News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by throw310822 on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:02AM (#44344573)
All this talk about nuclear weapons is purposefully misleading. Iran had agreements in place to keep its nuclear program under strict and thorough international checks, and was currently negotiating a new one. The original deal was scrapped on Netanyahu's request, and the bombing was started by Netanyahu to prevent a new one.

Israel doesn't fear Iran's nukes. Israel fears an economically functional Iran and uses the wmd excuse to sabotage it as much as possible. The worst possible outcome for them is Iran proving it has no nuclear weapons at all and having its sanctions lifted.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by nine_k on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:15AM (#44344651)
Realistically, a secular Iran would be the only real ally of Israel in the region. This is how it was under the shah, until 1979.

Israel is set to benefit enormously from an economically functional Iran, with sanctions lifted, and a sane, non-fanatical, non-oppressive government. Iran used to be a pretty cool and developed country in 1960s, and could be now.

(Edit: typo)

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by dttze on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:25AM (#44344694)
You’re like the gusanos that say Cuba was so much better before the revolution. Without mentioning it was only great for the landowning slavers.

Why do you think there was a revolution?

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by nine_k on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:24AM (#44345051)
Cubans kept massively supporting Fidel for quite some time, and quite explicitly, even through the disastrous Communist economic policies.

Iranians keep protesting; last few years have seen several large protests, involving hundreds of thousands, and continuing for months. The popularity just isn't there.

Regarding revolutions, it's quite often that a relatively small group of like-minded people capture the control, and the majority is weakly supporting them, or is even weakly opposed but complies. The French revolution was mostly about some nobility wanting to remove the monarchy that oppressed them, along with the rest; most of the population wasn't overtly anti-monarchy, and not even covertly so, but it did not like the monarchy's pressure either. The Russian revolution was "communist" and "proletarian", but even by their own Marxist accounting, proletarians were less than 10% of Russian population, and communists, much fewer still. Nevertheless, they subdued most of the Russian empire.

The Iranian revolution was also done by a group of highly religious people who were fed up with the shah's secularization reforms. The shah, AFAICT, was a guy a bit like Putin, or Saudi kings: efficient and geared towards prosperity of the country, but quite authoritarian. The fact that e.g. the educated urban population in Iran wasn't happy about authoritarianism does not imply that the same people were (or are) huge fans of theocracy. Actually, the theocracy ended up even more oppressive.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by HK-NC on Sunday June 22, 2025 @05:29AM (#44345403)
Well I'd argue 50% of the population got a raw deal in the revolution at least.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by inglor_cz on Sunday June 22, 2025 @05:46AM (#44345478)
The Cuban revolution was more of a coup than a widespread national uprising.

It was a blind alley anyway. Zero countries that embraced Marxism-Leninism were able to reach prosperity on that ideology. Meanwhile, a lot of desperately poor countries of the 1950s are nowadays reasonably well of, on the basis of a normal, regulated market economy.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by LtWorf on Sunday June 22, 2025 @08:16AM (#44346262)
Do you have sources for all of this fantasy spin on history?
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by inglor_cz on Sunday June 22, 2025 @08:22AM (#44346303)
AFAIK Castro had never more than 3 thousand armed men at his side, and often much fewer, down to lower hundreds, spending much of the protracted conflict hiding in the countryside.

A revolution is something in which a significant part of a nation actively participates, not something that almost the entire population sits out passively.

Of course we can debate what is the necessary fraction, but 3000 militants isn't a big deal in a country of several million. Every Iraqi cleric in 2010 was able to put together a bigger militia than that.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by lostlogin on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:28AM (#44344714)
> This is how it was under the shah, until 1979.

Sort of? The US played a role in that shit show and it wasn’t all happy days under the Shah.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_Revolution

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by nine_k on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:38AM (#44345139)
Not "happy", but Iran was quite a bit more sober, not hostile towards Israel, and relatively secular.

(Similarly, China under Deng Xiaoping was not a paragon of political freedom at all, but it was quite a bit more sober than under Mao Zedong. The US administration had tons of shortcomings under president Biden, but it was in quite a bit less of disarray than under president Trump.)

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by praptak on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:36AM (#44344769)
Shah was a dictator propped up by US. There's no going back to these times.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by CalChris on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:45AM (#44344828)
Installed. We overthrew Mossadegh. We overthrew a democracy.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by nine_k on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:44AM (#44345175)
Indeed, it was a shameful act.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by mensetmanusman on Monday June 23, 2025 @09:50AM (#44355813)
Don’t forget Iran was defined as a country by the Ottoman Empire and others arbitrarily drawing lines around various groups that hate each other.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by throw310822 on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:29AM (#44344720)
> Israel is set to benefit enormously from an economically functional Iran,

Israel is currently engaged in genocide, how would it be good for it to benefit enormously?

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by foxglacier on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:13AM (#44344976)
People keep saying genocide but has it been established objectively? I seem to remember the ICJ deciding they weren't, but that was some time ago.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by Krasnol on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:31AM (#44345095)
Who cares about ICJ or any International Law these days anymore?

