Or using Bluetooth? Or using local WiFi (direct or not).
If both machines have an Ethernet port.
> Or using Bluetooth?
Half the time I need a dumb pipe, it's from personal to work. Regrettably, work forces me to use macOS, and macOS's bluetooth implementation is just an utter tire fire, and doesn't work 90% of the time. I usually fall back to networks, for that reason.
Of course, MBPs also have the "no port" problem above.
> Or using local WiFi (direct or not)
If I'm home, yeah. But TFA is advertising the ability to hole-punch, and if I'm traveling, that'd be an advantage.
It looks like MS also had one, but only on Windows CE for some reason https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=933...
This dumb pipe thing is certainly interesting but it will run into the same problem as the myriad other solutions that already exist. If you're trying to give a 50MB file to a Windows user they have no way to receive it via any method a Linux user would have to send it unless the Windows user has gone out of their way to install something most people have never heard of.
If this was a real thing you needed to do, and it is too much work to get them to install WSL, you could probably just send them the link to install Git and use git bash to run that curl install sh script for dumbpipe.
And if this seemed like a very useful thing, it couldn’t be too hard to package this all up into a little utility that gets windows to do it.
But alas, it remains “easier” to do this with email or a cloud service or a usb stick/sd card.
I guess now you can find the solution that you need by telling the requirements to LLMs who have now indexed a lot of the tradeoffs
If we put the requirements of,
1. E2EE
2. Does not rely on Google. (Or ideally, any other for profit corporation.)
That eliminates like 90% of the recent trend of WebRTC P2P file transfer things that have graced HN over the last decade, as all WebRTC code seems to just copy Google's STUN/TURN servers between each other.But as you say,
> but certain people don't want that problem to ever be solved without cloud services involved.
ISPs seem to be that in set. IPv6 would obsolete NAT, but my ISP was kind enough to ship an IPv6 firewall that by default drops incoming packets. It has four modes: drop everything, drop all inbound, a weird intermediate mode that is useless¹, and allow everything.
(¹this is Verizon fios; they claim, "This feature enables "outside-to-inside" access for IPv6 services so that an "outside" Internet service (gaming, video, etc.) can access a specific "inside" home client device & port in your local area network."; but the feature, AFAICT, requires the external peer's address. I.e., I need to know what my roaming IP will be before I leave the house, somehow, and that's obviously impossible. It seems utterly clearly slapped on to say "it comes with a firewall" but was never used by anyone at Verizon in the real world prior to shipping…)
My starlink is such that i cannot install/set up things like pfsense/opnsense because the connection drops sometimes, and when either of those installers fail, they fail all the way back to "format the drive y/n?" Also, things like ipcop and monowall et al don't seem to support ipv6.
I looked in to managing ipv6 from a "i am making my own router" and no OS makes this simple. i tried with debian, and could not get it to route any packets. I literally wrote the guide for using a VM for ipcop and one of the "wall" distros; but something about ipv6 just evades me.
If you've not got an Internet[-routable] address, are you truly connected to the Internet?
> I looked in to managing ipv6 from a "i am making my own router" and no OS makes this simple. i tried with debian, and could not get it to route any packets. I literally wrote the guide for using a VM for ipcop and one of the "wall" distros; but something about ipv6 just evades me.
TBH, I would think that this is just enabling v6 forwarding. That wouldn't do RA or DHCP, I don't think, but I don't think you'd want that, either. (That would be the responsibility of the upstream network.)
# On the upstream network.
[Network]
DHCP=yes
[DHCPv6]
PrefixDelegationHint=::/56
# On each downstream network.
[Network]
IPv6SendRA=yes
DHCPPrefixDelegation=yes
If you don't want systemd-networkd, look at https://wiki.debian.org/IPv6PrefixDelegation#Using_ifupdown_.... Firewalling is the same as v4, just without the NAT.One frustrating part is that as far as I can tell nothing supports easy downstream DHCPv6-PD delegation, so machines on the downstream network that want their own prefix won't be able to get one automatically. OpenWRT's network config daemon supports it, but nothing on regular Linux does.
> however many /64s that is (at least 8);
256!
The use-case of a wired connection between two PCs was already solved years before USB --- with Ethernet.
You only get Link-Local addresses by default, which I recall as somewhat annoying if you want to use SSH or whatever, but if you have something that does network discovery it should probably work pretty seamlessly.
See https://christian.kellner.me/2018/05/24/thunderbolt-networki... or https://superuser.com/a/1784608
The same thing happens with two machines connected via an Ethernet cable, which appears to be what this USB4 network feature does - an Ethernet NIC to software, but with different lower layer protocols.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medium-dependent_interface#Aut...
ssh fe80::2%eth0
where fe80::2 is the peer's address, and eth0 is the local name of the interface they're on.Unfortunately browsers have decided that link-local is pointless and refuse to support it, so HTTP is much more difficult.
