News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by TulliusCicero on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:49PM (#44359346)
If the speeding is only going with the flow of traffic, that's not a huge deal imo.

The left turn fuckup is really bad though, as is the instance of the robotaxi dropping someone off in the middle of an intersection after they hit the "drop off earlier" button: https://sh.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/1liku3o/tes...

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by energywut on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:59PM (#44359445)
Watching one of the videos, the car went 38/39 in a 30, and was the only car nearby. It was not keeping pace with other vehicles in its lane. It seemed like a lot of the roads it was driving on were signed 35 or 40 (it was a lot of stroads), but a few were signed 30, which it just flatly ignored.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by mslansn on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:17PM (#44359631)
If it was the only car nearby does it matter that it went 39 in a 30?
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by energywut on Monday June 23, 2025 @08:01PM (#44361481)
Yes. The energy in a vehicle increases with the square of the velocity. A car going 40 has nearly DOUBLE the kinetic energy of a car going 30 and the braking time required to stop a car is therefore also significantly increased.

That lower speed limit was set for a reason.

Additionally, predictable car movement is important for wildlife, pedestrians, and other vehicles. If the cars on that street always go 30, the others there will learn to predict the movement of a car. If some rando car start speeding along at 40 out of the blue, that will disrupt the calculations and decision making of everyone else.

Finally, are we comfortable saying, "Any company can decide whether it thinks obeying the speed limit is important, and is free to go over the speed limit by 1/3rd if they deem it safe"? Are we sure that precedent is healthy and desirable? I'm not. I don't think automated cars should just decide to add 33% to a speed limit and go that fast in normal operating conditions.

So yes, it does matter.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by tene80i on Monday June 23, 2025 @05:20PM (#44360244)
Yes. People should follow the law as a general rule, and particularly when operating a giant metal object that can kill. Software should do the same. Moreover, if it cannot, or chooses not to, why should we trust it to drive at all? What other rules might it flout? Who decides? You? Elon?
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by vel0city on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:20PM (#44359657)
Yes, the car should be traveling the speed limit if it is the only car around and conditions allow it. It should not be speeding by default on its own.
[dead]
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by tweetle_beetle on Monday June 23, 2025 @05:37PM (#44360410)
Ok, but who pays the fine, or has their license revoked when a robotaxi drives over the speed limit to fit in with humans?
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by reaperducer on Monday June 23, 2025 @06:42PM (#44360953)
Speed limits are artificially low because they know drivers will not obey them.

Entirely false.

Speed limits are determined by dozens of factors, including traffic studies, noise studies, and other needs. There's an entire industry for this.

Go to a city council meeting sometime and you'll learn all about it.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by mslansn on Monday June 23, 2025 @08:14PM (#44361556)
If I wanted to learn about something a city council meeting would be the last place I would go to.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by vel0city on Monday June 23, 2025 @10:31PM (#44362368)
Yeah, far better to get your information on how your city council decides on speed limits by reading Reddit and other random internet commenters instead of original sources and those actually setting the speed limits.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by rich_sasha on Monday June 23, 2025 @10:57PM (#44362509)
Perhaps it was trained to behave like a real taxi driver then?
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by addandsubtract on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:05AM (#44364831)
It needs an arm hanging out of the side window randomly gesturing at other drivers and road signs. Also 8 mobile phones all on different voice chat apps.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by crazygringo on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:04PM (#44359495)
> If the speeding is only going with the flow of traffic, that's not a huge deal imo.

If it's intentionally programmed to violate speed limits, then sure.

If it's intending to follow speed limits but is failing, then that's terrifying, because where is its wrong information coming from, and how catastrophic could the errors be?

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by rs186 on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:05PM (#44359507)
True, but AFAIK Waymo strictly follows speed limits.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by dzhiurgis on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:38PM (#44359828)
Which is why it couldn’t use highways for ages, as otherwise they’d been honked off the road
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by rs186 on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:48PM (#44359920)
Absolutely false.

I have driven many hours at posted speed limits on highway in the rightmost lane in the US, and I yet need to hear one honk. And I have seen cars driving even slower -- absolutely no problem. Anyone that wants to move faster just changes lanes and moves on.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by socalgal2 on Monday June 23, 2025 @05:07PM (#44360096)
It probably depends on where. Try driving the speed limit (50mph) on the south bound 101 between the Bay Bridge and Portola. Especially near the 280 turn off. The "right lane" of the 101 is two lanes over from the right most lane because the 2 right most lanes turn off to the 280. Diving 50 there will get you (well, me) shouted at.

No one seems to notice the speed limit is 50 and not 65 so the majority of cars are going 65 to 75mph. I thought about carrying a sign I could hold up "Speed limit 50mph!" for when I got screamed at for trying to go the speed limit

I'm on the "enforce it or repeal it" side. I personally wish they'd put up cameras there and ticket everyone until they slowed down. Or change the signs to 65 if they're not going to enforce it.

