News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Sunday June 15, 2025 @06:45PM (#44285455)
I watched David Attenborough's recent film 'Ocean' on a big screen. The footage of bottom trawling was really shocking. I don't understand how that has been allowed to continue in UK coastal waters, let alone to be subsidised in marine protected areas. Madness. It's like napalming a forest to get a few deer. Thankfully things may be changing:

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/government-proposes-to-ex...

Don't know how much of that was due to the film.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by Velorivox on Sunday June 15, 2025 @06:56PM (#44285495)
The relevant excerpt. [0]

[0] https://youtu.be/IzG9AwlypaY?feature=shared

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Sunday June 15, 2025 @07:02PM (#44285525)
Watch it in a cinema, to get the full effect.

There are some before and after scenes of the sea bed, which are pretty shocking as well.

I'm not sure how that got that footage. Surely fisherman would not want that to be seen?

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Sunday June 15, 2025 @07:06PM (#44285545)
Found this:

"Technically, probably the hardest thing was trying to film bottom trawling because it's never been filmed before and we didn't know if it was possible. You have to film the wonder but you also have to film the destruction. Capturing that was absolutely essential and it took a lot of research to find some scientists planning bottom trawling experiments who decided that adding cameras would help their research and also help to share it with the world."

At:

https://www.arksen.com/blogs/news/ocean-with-david-attenboro...

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by closewith on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:57AM (#44287496)
But watch it anyway. Trawling should be banned.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ropable on Sunday June 15, 2025 @07:48PM (#44285702)
I watched this film last night, and it was stunning and horrifying all at once. It really brings home the impact of industrial-scale trawling on the marine environment. It's literally like bulldozing a garden to harvest the fruit.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:05AM (#44288041)
It is like bulldozing a garden full of lots of different fruits and then only taking the apples above a certain size.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by dzhiurgis on Sunday June 15, 2025 @07:29PM (#44285630)
> subsidised in marine protected areas

What do you mean?

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by aspenmayer on Sunday June 15, 2025 @09:03PM (#44285971)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marine_protected_area

> A marine protected area (MPA) is a protected area of the world's seas, oceans, estuaries or in the US, the Great Lakes. These marine areas can come in many forms ranging from wildlife refuges to research facilities. MPAs restrict human activity for a conservation purpose, typically to protect natural or cultural resources. Such marine resources are protected by local, state, territorial, native, regional, national, or international authorities and differ substantially among and between nations. This variation includes different limitations on development, fishing practices, fishing seasons and catch limits, moorings and bans on removing or disrupting marine life. MPAs can provide economic benefits by supporting the fishing industry through the revival of fish stocks, as well as job creation and other market benefits via ecotourism. The value of MPA to mobile species is unknown.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:14AM (#44288085)
"Bottom trawling in seas globally emits as much carbon as aviation, and in Europe costs society up to €11 billion annually while governments subsidize it with €1·3 billion."

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanplh/article/PIIS2542-5...

"A wealth of studies also show that bottom trawling generates significant amounts of CO2 emissions and is fuelled by government subsidies."

https://www.bluemarinefoundation.com/2025/05/07/thebottomlin...

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by toomuchtodo on Sunday June 15, 2025 @09:32PM (#44286050)
Greenpeace used to drop boulders into the ocean to prevent bottom trawling circa 2021-2022. Unsure if they still do. Fairly straightforward to solve for if you’re willing to drop chunks of rock (granite, non reactive) or concrete in the ocean at the right spots.

Bans are nice, destructive force against adversaries works better though. Hard to take the selfish out of the human, so you have to engineer systems accordingly.

https://www.greenpeace.org.uk/news/live-greenpeace-boulders-...

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-marin...

