would make sense if the human brains have uniquely energy efficient pattern matching abilities that an emerging AI organism would harvest. That would also strengthen the spiritual humanist subtext.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by Kon5ole on Friday August 01, 2025 @03:19PM (#44761185)
That bugged me too! I decided that they actually meant "source of creativity" which made more sense.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by Melatonic on Friday August 01, 2025 @05:00PM (#44762443)
Thats because the original script did actually have the human farms being used for brainpower for the machines. They changed it to "batteries" because they thought audiences at the time wouldnt understand it!
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by klabb3 on Saturday August 02, 2025 @03:19AM (#44765461)
Wow, TIL. That strengthens my perception of the masterpiece. Thanks
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by int_19h on Friday August 01, 2025 @03:44PM (#44761498)
Perhaps this will be the incentive to finally get fusion working. Big tech megacorps are flush with cash and could fund this research many times over at current rates. E.g. NIF is several billion dollars; Google alone has almost $100B in the bank.
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by petesergeant on Saturday August 02, 2025 @12:00AM (#44764810)
> it turns out that AI at this level is very expensive to run (capex, energy)

If it's CapEx it's -- by definition -- not a cost to run. Energy costs will trend to zero.

Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by nasseri on Saturday August 02, 2025 @12:46AM (#44764964)
Why will energy costs trend to zero?
Re:Try Deep Think in the Gemini App by petesergeant on Saturday August 02, 2025 @01:02AM (#44765004)
Renewables will keep getting more efficient and cheaper to install, batteries will continue to get cheaper, at some point they'll crack fusion. Prices go negative or zero in several places already (West Texas wind energy overnight, solar in Chile). The question seems less "when will we get abundant, virtually free clean energy" and more "will we do it in time to avoid climate collapse".