The north bound side is also treacherous in that area. Again, the speed limit is 50mph but the 280 merges on the right and people come off it at 65mph+. That makes it harrowing to get in the right lane for the Cesar Chavez exit from the 101. If you're going the 50mph speed limit you'll merge into a line going 65-70. If you go 65-70 you have far less time to get in the right line in time to make the exit.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by awongh on Monday June 23, 2025 @06:51PM (#44361009)
I would go so far as to say that it's dangerous to drive what the speed limit is supposed to be, if everyone else is driving 15-30 miles an hour faster than you.

Which also highlights one of the inherent flaws with laws and rules like speed limits. They don't ever actually mean, drive at this velocity. They always mean, drive at a safe speed and here is the number we all collectively agree on, unless we don't.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by harmmonica on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:54PM (#44359976)
I've seen a few folks in this thread say this, but where you're from do people genuinely get honked at if they go the actual speed limit? I live in an area that's pretty famous for people driving a) with entitlement b) like shit and c) fast. Unless someone is camping out in the left lane (assuming a multi-lane highway and left-hand drive car) and they're driving the speed limit, I've literally never seen someone honk at a person going the speed limit in my lifetime. Even when folks are camped in the left lane I'm not sure I've seen that, though aggressive tailgating and/or flashing high beams is a regular occurrence. And then more often than not the left-lane blocker doesn't even do anything in response to that (or so those aggressive drivers stuck behind them tell me).

I just don't think there's going to be any issue in most geographies if they go on highways/freeways and follow the speed limit (I guarantee that's true in the US; I'd go out on a limb and guess it's true almost everywhere).

edit: grammar

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:45PM (#44359894)
> otherwise they’d been honked off the road

Slowing down surrounding traffic to the speed limit would be an amazing safety multiplier for AVs.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by potato3732842 on Monday June 23, 2025 @05:19PM (#44360234)
It takes "I'm a good driver, all my accidents have been other people's fault" type ignorance to say such a thing. Have you ever followed a police escorted wide load, snow plow or other road obstruction to that effect? The sort of tightly packed surging traffic that follows those rolling road blocks is far, far, less safe than the baseline for the same road/traffic conditions sans the rolling roadblock. This is readily apparent to anyone who has ever encountered it.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by seanmcdirmid on Monday June 23, 2025 @07:30PM (#44361279)
Pace cars are a thing. Traffic calming works by a similar principle. Automated traffic calming would be far from unprecedented. If it doesn't work out, it isn't because of the AVs following the speed limit, but the road and its capacity requirements are not actually fitted to that speed limit.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @01:41AM (#44363136)
> It takes "I'm a good driver, all my accidents have been other people's fault" type ignorance

No, it takes a person who hasn’t had an accident outside a parking lot in decades.

Speed limits save lives. I am not an angel when it comes to them. And we definitely have an issue with stupid speed limits in towns as revenue traps. But on freeways? 65 to 80 mph is plenty.

> tightly packed surging traffic that follows those rolling road blocks is far, far, less safe than the baseline for the same road/traffic conditions sans the rolling roadblock

Totally false. Crashes decrease with congestion [2][3]. And mortality in a crash is essentially governed by speed [1]. A surging bolus is only as dangerous as its speed.

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29323934/

[2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10149483/

[3] https://www.roads.maryland.gov/OPR_Research/MD-03-SP308B46-C...

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by potato3732842 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @06:01AM (#44364489)
Ah, yes, the famous "cite a source that uses trade lingo that is overloads normal people lingo in a way that will actively mislead the casual reader" slight of hand.

You can take that behavior, load it into a 12ga shell and suck it out the barrel end like a mentally troubled musician for all I care.

What your sources are calling congestion a normal person would call stop and go traffic or a traffic jam. No surprise nobody dies in that. We're talking about higher speed stuff, the transition from "speed capped by conditions" to "speed capped by other traffic". That transition zone absolutely is dangerous because all sorts of lane changing and merging and zipping around each other happens and there's way more interactions between traffic of differing speeds and a chunk of the attention of all the drivers that normally goes to being able to safely deal with the unexpected instead goes to managing this high baseline of activity. It is less safe. There are infinitely more situations where every single person has to actively "do" something to keep it all working without conflict than in traffic that isn't at this transitionary speed, either above, or well below like the crap you linked to indicates. But of course minor accidents because traffic speed changed drastically at just the moment someone was teeing up a lane change are hard to measure in cause, so instead we get people like you telling us speed is the problem because more of these people die when such an event happens at 65 than at 55 among other infantile analysis.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @03:10PM (#44369801)
> That transition zone absolutely is dangerous

And yet we have no evidence for this perfidious danger! Despite lots of evidence for its opposite, e.g. pacing cars making roads safer.