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by noisy_boy on Sunday June 15, 2025 @10:38PM (#44286235)
I think it would be a great PR idea for a billionaire to buy a few old ships and use them to drop rocks over the most popular/vulnerable fishing grounds. What happened to rich people who were all not evil?
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by xingped on Sunday June 15, 2025 @10:53PM (#44286294)
New money outcompeted old money in the economic ecosystem and new money doesn't have the same historical fear of the proletarian guillotine.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:02AM (#44288026)
...yet.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:45AM (#44288269)
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by Grimblewald on Sunday June 15, 2025 @11:00PM (#44286323)
How do you think billionaires became billionaires? How can you extract a billion dollars of wealth in your life time, or even several generations? Certainly not by creating value. Almost certainly by destroying something else, privatising the profits and socialising the losses. E.g. mining, commercial fishing. Etc.

We will never see billionairs act as a force for good because the current system only allows for evil to create such a level of private capital. I would go as far as to argue such wealth disparity is not natural and is only possible through severe perversion of the natural order.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Sunday June 15, 2025 @11:27PM (#44286408)
It is natural. Unfairness is the basis of civilization.

In order to mobilize a group of humans for the common good they must be artificially incentivized to do it as the tragedy of the commons usually prevents people from doing these things collectively. Look up the tragedy of the commons.

But in order for a group of humans to be incentivized like that there must exist an authority with enough wealth to incentivize humans to work collectively like that. That means one authority needs to get unfairly rich. And additionally there must be incentive itself for such an authority to conduct that action in itself. So basically there must be some unfair distribution of wealth for any of this to happen AND there must exist strategies that can be exploited for someone to gain that wealth.

I’m not making this shit up. Literally in anthropology one of the theories about why certain places developed into advanced civilizations or not literally relied on whether or not the currency of the habitat could be used to accumulate wealth. For example fruits in Hawaii didn’t last long enough for someone to become a billionaire but grain in Europe does.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by croes on Monday June 16, 2025 @12:18AM (#44286583)
Unfairness maybe be natural but billionaires are artificial.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:00AM (#44286736)
Billionaires are the definition of unfairness. And therefore they are natural.

Only From the perspective of civilization, of course, which is only a small fraction of human existence.

From the perspective humanity overall, not only are billionaires unnatural, but civilization in itself is unnatural. Hence all the declining birth rates we see today.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by oporquinho94 on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:59AM (#44286973)
Sounds like something you just made up. Kind of moot to argue what is natural and what isn’t.

Unfairness or billionaires might be natural or not - that doesn’t mean we have to accept their existence.

You know what else is natural? To die at 30 from dysentery or a broken leg.

Natural is a nonsense category

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:42AM (#44289005)
You’re sort of confused. The person I’m responding to claimed it wasn’t natural. He came up with the category. So take your illogical argument up with him.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by croes on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:11AM (#44287022)
https://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/unfairness

No mention of billionaires.

Show me one billionaires in nature beside mankind. Billionaires now and then are artificially created by the systems mankind creates. They are an anomaly

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:40AM (#44288993)
This is just garbage. Not going to respond further to this.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by croes on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:35AM (#44289377)
You could just say you have no arguments
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:51AM (#44289501)
I do but your citation of the dictionary is fucking obviously not a legit argument so I won’t bother with you.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by croes on Monday June 16, 2025 @10:12AM (#44289678)
You came up with the definition part, and dictionaries show definitions.

Billionaires are an extreme example of unfairness not the definition. Otherwise most unfair things would be unfair at all compared to the unfairness of billionaires.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by koonsolo on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:26AM (#44287084)
History is full of people with extreme wealth and power. I would say our current political structures are keeping them somewhat under control.

Edit: So in that sense, I'm also on the side that billionaires are created naturally. When you already have a lot of wealth, the odds are in your favor to create even more wealth. So if you would just keep the system running without much interference, wealth will naturally accumulate to those who already have a lot. Therefore, we need political structures to keep that under control.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by sho on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:27AM (#44286837)
Has it occurred to you that the narrative you're repeating here is awfully convenient for the elite? Don't question their wealth - don't you know civilization itself depends on it!

