News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by jillesvangurp on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:51AM (#44708345)
That's a misconception about military aid. That money is flowing straight back to US defense companies. It's not actually costing the US; it's profiting from this. And it's not actually tax payer money but freshly minted dollars that are created through debt. Nobody is getting taxed "extra" to pay for all this.

If you strip away all the moralism and suffering, the conflicts (plural) in the middle east and increasingly Ukraine are all about keeping the defense industry and the economy going. Same with Ukraine. Same with just about any other conflict where countries like the US supply the weapons.

Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by ozgrakkurt on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:55AM (#44708381)
You mean they are funneling their citizens’ money into some private corporations, and killing a decent number of children while doing it?

Edit: they are helping to kill the children, they are not doing it themselves

Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by rlt on Monday July 28, 2025 @04:04AM (#44708442)
> And it's not actually tax payer money but freshly minted dollars that are created through debt

Minting dollars is a form of taxation (albeit one partially paid by foreign entities that hold dollars)

Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by burnt-resistor on Monday July 28, 2025 @04:03AM (#44708438)
Doesn't change the end result, but it paints a moral dimension on those who actively profit from the deaths of imprisoned civilians. The money goes into the pockets of the owners of mostly American defense contractors' owners, arms leave for conflict zones, and mostly civilians where Gaza is concerned. Conflating Ukraine with Gaza is genocide-denial gaslighting.
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by simonh on Monday July 28, 2025 @05:51AM (#44709085)
This is the US devoting resources to do one thing, build things go bang abroad, instead of doing other things like building/renewing infrastructure or providing services to citizens. So, that is a cost. The question is what are the benefits. In Ukraine I can see that, in Israel it’s got a lot more messy.
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by cherryteastain on Monday July 28, 2025 @06:55AM (#44709505)
Nonsense. If the US instead just ordered $24B of military equipment and gave it to Israel would you still be calling it 'not a donation'? The two are equivalent.
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by _rm on Monday July 28, 2025 @09:08AM (#44710514)
That's some top tier clown economics.

Do you think the labor and resources that went into creating that materiel would vanish if it wasn't created? Like a missile is magic and conjures engineers and metal into existence just to fulfil its creation?

Oh and in fact leaves a little left over, the "profit", because thankyou for giving it some schools to obliterate?

What would we do if we weren't blowing people to bits huh, building theme parks or something instead - oh the waste! Think of the ~slaughter~... ahem, I mean the "economy"!

Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m by red-iron-pine on Monday July 28, 2025 @09:58AM (#44710938)
the profit was made by defense contractors when it was built. and flows as wages to the workers in GA / VA / wherever building it.

what happens after it's made is a function of utility. lotta waste, but if a 2 million missile can trash 4 million in buildings, cars, and humans, then it is still a win, even if there is no profit.