Fortunately this discussion is moot as the authorisations for these EVs were granted before the crowd that concludes first and looks for evidence second took notice.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by xnx on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @08:07AM (#44365252)
I believe Waymo has found evidence for this is their large scale date. Waymo reduces overall accidents on the areas they operate.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by potato3732842 on Monday June 23, 2025 @05:06PM (#44360095)
They could've done it just fine. You only get treated like shit on the roads if your behavior is both selfish/unnecessary and inconveniences others

Garbage truck leaving a slowly but as fast as he can -> no problem

Tesla M3 leaving a light slowly -> dude deserves ever honk he gets.

BMW M3 weaving through traffic cuts people off but is gone as fast as he came -> nobody cares

Prius doing 55 in the right lane -> no problem

Prius doing 55 in the left lane because entitlement -> lots of middle fingers

I have complete confidence waymo would have "done the right thing". The real problem is that there still would have been a million rear endings. Eventually the insurance companies would have sued them because no amount of idiots online screeching about the "rules" actually makes it ok to habitually create the preconditions for an accident. It would have been a big expensive legal fight. The state doesn't want high speed limits to reflect how fast people actually drive. Waymo doesn't wanna be involved in that. The insurance companies don't wanna be involved in that. It's just a no brainer not to given the constraints.

Though I can't help but wonder if insurance rates would've eventually gone down for everyone if the issue got forced and it resulted in some sort of "after the 3rd rear ending they're on you by default" rule or something.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by drcongo on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @04:24AM (#44363982)
Do Waymos pull off the road when honked at? That feels like a design flaw to me.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by duxup on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:59PM (#44359443)
"We're at the corner"

Um ... kinda...

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by andrewmcwatters on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:55PM (#44359405)
Nah, I want a system that obeys the law. I don't need software breaking the law on my behalf. Waymo has proven that it's an exceptional ride experience when you have an automated driver that is cautious and obeys the law, which is more than what 99% of drivers do in the Phoenix metro. Go count how many people obey traffic laws for fun.

And guess who's at fault when you're caught?

Edit: No, crossing double-lines to avoid obstructions isn't breaking the law. People in the Comma Discord bring up these weird edge cases that are outlined in law, too. No, you're never forced to break the law when driving.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by nradov on Monday June 23, 2025 @03:58PM (#44359435)
There are circumstances where breaking the law is necessary, like crossing a double yellow line to safely get around a lane obstruction.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by nash on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:02PM (#44359470)
Generally that's not actually breaking the law. Avoiding accidents, following reasonable directions from road crews and the like explicitly override other laws.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by nradov on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:14PM (#44359597)
How do Tesla Robotaxis handle unreasonable directions from road crews? The other day there was a crew patching potholes in my neighborhood and one worker was standing there giving vague hand signals with no sign or anything. I just ignored him and went around when it seemed safe.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by jasonlotito on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:26PM (#44359721)
> How do Tesla Robotaxis handle unreasonable directions from road crews?

Legally.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by reaperducer on Monday June 23, 2025 @06:48PM (#44360993)
How do Tesla Robotaxis handle unreasonable directions from road crews?

The law where I am is that human traffic directors (police, sheriffs, construction crews, etc) take precedent over what's in the book. If they didn't, nobody could ever get around a fire truck at a fire.

I just ignored him and went around when it seemed safe.

And that's where you get a ticket. Plenty of cops around here sitting at the exit of construction zones waiting for people just like you.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by nradov on Monday June 23, 2025 @07:23PM (#44361245)
Nah. If there was a cop around he would have made sure the road crew had actual signs.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by reaperducer on Monday June 23, 2025 @10:49PM (#44362464)
How?
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by nradov on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @12:08AM (#44362784)
By telling them what to do.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by reaperducer on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @01:04AM (#44362983)
Clearly you are either a child, or not from a developed country, because you demonstrate a basic lack of understanding of how ordinary things are done.
Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by moralestapia on Monday June 23, 2025 @04:18PM (#44359637)
Excuse me, what?

I get that nobody's perfect and you might do it by mistake (going 35 on a unmarked road that was 30 max or something), but the way you write your comment makes it sound like it's something one does in a deliberate way?

Drivers like that shouldn't be on the road.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by nradov on Monday June 23, 2025 @07:25PM (#44361251)
Excuse me, what?

If there's an obstruction in the middle of my lane then obviously I'm going to deliberately go around it. Have you ever driven a car?

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by beAbU on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @02:27AM (#44363367)
> like crossing a double yellow line to safely get around a lane obstruction

That's not breaking the law though.

Re:Tesla Robotaxi Videos Show Speeding, Driving into Wrong Lane by jstummbillig on Monday June 23, 2025 @05:15PM (#44360198)
I think there are two distinct types of "bad" here, and to me, one is way more interesting than the other.

If we mean, that this is dangerous: Yes, of course. It's an obvious, somewhat dangerous error (and I say "somewhat", only because I assume currently everyone participating is cognizant of the fact, that this is in some kind of testing stage)

But I think the more interesting question is: How quickly can this issue (and others like it) be fixed? If the answer at this point is "we will have to retrain the entire model and just hope for the best" that sounds, like, really bad.