News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by reaperducer on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:14PM (#44491849)
I know it's trendy to hate Dyson machines on HN because everyone here is absolutely smarter than every other person in the world that actually makes things, but, I rather like my Dyson vacuum cleaner.

People on HN are always saying they'd pay extra for a vacuum cleaner that is repairable. Well, here it is. Put your money where your mouth is.

I've had mine for at least ten years, and when something goes wrong, I'm able to order parts, and fix it myself. The whole thing is extensively designed to be repaired, complete with little icons on most of the parts to guide to taking them apart and putting them together.

I suspect that 90% of the people on HN who complain about Dyson (and most other consumer products) have never owned one, and are just aping things they've read online just to have something at all to say.

Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by ivell on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:16PM (#44491857)
I have found the parts to be very expensive though.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by reaperducer on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:52PM (#44492229)
I have found the parts to be very expensive though.

Seems OK to me. I have an articulated, motorized brush head on the way. ~$51, including shipping. Pretty good considering recent inflation, tariffs, etc…

Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by mostly_harmless on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:39PM (#44492107)
I don't hate Dyson because it's trendy, I hate Dyson because my $700 vacuum wont pick up cheerios; a common spill with toddlers.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by IncreasePosts on Monday July 07, 2025 @04:04PM (#44494125)
Buy a dog. The dog picks up the cheerios and the $700 Dyson picks up the dog hair.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by danpalmer on Monday July 07, 2025 @05:51PM (#44495040)
I don’t have a Dyson, but my vacuum also struggles with items so big they don’t fit under the roller. I don’t generally find it to be a problem because at that size they’re easy to pick up.

Not defending Dyson, there’s a lot of valid criticism here, but at some size pieces are too big to vacuum, and if that size is Cheerios, maybe that’s not much of a problem?

I’d rather have a vacuum that does well at the small stuff I can’t reasonably pick up.

Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by tristor on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:44PM (#44492145)
> I suspect that 90% of the people on HN who complain about Dyson (and most other consumer products) have never owned one, and are just aping things they've read online just to have something at all to say.

Same suspicion for me. I've owned two Dyson vacuums, and the only reason I had to buy the second was because someone stole the first one when they broke into my apartment over a decade ago. My current vacuum is more than 8 years old and has been repaired a few times doing it myself, and is still fully functional and comparable or better than most new vacuums.

Dyson makes very good products that are also beautiful. Yes, they're plastic, yes they're expensive, no they're not necessarily on paper the /best/ at their thing, but they're good, they're repairable, and they pass the wife acceptance factor.

Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by jayd16 on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:58PM (#44492310)
I have a bunch of Dyson things because the wife loves the design but I find them to be consistently disappointing. Incredibly expensive for mediocre results and usually bad battery life. It's a step above junk but you're really just paying for style.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by rancidcrab on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:59PM (#44492313)
Additionally the comparison of the hand dryers is pretty unfair imo. Those V-shape Dyson dryers are so much better than any others I've tried ever. All the other seem downright anemic (or rather asthmatic in this case) and take much longer than those advertised 20s.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by antihero on Monday July 07, 2025 @01:52PM (#44492919)
Yeah the airblades are night and day better than anything else, other than the noise which is painful if you're hungover.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by zeroxfe on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:59PM (#44492317)
Yeah, I was thinking the same. I have two Dyson vacuum cleaners, one purchased about 9 years ago, and the other two years ago. Both are excellent, and I still use the old one for my basement.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by calmbonsai on Monday July 07, 2025 @12:59PM (#44492325)
I did pay more for a vacuum. I bought a Miehl 12 years ago and it's awesome.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by AlotOfReading on Monday July 07, 2025 @01:24PM (#44492589)
Not quite as long ago, but yeah I've taken my miele down to parts for cleaning and back. The motors, molding, and reels are available as spare parts if I ever need to replace them, which I haven't yet. The only downside has been the premium.
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by nancyminusone on Monday July 07, 2025 @01:14PM (#44492484)
The only Dyson that we have is an old vacuum I pulled out of the trash, which they haven't sold in years. Was clogged with hair; we removed the hair. Works well enough. It's a vacuum. It vacuums stuff pretty ok.

9/10 would trash pick again. I don't think I would ever buy one new though.

Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by _dain_ on Monday July 07, 2025 @04:26PM (#44494332)
i have never even seen dyson come up as a topic on HN before
Re:Dyson, techno-centric design and social consumption by tomhow on Tuesday July 08, 2025 @03:04AM (#44497761)
Plenty of comments here seem positive towards Dyson. Others are negative but explain their reasons.

These kinds of curmudgeonly sneers/swipes at the HN community are so lame. They're easy to make and will attract upvotes and agreement from people who want the stereotype to be true. But they're futile to try and refute because people will always put more weight on the evidence that supports a belief like this than that which opposes it. The ultimate effect is wasted energy, and making HN threads depressing, which is interesting when the commenter is purportedly concerned about excessive negativity in this community.

Comments like this are clearly in breach of the guidelines, for good reason: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html