After TCP/IP became standard on personal computers, I used Ethernet crossover cable to transfer large files between compuers. I always have some non-networked computers. USB sticks were not yet available.
Today the Ethernet port is removed from many personal computers perhaps in hopes computer owners will send ("sync") their files to third party computers on the internet (renamed "the cloud") as a means of transferring files between the owner's computers.
Much has changed over the years. Expect replies about those changes. There are many, many different ways to transfer files today. Expect comments advocating those other methods. But the crossover cable method still works. With a USB-to-Ethernet adapter it can work even on computers with no Ethernet port. No special software is needed. No router is needed. No internet is needed. Certainly no third party is needed. Just TCP/IP which is still a standard.
Pretty sure one can set up an ad hoc wifi network for this.
Ad hoc requires the machines be in "WiFi shouting range".
macOS does not have any offline documentation like pretty much every OS used to. When I turn off my WiFi and then open "Mac User Guide" or "Tips for your Mac", they both tell me they require an internet connection.
When I re-enable my internet connection, neither of those apps have information about how to set up an ad-hoc wifi network.
When I looked up how to create an ad-hoc network in other sources, I discovered that the ability to create an ad-hoc network was apparently removed from the GUI in macOS 11, and now requires CLI commands.
I hate how modern tech companies assume that everybody always has access to a high speed internet connection.
I suspect it's deliberate, especially when said company also sells cloud services.
Perhaps that's mea culpa, and I suppose perhaps I should try NM again, but I also sort of thought this wouldn't be rocket science, until I tried to do it and failed.
I’m not buying it.
They have normal, consumer OSes on them. Whatever one might reasonably already have preinstalled.
I'm sitting at an macOS machine presently. If I poke around the Wi-Fi menu, and the Wi-Fi settings … IDK, I come up empty handed.
So let's cheat, and Google it. But the entire point of my post above is that needing to Google it defeats the point; if I have an Internet connection (which would be required to Google something) — I can just network the various machines using that Internet connection. In every situation I've wanted to form an ad hoc network, it is because I do not have any access to the Internet, period, but I still have the need to network two machines together.
Anyways, Gemini's answer:
> To set up an ad-hoc Wi-Fi network on macOS, you can use the "Create Network" option in the Wi-Fi menu.
Apparent hallucination, since there is no such menu item.
The first result says the same thing:
> 1. Click the wifi icon on the menu bar. 2. Click “Create network. . .”
(… I suppose I see where the training data came from).
The next result is a reddit thread; the thread is specifically about ad hoc WiFi. The only answer is a link to a macOS support article; that article tells us to go to General → Sharing, and use "Internet Sharing". But AFAICT, that's for sharing an existing WiFi connection over a secondardy medium: i.e., if you have WiFi, you could share that connection over a TB cable, or some other wired medium. And "To Devices Using" conspicuously lacks "also over WiFi", or similar. I.e., this also isn't what we're looking for.
The rest of the results are mostly all similarly confused, and I've given up.
So even if I had Internet, … I still can't do it. So if I'm actually in a situation where I need an ad hoc, it definitely isn't happening.
Wow, tell me you don’t know how computer networks work without telling me you don’t know how computer networks work.
I think we are done here.
I think there must be some misunderstanding? I think deathanatos just wants an easy way to send files between computers when the internet is down, which seems decently reasonable.
Oh come on, this isn't a conspiracy. For the last decade, every single laptop computer I've used has been thinner than an ethernet port, and every desktop has shipped with an ethernet port. I think the last few generations of MacBook Pros (which were famously thicker than prior generations) are roughly as thick as an ethernet port, but I'm not sure it'd practically fit.
And I know hacker news hates thin laptops, but most people prefer thin laptops over laptops with ethernet. My MacBook Air is thin and powerful and portable and can be charged with a USB-C phone charger. It's totally worth it for 99% of people to not have an ethernet port.
The XJACK and similar designs have been around long enough they can vote
Up to 2MB/s effective throughput, better than 10M Ethernet. Likely it was slower for you due to other limitations.
This could be done on Amiga too, using parnet https://crossconnect.tripod.com/PARNET.HTML
I recall it being easier to set up than a dialup modem (since the latter also required installing a TCP/IP stack)
usb probably works too if you google a bit
I know there's something about USB A to USB A cables not existing in theory, but this would have been a good reason to have it exist, and USB C of course can do this
Also, Android to PC can sort of do it, and is arguably two computers in some form (but this was easier when Android still acted like a mass storage device). But e.g. two laptops can't do it with each other.