News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by themaninthedark on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:18PM (#44446312)
It's not just cheap labor. It's labor that is abused, sometimes enslaved.

It's also lack of environmental regulation adherence. China has environmental regulations but they don't always demand compliance. I read about companies paying for scrubbers to be installed in factories and when a team comes to take a tour, still with original filters and low run hours.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by lesuorac on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:46PM (#44446667)
Labor is like 8% of the price of a car. That's not the difference between 25k and 65k.

While China does have an advantage over northern states in labor prices it's not why it's so cheap.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by missedthecue on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @02:27PM (#44447181)
That 8% is only if you include the labor costs of final assembly at the GM plant. But their inputs also were built by labor. GM buys turbochargers not out of thin air, but from Garrett Motion inc., in Plymouth Michigan, who also has sizeable labor costs. Repeat not just for turbochargers, but for the rest of GM's input supply line. If you include only their direct suppliers, the cost of a new car that goes to human wages is about 30-40%.

Chinese turbocharger suppliers have lower labor costs and therefore BYD, Changan, Great Wall and others have more pricing power vs GM and Ford products.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by fragmede on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @03:31PM (#44447873)
Not to be an ass, but I don't think BYD is using turbochargers in their electric cars, but I am not an electric drivetrain engineer.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by ponector on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @04:36PM (#44448546)
Your comment would be funny if not only half of BYD vehicles are fully electric.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by missedthecue on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @05:26PM (#44449037)
Yes, their song, tang, han, and shark models are all turbocharged.

But my broader point is that their entire supply chain is comprised of lower labor cost inputs. Whether it be the EV batteries, the windshield, or the air valve in each of the four tires.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @09:27PM (#44450692)
> Yes, their song, tang, han, and shark models are all turbocharged.

Pretty sure that only applies to the ICE versions of those cars and not the purely electric ones.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by missedthecue on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @11:01PM (#44451231)
...naturally
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by Yeul on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @05:28PM (#44449052)
Maybe Americans could build cars that people living in Asia actually want? Hint someone in Jakarta doesn't want a 40k pick-up truck.

Tangentially related China is located in the region with largest economic growth. Power is shifting from Europe and North America.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by wkat4242 on Thursday July 03, 2025 @05:19AM (#44453163)
> Maybe Americans could build cars that people living in Asia actually want? Hint someone in Jakarta doesn't want a 40k pick-up truck.

You'd be surprised. One of the things that really raised my eyebrows in Thailand was slum shacks with a gleaming new muscle pickup parked beside it. For some reason these are really popular and people spend an inordinate amount of income on them.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by throw734785 on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:57PM (#44446819)
That is rich from Americans, who exploit illegal immigrants for cheap labour!
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by DontchaKnowit on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @04:33PM (#44448517)
Who said OP was american.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by themaninthedark on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @07:46PM (#44450059)
That sounds like a very good argument for cracking down on illegal immigration, either by bringing people out of the shadows or by removing them. Currently American is going the removal route.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by pphysch on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:47PM (#44446692)
Counterpoint: cost of living is ridiculously cheaper in China vs. USA. Workers can be paid 3x less and still have a better QoL. It's a vastly more efficient economy in terms of human capital.

Counterpoint: China is the undisputed leader in renewable energy technology, including battery storage. I don't think they are doing it purely for environmental reasons, but they are doing it.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by darth_avocado on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @02:03PM (#44446890)
I agree. A lot of modern trade for the US is built around arbitrage on purchasing power. If all else costs the same, and you have to decide whether to pay someone $2 per hour to do it or $20, $2 always wins unless shipping it over is more expensive than the difference, which almost always isn’t.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by _DeadFred_ on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @04:15PM (#44448312)
Average salary in China has gone up quite a bit. It might be 1/3 but it's not $2.

I had a friend move his factory to China because the packaging and other costs were so much cheaper. I wish I'd asked for a breakdown. He didn't factor in/expect wages to be much of a savings.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by darth_avocado on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @04:56PM (#44448725)
I just pulled a random number but what I intended to say is that as long as differences in purchasing power exist and the dollar is the stronger currency, trade will move to where your dollar has more purchasing power for labor, as long as moving the finished goods back to the US isn’t prohibitively expensive.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by int_19h on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @07:40PM (#44450013)
But the main reason why that cost of living is ridiculously cheaper is because human labor is so much less expensive. There's no free lunch - if the output is that much cheaper, that difference has to come out of someone's pocket eventually, even if it's not the person directly manufacturing the thing but someone down the line from them.