> I’m not making this shit up. Literally in anthropology one of the theories

It's a theory, yes. And there's another theory which says that's all BS invented by the ruling classes over time - the church and kings back in the day, the billionaires these days - to justify their otherwise quite unjustifiable positions, cloak them in mumbo-jumbo about natural law or what not, with the goal of discouraging questioning of the status quo.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:57AM (#44287228)
The theory I'm regurgitating is from academia. The opposite of wealth.

I hate billionaires. I think it's unfair. But I'm also scientific. That means if unfair and unequal distribution of wealth is what resulted in civilization we need to admit it.

But that doesn't mean we need to worship billionaires. Civilization is built off of blood and corruption. That doesn't make the blood and corruption justified.

If you want to deal with wealth inequality then why don't we just fight for communism? Communism is the ideal theory for fair wealth distribution. But what happens when we go for the ideal? Reality hits. Communism works in theory BUT not in reality. It's an idealist fantasy concept.

The big question here is that how do we meet our ideals WHILE NOT ignoring REALITY. Like ok, so a billionaire loves what I'm saying. I don't give a shit. To hell with him. We need to attack problems with the truth. Not some fantasy witch hunt bs trying to build a utopia that isn't inline with reality.

So maybe something in between works right? Not communism, you need a bit of inequality. But maybe not too much. What system like that has worked? Do we have examples? I mean Elon is a billionaire ass hole, that much is true, but the allowance of the existence of such billionaire ass holes in the United States has also allowed the existence of rocket catching technology never seen before by the likes of mankind. What's the tradeoff? Do we know? Are we examining the full reality of it? Maybe if we taxed billionaires like crazy and reduced them to millionaires... maybe the rocket catching technology would've still existed... Do we know? No. We don't But let's not blind ourselves to reality before we know.

One thing is for sure: wealth inequality is RESPONSIBLE for civilization. Are you rational enough to be impartial about this or are you so against wealth inequality that you can't even look at the good parts of it.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by marcus_holmes on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:05AM (#44286998)
This is very "theory X" - the theory that people only work or do anything if someone in authority forces them to.

The other theory, "Theory Y" says that people work because that's what people do, and the function of authority is more about guidance and removal of blockages.

I'm a Theory Y believer, and believe that people work together to improve their lives without needing an authority or any compulsion. I believe that the incentive for people to work together for the common good, is the common good. That alone is enough incentive. I believe that authority tends to enrich itself and work against the common good. Less authority is better.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:40AM (#44287141)
You're saying this because you actually don't understand a huge part of what I'm talking about: The tragedy of the commons. You didn't look it up, so your answer here is completely mistaken. MY entire ARGUMENT is based on that, and that is EXACTLY what theory Y is. It is the negative consequence of theory Y. You need to understand my argument before responding. Perhaps it's my fault for expecting most people to know what the tragedy of the commons is:

The tragedy of the commons is a paradox in which individually rational behavior leads to a collectively irrational and destructive outcome. It is not a story about bad people doing bad things. It is a story about good people doing exactly what makes sense—and still destroying something vital in the process.

Imagine a shared resource: a pasture open to all local herders. Each herder faces a choice:

  1. Add another animal and gain the full benefit of that animal’s growth.

  2. The cost? Slightly more wear on the pasture, but that cost is shared by everyone.
Rational choice says: add another animal. You gain, others share the cost.

But now every herder thinks this way. They all add more animals. Soon, the pasture is overgrazed. The grass dies. The system collapses. Everyone loses—including the ones who were just “doing what made sense.”

Let’s be crystal clear:

  1. Individually: Adding another animal is logical. The gain is personal.

  2. Collectively: If everyone does it, the shared resource is destroyed.

  3. Result: Rational behavior by all leads to a guaranteed catastrophe.
This is not about greed or malice. It’s about structure. It’s a situation where doing the right thing for yourself creates the wrong outcome for everyone.

The tragedy of the commons is not a flaw in people. It is a flaw in unregulated systems.

It is inescapable unless external mechanisms change the incentives. And that is what makes it truly tragic: it unfolds from reason itself.

