That's rather cynical. This is precisely the kind of trial that doesn't require expert thinking because most of what is up for debate is whether Samsung willfully attempted to fool customers into thinking that their products were just like an iPhone by copying the trade dress. And determining such a thing is a matter of common sense.
This reminds me of an anecdote about Brahms's first symphony:
Brahms himself said, when comment was made on the similarity with Beethoven, "any ass can see that." [1]
So it is here. We needn't pretend any longer that Samsung's designs are mere coincidence. Whether it should be punishable is another question, but under the current law this, to me, is the right call.
1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._1_(Brahms)#History
This reeks heavily of people that had little idea about how the system actually works and gave verdicts that were more speculative rather than grounded and based on hard acts of actual infringement.
http://techcrunch.com/2012/08/24/hang-on-a-minute-jurors-awa...
Even more honest answer: I'd probably let the Apple fanboys share the injustice to the world.
It is not "many of the claims" it is one claim for one phone out of what 15+ that were covered in the case. It is quite understandable that there would be at least one mistake out of the all patent/phone combinations.
"The judge is writing a note to the jury to point out exactly what the inconsistencies are, because they couldn’t seem to tell from going over the document themselves."
Poor judge who was reading it seems to be more switched on than people who were writing it. I'm sure court room felt like an elementary school at that point.
http://www.theverge.com/2012/8/23/3260463/apple-samsung-jury...
I actually have some experience with this. I recently “second chaired” a very complex civil trial involving significant accounting issues. The presentation of evidence alone took 5 weeks. The verdict form was almost as complex as the one described here. We all expected the verdict form to come back a self-contradictory mess, but in fact the jury had no problem sorting through it all. The verdicts were perfectly consistent and logical, as were the damage awards. And unlike the Apple/Samsung jury, our jury mostly consisted of homemakers and people from working class backgrounds, so we couldn’t expect them to have comfort with the subject matter. My take on this was that the jurors understood they were deciding a dispute worth tens of millions of dollars and really wanted to reach the right result. So we might see the same thing in this case. On the other hand, my trial involved “real people” with names and faces, not faceless corporations like Apple and Samsung. It is possible that the jurors had a higher level of engagement under the circumstances.
I thought the lawyers, judge and witnesses provide all the information they need to make the decision.
>> And how many of those people are biased because they just love Steve Jobs
I would think that Samsung's lawyers would have disqualified those types of people during the selection process.
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/07/apple-v-samsung-j...
Another potential juror, a UI designer on the Android team was rejected by Apple.
It is important to realize that a jury trial is a seminar for the jury. It is given by two opposing sides to a disinterested party tasked to make a decision. If either side fails to inform the jury of the enormity or ramifications of their decision, it is the fault of that side.
It's easy to complain about the verdict, but taking pot-shots at the jury is so cheap.
If Samsung can't convince this lot - they couldn't it seems. So their only hope is the appeals court. But I got a feeling they'll drop that too.
Samsung's best approach is to pay. And move on.
It is also high on the conscious of American consumers that Apple is an innovative company that is readily ripped off by foreign companies.
FWIW I think the patent system is a lot more complicated than what a lot of geeks would understand as well. It really should be decided by a panel of judges and/or experts who can evaluate the case on merits and justify each decision.
No tech-savvy geek is unbiased. We both know it. If I were sitting on that jury, I'd be one hell of a biased juror who'd shout myself hoarse trying to terrorize other jurors to agree with me. Believe me, you don't want me deciding your billion-dollar case.
In this particular case, I agree with other commenters here that the general public should be fit to judge. But I'd rather see technical cases like Oracle vs. Google decided by experts.
“Only in America”
Far from it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_system#The_jury_trial_in_v...
Juries around the world are compromised of ordinary people.
I agree that this particular type of case should not be decided by jury.
It's mainly a trade dress and UI look & feel issue. So the general public are absolutely the right people.
The Samsung counterclaims really centered around the patent exhaustion issue. If the jury found that it did not apply in this case Apple would clearly have infringed.
Here is the jury according to techcrunch
1. An electrical engineer 2. A homemaker 3. A construction worker 4. A young unemployed man who likes video games 5. An insurance agent 6. An ex-Navy avionics technician 7. A store operations manager for a cycling retailer 8. A project manager for wireless carrier AT&T 9. A benefits and payroll manager who works with startups
http://techcrunch.com/2012/08/21/apple-samsung/
Only in America?? And how many of those people are biased because they just love Steve Jobs and Apple products. I know for sure, my mom loves her Mac and she wouldn't think twice who is right and who is wrong in this case.