Yeah, I mean we can still use it (or it's slowness and uselessness) to hide behind it but the facts are on the table. Gaza looks like post-war Germany at this point. People ARE starving. Meanwhile Israel expands to the east. Also illegally.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by foxglacier on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @10:47PM (#44383806)
Anyone who calls something genocide needs to care because it has to have some definition or set of examples to mean anything, and those organizations are pretty much where the definitions come from. People love exaggerating political issues by using stronger words, so you have to tune it out, and then there's no information left.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by tdeck on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:46AM (#44345188)
> ? I seem to remember the ICJ deciding they weren't

Is this some reality distortion field? This never happened. Instead the ICJ issued multiple explicit orders to Israel that Israel has violated and the genocide case is still ongoing.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by foxglacier on Sunday June 22, 2025 @11:53PM (#44352324)
So it hasn't yet decided if there's genocide or not?

People should just say what they actually mean instead of ambiguous words like genocide. Is the genocide limiting food aid with the aim of demoralizing the population into losing support for Hamas? Or is it directly killing people in the fighting? He could have just said that so his words mean something. Those actions might or might not be genocide but they might still be something worth criticizing.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by tdeck on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:58AM (#44353155)
So we're just glossing over the fact that you tried to pretend the ICJ had said it wasn't genocide, a blatant lie, in your parent post? Why are you so committed to muddying the waters here?
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by foxglacier on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @10:42PM (#44383786)
It wasn't a lie. I really did seem to remember that. It may have been that they didn't reach a conclusion that it was genocide, or something else. I tried to look up the case and still couldn't see ICJ actually labelling it as genocide.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by qwery on Sunday June 22, 2025 @07:37AM (#44346052)
People keep questioning the definition of genocide, as if finding some technical distinction will absolve the perpetrators.

If you actually care about international law, you might be interested to know that the ICC has issued (standing) arrest warrants for Netanyahu and the former Israeli Minister for Defense for various crimes against humanity and the use of starvation in warfare.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by energy123 on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:40AM (#44344798)
Iran has violated the NPT so many times at this stage that no good faith observer can say what you've said here with a straight face. This is just using words to persuade for political purposes, it is not analysis.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by throw310822 on Sunday June 22, 2025 @08:20AM (#44346290)
Iran has violated the NPT because there were agreements in place for it to respect it, and the agreements have been violated by the other side. An action that must have consequences, otherwise there is no point in making deals with anyone.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by ivell on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:56AM (#44344884)
> The worst possible outcome for them is Iran proving it has no nuclear weapons at all and having its sanctions lifted.

Circumstantial evidence seems to be that Iran indeed was enriching Uranium beyond what was necessary for electricity. Why would they build enrichment facility deep underground? It is not that Iran is having energy crisis. The claim that Iran is thinking of green energy and climate change effects is a bit weak.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by LtWorf on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:18AM (#44345013)
Remember all that evidence about iraq? Remember the british guy who worked at the ministry and went to the news saying there was no evidence and then suicided without leaving his own fingerprints on the weapon?
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by simonh on Sunday June 22, 2025 @02:26PM (#44349125)
The uranium enrichment is confirmed by the Iranians, the have published pictures of their leaders inspecting the centrifuges. You can find them with a quick search.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by compsciphd on Sunday June 22, 2025 @07:31AM (#44346015)
its not circumstantial.

Even Iran has publicly said that they have enriched to 60%. 60% is not needed for civilian uses and only useful for research in how to make it go boom.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by 8note on Sunday June 22, 2025 @03:52PM (#44349771)
thats still circumstantial.

they could show research that theyre doing for how to make nuclear power using 60% enriched uranium. nothing says they have to use an existing design

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by petre on Sunday June 22, 2025 @04:23AM (#44345048)
Sure, they're making weapons grade uranium to exhibit it in the Museum of the Islamic Revolution and the Holy Defense in Teheran.
Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by k7sune on Sunday June 22, 2025 @12:55PM (#44348366)
How about the UN censuring Iran for not complying with the agreement? Was this a manufactured consensus? I don't see anyone mentioning IAEA's decision here.

www.pbs.org/newshour/amp/world/un-nuclear-watchdog-censures-iran-a-move-that-could-lead-to-restore-sanctions

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by xdennis on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:49AM (#44352774)
> Israel fears an economically functional Iran and uses the wmd excuse to sabotage it as much as possible.

Israel couldn't care less about Iran until 1979. It's the Islamists who are obsessed with Israel.

If Iran stopped chanting "Death to Israel" and stopped arming anti-Israeli groups then Israel would have no issue with Iran.

Re:Trump says US has bombed Fordo nuclear plant in attack on... by thunky on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @08:50AM (#44365636)
> If Iran stopped chanting "Death to Israel"

It's a stupid slogan because it gives politicians ammunition, but it can be interpreted various ways. For example:

Ali Al Bukhaiti, the former spokesman and the official media face of the Houthis, said: "We really do not want anyone's death. This slogan is only against the intervention of those governments [i.e. the United States and Israel]."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_to_Israel

Meanwhile, if you judge a country by it's actions rather than it's slogans tell me how Israel is looking right now on the "death to ..." scale.