That external MECHANISM is what I mean by AUTHORITY. You need some law to control it. The tragedy of the commons is the reason to almost all the environmental problems we face on earth today. Overfishing, global warming, pollution. Why do you drive a car when you know it harms the earth? What exactly is being DONE to make it so you don't harm the earth. Is it your individual choice, or are people in positions of AUTHORITY pushing for it and trying to save the earth by changing the law and changing the underlying infrastructure. I assure you, if authority wasn't part of the equation there's no hope of stopping global warming.

You and I are exactly talking about theory Y.

Now. That being said. What happens when you let theory Y run rampant? That's pre-civilization anarchy. Hunter-Gatherer groups because of: No authority. Make sense? I mean think about it. What group in all of human civilization has Zero authority? Hunter-Gather groups. Groups that were NEVER part of civilization in the first place.

If you have authority you can start controlling people and making people build things that kick start civilization. Canals, public works, all things that they wouldn't build on their own because of the tragedy of the commons.

This isn't even a personal opinion I'm talking about here. This is academic opinion. People who study these things say what I'm saying and all I'm doing is regurgitating it. But, of course arm chair expert marcus_holmes knows best and can trump all of academia with theory Y.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by marcus_holmes on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:50AM (#44287465)
I wrote out a whole response but decided not to bother replying to this post. I'm not an armchair expert and this kind of ad-hominem bullshit is not worth wasting my time on.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:16AM (#44287576)
Your previous response and this one was just garbage. Just flippantly dismissed all of what I wrote and came up with a response that showed you wrote it without even understanding half of what I’m talking about. Additionally saying I’m just randomly applying a theory out of some arbitrary choice is just offensive. Did I not say this is academia? This is the study of anthropology? Don’t play this as if you have some moral high ground when your response was rude.

I’m not interested in your reply because I think it’s dishonest. You clearly didn’t know what was going on and now you’re just trying to defend a position. You’re not charitably exploring a concept or idea.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by floydnoel on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:10AM (#44288798)
some of us understand that tragedy of the commons situations are almost exclusively caused by governments themselves.

more authority doesn't help in those situations, it is the root of the problem.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:40AM (#44288988)
Governments cause it? Why don’t you read the paper and the actual theory before making up shit.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ds_ on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:59AM (#44286972)
Not sure why you're being downvoted, because you're absolutely right.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by adastra22 on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:53AM (#44287204)
The current top-10 billionaires on Forbes' list all got rich by creating value, though some like Larry Ellison certainly did both.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by McDyver on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:33AM (#44287374)
I don't agree. They didn't get rich by creating value. They might have created value, but they got rich by keeping that value to themselves.

I would also argue that they don't create the value themselves, but their workers do. Just like that joke: a worker is admiring the boss's Ferrari, and the boss tells him "if you continue working hard, next tear I'll have 2"

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by koonsolo on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:25PM (#44291520)
I'm freelance, which means I'm my own boss working for a bigger company.

So do I fall in the category of being exploited, or do I fall into keeping all the value for myself?

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by borski on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:32PM (#44292142)
> They didn't get rich by creating value. They might have created value…

Odd to contradict yourself with only a period separating the contradictory statements.

> I would also argue that they don't create the value themselves, but their workers do.

Sure, that’s fair - but those workers also have jobs and salaries because of risk the founders took to de-risk the company before the employees joined.

The level of risk required is not everyone’s cup of tea.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by nagaiaida on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @02:08AM (#44296151)
why pretend to have found a contradiction when a stronger reading of the comment is clearly that it meant to highlight the distinction between the creation of that value and its consolidation primarily into an individual's personal wealth?
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by borski on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @12:44PM (#44301090)
Because it is paradoxical on its face. Many people like to argue that founders (or rich people, or billionaires, or whatever) don’t create real value, but simultaneously discount all the jobs they created and products they produced, because it is convenient to do so when it fits your narrative.

Yes, I’m all for co-op structures, but there is a big difference between “created no value” and “created lots of value but kept the majority of profits for themselves.”

