News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why English doesn't use accents by tacker2000 on Monday July 07, 2025 @03:14AM (#44487537)
This article is about accents on letters (diacritics), not accents as in dialects.

I found your post interesting neverthelesss.

Re:Why English doesn't use accents by Luker88 on Monday July 07, 2025 @05:07AM (#44488243)
It is probably connected.

Having so many different dialects (and full minor languages!) saying the same word slightly differently, Italians were forced to find (and use) a way to put the correct accent in writing.

Other languages probably don't have the mind boggling number of dialects Italy has. GP was not exaggerating, it really changes every few kilometers.

Like the article says: "situations like these are surprisingly few in English"

Re:Why English doesn't use accents by lompad on Monday July 07, 2025 @05:25AM (#44488366)
Germany is similar. Especially in more rural areas, a couple villages away people are going to have a hard time understanding you.

Though there's typically a common dialect variant everybody speaks, usually the one spoken by the largest city in the region.

E.g. every middle-franconian understands Nuremberg franconian dialect and is able to talk in a way they would understand.

Re:Why English doesn't use accents by yieldcrv on Monday July 07, 2025 @07:38AM (#44489230)
I'm American

My ear has just gotten to the point of noticing German dialects, and spotting the quizzical looks of other German/Austrian/Swiss people in the group

Fascinating. I feel like they had 1,000 years to resolve this

Re:Why English doesn't use accents by adonovan on Monday July 07, 2025 @08:13AM (#44489542)
1000? Prussia dissolved only in 1947 and the nation state of Germany was reunified only in 1990.

In any case, communication technology (trains, TVs) is a greater determinant of dialect than government.

Re:Why English doesn't use accents by yieldcrv on Monday July 07, 2025 @10:19AM (#44490645)
suboptimal outcome for sure
Re:Why English doesn't use accents by fakedang on Monday July 07, 2025 @08:25AM (#44489642)
Heck, Swiss German is like this lol.

My cofounder's wife, during a parents together at school, was "advised" by some of the mothers to not "hang around those" mothers because they're stranger folk. Turns out, they lived 1.5 miles away in the next village.

Re:Why English doesn't use accents by jason-johnson on Monday July 07, 2025 @09:19AM (#44490108)
well, if you ignore the current country borders then "German" would encompass a large portion of Switzerland and the Netherlands. So, with that assumption, I would be surprised if Italian had more dialects than German.
Re:Why English doesn't use accents by stavros on Monday July 07, 2025 @05:45AM (#44488485)
Italian script doesn't use diacritics, though, so it's not the same kind of accent as the article talks about.
Re:Why English doesn't use accents by Luker88 on Monday July 07, 2025 @05:53AM (#44488531)
Italian script most definitely requires diacritics.

"è" (is) vs "e" (and)

"pero" (pear tree) vs "però" (but)

"perché" is the only correct one and "perche" and "perchè" do not exist

and so many other examples.

Re:Why English doesn't use accents by stavros on Monday July 07, 2025 @05:57AM (#44488560)
Oh huh, I've forgotten more Italian than I thought, thanks for the correction!