I have driven many hours at posted speed limits on highway in the rightmost lane in the US, and I yet need to hear one honk. And I have seen cars driving even slower -- absolutely no problem. Anyone that wants to move faster just changes lanes and moves on.
No one seems to notice the speed limit is 50 and not 65 so the majority of cars are going 65 to 75mph. I thought about carrying a sign I could hold up "Speed limit 50mph!" for when I got screamed at for trying to go the speed limit
I'm on the "enforce it or repeal it" side. I personally wish they'd put up cameras there and ticket everyone until they slowed down. Or change the signs to 65 if they're not going to enforce it.
The north bound side is also treacherous in that area. Again, the speed limit is 50mph but the 280 merges on the right and people come off it at 65mph+. That makes it harrowing to get in the right lane for the Cesar Chavez exit from the 101. If you're going the 50mph speed limit you'll merge into a line going 65-70. If you go 65-70 you have far less time to get in the right line in time to make the exit.
Which also highlights one of the inherent flaws with laws and rules like speed limits. They don't ever actually mean, drive at this velocity. They always mean, drive at a safe speed and here is the number we all collectively agree on, unless we don't.
I just don't think there's going to be any issue in most geographies if they go on highways/freeways and follow the speed limit (I guarantee that's true in the US; I'd go out on a limb and guess it's true almost everywhere).
edit: grammar
Slowing down surrounding traffic to the speed limit would be an amazing safety multiplier for AVs.
No, it takes a person who hasn’t had an accident outside a parking lot in decades.
Speed limits save lives. I am not an angel when it comes to them. And we definitely have an issue with stupid speed limits in towns as revenue traps. But on freeways? 65 to 80 mph is plenty.
> tightly packed surging traffic that follows those rolling road blocks is far, far, less safe than the baseline for the same road/traffic conditions sans the rolling roadblock
Totally false. Crashes decrease with congestion [2][3]. And mortality in a crash is essentially governed by speed [1]. A surging bolus is only as dangerous as its speed.
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29323934/
[2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10149483/
[3] https://www.roads.maryland.gov/OPR_Research/MD-03-SP308B46-C...
You can take that behavior, load it into a 12ga shell and suck it out the barrel end like a mentally troubled musician for all I care.
What your sources are calling congestion a normal person would call stop and go traffic or a traffic jam. No surprise nobody dies in that. We're talking about higher speed stuff, the transition from "speed capped by conditions" to "speed capped by other traffic". That transition zone absolutely is dangerous because all sorts of lane changing and merging and zipping around each other happens and there's way more interactions between traffic of differing speeds and a chunk of the attention of all the drivers that normally goes to being able to safely deal with the unexpected instead goes to managing this high baseline of activity. It is less safe. There are infinitely more situations where every single person has to actively "do" something to keep it all working without conflict than in traffic that isn't at this transitionary speed, either above, or well below like the crap you linked to indicates. But of course minor accidents because traffic speed changed drastically at just the moment someone was teeing up a lane change are hard to measure in cause, so instead we get people like you telling us speed is the problem because more of these people die when such an event happens at 65 than at 55 among other infantile analysis.
And yet we have no evidence for this perfidious danger! Despite lots of evidence for its opposite, e.g. pacing cars making roads safer.
Fortunately this discussion is moot as the authorisations for these EVs were granted before the crowd that concludes first and looks for evidence second took notice.
Garbage truck leaving a slowly but as fast as he can -> no problem
Tesla M3 leaving a light slowly -> dude deserves ever honk he gets.
BMW M3 weaving through traffic cuts people off but is gone as fast as he came -> nobody cares
Prius doing 55 in the right lane -> no problem
Prius doing 55 in the left lane because entitlement -> lots of middle fingers
I have complete confidence waymo would have "done the right thing". The real problem is that there still would have been a million rear endings. Eventually the insurance companies would have sued them because no amount of idiots online screeching about the "rules" actually makes it ok to habitually create the preconditions for an accident. It would have been a big expensive legal fight. The state doesn't want high speed limits to reflect how fast people actually drive. Waymo doesn't wanna be involved in that. The insurance companies don't wanna be involved in that. It's just a no brainer not to given the constraints.
Though I can't help but wonder if insurance rates would've eventually gone down for everyone if the issue got forced and it resulted in some sort of "after the 3rd rear ending they're on you by default" rule or something.