If they’ve created 1000 jobs; is that value? Surely to those 1000 employed people, it is.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by slifin on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:35AM (#44287385)
Remember Forbes list is a marketing device

Do not treat it like the real list of world's richest people

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by adastra22 on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:11AM (#44287559)
Yes these numbers are peanuts compared to the Rothschilds and Saudis of the world. But the question was about self-made billionaires, which I believe everyone on that list is.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by notachatbot123 on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:18AM (#44287308)
I also create value but am not as rich. Maybe they extracted value from society by unethical means to acquire that much of it?
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by 4gotunameagain on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:05AM (#44287260)
Because this is hackernews, where everyone spending time here is a one-off genius, superior to others that deserves to be a billionaire.

Or at least that's the average tech bro mentality..

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by tomhow on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:35AM (#44287383)
This is a breach of the guidelines (“please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community”), but it is also inaccurate. Most regular participants on HN are employees, not wannabe billionaires.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by closewith on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:53AM (#44287479)
> Most regular participants on HN are employees, not wannabe billionaires.

You can be both and it would be interesting to see the breakdown of aspirations.

Certainly as the tide of public opinion has turned hard against tech and tech billionaires in the last 5 years, the dominant demographic on HN seems less and less aware of how out-of-touch they are with public opinion at large.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by tomhow on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:07AM (#44287538)
I read the comments here all day and it's pretty clear to me that overall opinion is weighted fairly strongly against tech billionaires and big tech company leaders on HN, as much or even more than it is among the broader population.

If you have a recent discussion thread or subthread that demonstrates that the “dominant demographic on HN seems less and less aware of how out-of-touch they are with public opinion”, I'd be interested to know about it so I can get an understanding of what you mean.

I suspect it's an assumption based on stereotypes about what kind of people would be interested in a Silicon Valley-based tech-focused discussion forum, but if it was ever accurate, and perhaps it was in the early days of YC/HN, it's not that way any more.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by closewith on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:20AM (#44287589)
> I read the comments here all day and it's pretty clear to me that overall opinion is weighted fairly strongly against tech billionaires and big tech company leaders on HN, as much or even more than it is among the broader population.

I think you're out of touch with public opinion outside of your bubble.

> If you have a recent discussion thread or subthread that demonstrates that the "dominant demographic on HN seems less and less aware of how out-of-touch they are with public opinion", I'd be interested to know about it so I can get an understanding of what you mean.

This thread is a perfect example. While there is debate about the role and morality of billionaires, offline this phase has passed and now people are talking about how to overturn the economic order and the resulting impacts on billionaires, to put it politely.

> I suspect it's an assumption based on stereotypes about what kind of people would be interested in a Silicon Valley-based tech-focused discussion forum, but if it was ever accurate, and perhaps it was in the early days of YC/HN, it's not that way any more.

I suspect you are insulated demographically if you believe that's the case. I think many/most people's opinions of how to solve extreme wealth inequality would be banned here.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by tomhow on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:45AM (#44287687)
Please don't make assumptions like that. I don't live in Silicon Valley or even the USA. Almost none of the people I associate with socially or in my family work in tech. Much of the work I've done in the past decade has been with farmers. Most people I know are concerned about the influence of the big tech companies and emerging technologies on society and about wealth inequality, as am I.

> I think many/most people's opinions of how to solve extreme wealth inequality would be banned here.

Nothing is banned here if it's expressed in a way that is within the guidelines. I gather what you're getting at is that outside the bubbles that you think I (and the stereotypical HN user) inhabit, there's more of a push to, as you put it "overturn the economic order". I see plenty of support for that on HN too, and nobody gets banned for saying it. But perhaps it doesn't get much visibility, because "overturning the economic order" is not really a new idea. The thing we don't see enough of are workable new ideas on how to build an economic system that gets the best outcomes for society and avoids the pitfalls that have befallen all the economic systems that have come before.

Which brings us back to the beginning of this discussion: the reason comments like that get downvoted is not because "everyone spending time here is a one-off genius, superior to others that deserves to be a billionaire", it's because comments like that are repetitive, generic tangents that stir up indignation but don't raise anything interesting or new to discuss.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by koonsolo on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:54AM (#44287209)
I would say billionaires create value just like any other entrepreneur, but billionaires take their profitability to the extreme. So in that sense, I agree they start to lean over to exploitation.