Or you can look from it from the opposite direction and imagine what would have happened if there was full freedom of movement between China and US (i.e. no visas etc) and thus an actual free market for labor. If you expect workers in such situation to steadily migrate from China to US but not vice versa (at least until cost of labor equalizes), this implies that the workers in China are somehow worse off in absolute quality of life even when accounting for relative cost-of-life differences. That is, if the relationship between two countries wasn't economically exploitative in some way, we wouldn't need to restrict the free flow of labor at the border.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by pphysch on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @09:20PM (#44450653)
> But the main reason why that cost of living is ridiculously cheaper is because human labor is so much less expensive.

That's a really bizarre take that is obviously false. The disenfranchised migrant laborer or prison slave producing your American groceries is earning approximately as much as a Chinese peasant, i.e. basically nothing.

There is however a vast difference in what the organization looks like above the laborer. In America: vast profits and consolidation. By contrast, China has more small businesses (think street food) and large enterprises are SOE or otherwise constrained by the political system.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by int_19h on Thursday July 03, 2025 @07:16PM (#44459896)
As far as I know, this is not the case for migrant laborers at least, who often get paid more than federal minimum wage (because otherwise they can't get enough people even if they are undocumented immigrants).

In any case, if those were the main two reasons for the disparity, then we wouldn't see the same for other first world countries which have neither cheap migrant labor nor prison slaves. Yet cost of living is still significantly more expensive in, say, Finland than it is in China.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by HDThoreaun on Thursday July 03, 2025 @10:35AM (#44455497)
America's cost of living issues are mostly because of bad regulation. The big three rising costs are housing, healthcare, and education, and all 3 have been horribly misregulated by the US gov leading to massive spikes in price.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by int_19h on Thursday July 03, 2025 @07:16PM (#44459900)
How about the rest of the First World then?
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by themaninthedark on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @07:43PM (#44450035)
And why is cost of living ridiculously cheaper in China?

If you pay less in wages, goods cost less.

If you have less environmental regulations/ignore them, goods cost less.

Yes, they are the leader in renewable energy tech. They have also cornered the market with regards to the rare minerals that are some/most of the inputs. The link is not a coincidence.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by abe_m on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @08:12PM (#44450223)
In the US, housing and real estate have been driven up significantly to the benefit of the really rich. Increased rent, and increased house cost for existing structures just ends up lining the pockets of people rich enough to get priority access to new, cheap debt issuance. Inflation benefits those who are closest to the new money creation, while screwing those furthest away. All the while, everything gets more expensive with increasing rents.

I don't know if that is also the case in China.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by chii on Thursday July 03, 2025 @02:29AM (#44452224)
> I don't know if that is also the case in China.

it is exactly the case in china - just with different numbers. It's why shanghai and beijing has some of the highest property price to income ratios. Just like in san fran.

There's cheap property in the USA - rural areas and lower populated areas. Just like there are in china.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by ponector on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @04:38PM (#44448561)
> It's labor that is abused, sometimes enslaved

Sounds like average American gig worker.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @09:26PM (#44450678)
> It's labor that is abused, sometimes enslaved.

Maybe 20 years ago? Wages are rising salaries and employers are playing nice so their employees don't jump ship elsewhere. The day of your employer keeping your ID card captive is long gone (unless you are a naked official).

> China has environmental regulations but they don't always demand compliance.

That was also a lot more common 20 years ago than today. These days, cities/provinces are held accountable for AQI reductions, so pretend inspections no longer help their metrics. But I totally get it, there is a lot of material from 2000 to 2015 or so, and they basically live forever on the internet.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday July 03, 2025 @08:01PM (#44460124)
Those articles seem to be mostly retrospective, so you are agreeing?
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by themaninthedark on Monday July 07, 2025 @08:29AM (#44489677)
From the 2024 Politico article:

>The study, which focuses on 2023 and early this year(2024), adds to a growing body of evidence that Beijing is using forced labor and mass internment camps to control the Uyghurs — and ramps up pressure on the European Union to finalize plans for a bloc-wide ban on imports of products made with forced labor.

Your comment: >Maybe 20 years ago?

Unless it is suddenly 2030 and I missed the time shift, I am talking the past year or two.