It's up to political structures and laws to keep billionaires under control.

Since wealth naturally accumulates to those who already have wealth and power, I would say it's a natural process. Look at history and how many elites had huge power and wealth. Just compare the richest man now, Musk, with Augustus Caesar, Genghis Khan, etc... . Musk is a nobody.

It's not up to the billionaires to keep themselves under control, it's up to us to create political structures to keep it under control. Which we are already doing (some countries better than others), and we could still improve.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by gorbachev on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:53AM (#44286943)
Ray Dalio is involved with Ocean research and education: https://www.daliophilanthropies.org/ocean/
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by TeMPOraL on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:56AM (#44287214)
> What happened to rich people who were all not evil?

Public opinion drove them crazy and turned them evil anyways.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by easyThrowaway on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:35AM (#44287384)
In a terminally capitalistic age (or whatever we should call the last 30 years, we are actually "capitalistic" the same way the URSS was "communist" in the '80s) being rich and being ethical are mutually exclusive.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by closewith on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:48AM (#44287452)
The truth is that only the evil remain ultra-rich as the rest use their money in ways that depletes there fortunes.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by GuinansEyebrows on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:05PM (#44291350)
> What happened to rich people who were all not evil?

probably the same thing that happened to dragons and unicorns :) can anything happen to something that has never existed?

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ljsprague on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:21PM (#44291478)
Bill Gates promotes vaccination which is in some ways the opposite of "protecting nature".
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by borski on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:28PM (#44292104)
They still exist. You just don’t hear about them in the news, because good news doesn’t sell ads.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by pyrale on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:45AM (#44287434)
> Bans are nice, destructive force against adversaries works better though.

The ocean is large, and the effort required to cover significant areas in boulders is ridiculously high.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:02AM (#44288022)
Just the possibility of boulders that might destroy your very expensive dredge might be enough.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by chatmasta on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:16AM (#44288092)
Won’t they be visible on sonar?
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:57AM (#44288347)
Not sure. But even if they were, do you want to have to survey the path of your dredge before every trawl?
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by chatmasta on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:04AM (#44289137)
I’d assume it’s pretty standard practice already. Your average Florida Man with a boat has a sonar showing the surface before dropping anchor or throwing fishing line… surely industrial fishing groups would know the area before they start exploiting it. But maybe that’s hoping too much!
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by Loic on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:52AM (#44287474)
You had this nice story about unusual "boulders" to prevent trawling.

https://www.wired.com/story/underwater-sculptures-stopping-t...

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:55AM (#44288337)
The guy behind this (Paolo Fanciulli) is a hero.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by abrookewood on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:19AM (#44286806)
That part of the film is horrifying. Like genuinely, sick-to-the-stomach horrifying. I can't believe that anyone would willingly cause that much destruction.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by closewith on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:00AM (#44287506)
> I can't believe that anyone would willingly cause that much destruction.

I interact with fishermen as part of a marine SAR role and there's a significant subset who treat the sea with contempt. Not usual to see them dump rubbish overboard in littoral areas, flicking cigarettes butts into the sea, etc.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by abrookewood on Monday June 16, 2025 @07:48PM (#44294388)
Such weird behaviour considering it is the source of their livelihood.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by baobun on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @05:51AM (#44297342)
Speculating: Perhaps for some they start being aware of horrible inherent aspects of their work/industry (such as in the movie or otherwise).

It becomes self-defence to emotionally detach and distance from the whole ocean at some point. With that, it can be easy to relativize and individuals cigarette butts.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by marcus_holmes on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:56AM (#44286961)
Stop eating fish. The fishing industry is destroying the oceans.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by t0bia_s on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:02AM (#44287511)
I like fishes. Fishes are healthy and main source of Omega-3 fatty acid for many.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omega-3_fatty_acid

Be aware of pharma propaganda that for sure support any narrations that would make benefit for them, like making any kind of natural sources good for humans as threat, like sunshine or.. Fishes?

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by marcus_holmes on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:51PM (#44294713)
Catching your own fish, and eating that, is fine. Even if everyone who could do that, caught the fish they intended to eat, the oceans would be fine.

It's the massive industrial trawlers that scoop up entire ecosystems that we need to stop.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by t0bia_s on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @03:19AM (#44296495)
Are you able to build your home? Or smartphone as well?

Companies usually offer products that are much cheaper to make than individuals would make individually. Which mean lower source consumption.

True question is balance between quality and quantity. But economically it is broken when fiat money does not store value and governments decided to make own citizens to live on debts.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by vonunov on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:27AM (#44287086)
Besides, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-04272-1#Sec3

>For rainbow trout, an estimated 10 (1.9–21.7) minutes of moderate to extreme pain (Hurtful, Disabling and Excruciating pain combined) are endured by each trout due to air asphyxia (Fig. 1).

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by fcpk on Monday June 16, 2025 @07:19AM (#44288510)
and that's why things like ikejime are needed. It instantly kills the fish and destroys its nervous system in the same way we do for cattle. It's absolutely unbelievable that it is not a common practice. And it also extends the quality of the fish and the duration for conservation.

I am a freshwater fisherman myself, and I do it on any fish I intend to keep, and release them very quickly otherwise.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by oporquinho94 on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:00AM (#44286977)
Individual actions won’t change the system, you need collective organised action
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by marcus_holmes on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:11AM (#44287021)
Be the change you want to see in the world.

You can only control your actions.

Also taking the action of starting to organise some collective action is a good thing. But don't continue eating fish until everyone else agrees not to, because that becomes self-defeating.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by ninetyninenine on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:56AM (#44289081)
Exactly. The tragedy of the commons makes it so that individual action of eating the fish is the most rational move.

Mobilizing people to act irrationally is challenging unless they are forced to do it by law.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by Nasrudith on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:33AM (#44289357)
That is a complete paradox because you not only cannot have collective organized action without individual ones but the previous is entirely composed of the latter.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by taskforcegemini on Monday June 16, 2025 @10:32AM (#44289924)
why not both, if the point for both is to reach the same goal?
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by yesfitz on Monday June 16, 2025 @12:56PM (#44291275)
This is organizing.

We're inviting you to join the collective of people who don't eat fish.

Our main activity is finding and encouraging others to not eat fish. If you'd like to organize more collective action, we will probably be interested!

But the baseline is actually inaction. First, do no harm.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by doktorn on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:46AM (#44287167)
TIL: trolling != thrawling
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by rex_lupi on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:57AM (#44287220)
Seaspiracy is another eye opening documentary.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by riffraff on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:00AM (#44287237)
Seaspiracy (like Cowspiracy by the same author) is pretty full of factual errors on misrepresentations.

While the core ideas may be right, it's basically a propaganda piece.

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @07:03AM (#44288388)
'Seaspiracy' is a polemic with little attempt at balance or objectivity IMO. But I think it is still worth watching.
Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by riffraff on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:57AM (#44287222)
what, how is it allowed in marine protected areas? I mean, what are they protected from if not BT?

I think the EU planned to ban bottom trawling completely by 2030 and that got nowhere, but it still upholds a ban on bottom trawling in marine protected areas[0][1], in addition to national ruling (e.g. Italy bans it near the coast and in shallow waters).

[0] https://www.bluemarinefoundation.com/2025/05/22/eu-court-uph...

[1] https://www.bairdmaritime.com/fishing/regulation-enforcement...

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by madaxe_again on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:51AM (#44288305)
People did indeed used to set fire to forests to get a few deer - you’d use the flames to drive them to a cliff edge, or to a river, where you would either let gravity do the work, or just pick off the panicked mass with spears or rocks.

Le plus ca change…

Re:David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story e... by hermitcrab on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:59AM (#44288359)
I guess you could get away with it when humans were nomadic and population density was low.