The options are to fix what are probably a whole bunch of problems across multiple domains at a cost of $(enormous sum) with a project spanning many decades (and which may easily be derailed and set back years and years at any time), so that living in the US doesn't make people gain weight, or... drugs, that work today. From a policy perspective, those are the only options. There's no good reason to think that reversing "moral decline" or whatever will help, since that doesn't seem to be why some other countries are skinnier.
- economics. Junk food is more available because processed foods last longer and can be stored at mini marts and gas stations. It is true that beans and rice are cheaper than junk food, but junk food is a very cheap way for a dopamine hit.
- time: people have less time to cook due to working and commuting
- urban planning: walkable neighborhoods are few in the US. Lots of daily exercise is foregone for this simple reason.
- culture: the US has a very pleasure-seeking culture. Given the choice of having healthy food vs gratifying food, we tend to the latter.
All of these factors conspire to get us where we are.
It's not a question of decline. There's no reason to think that humans today have less self control than in the past. We're dealing with obesity now because tasty, cheap food didn't exist until the second half of the 20th century.
Self control is a skill which requires practice. A huge amount of our time and practice is devoted to chasing immediate gratification. Doom scrolling, tv, ect. This is all practicing the opposite.
So another hypothesis that seems totally in keeping with the data is that either 1) some group of people have always had this problem in history, they just haven't had access to food like we do now, and/or 2) something about modernity is pushing those chemical triggers up to overdrive in more people.
Self-control really sucks as a solution to anything. When was the last societal problem solved by a national campaign of personal self-control?
unless we start dosing children with GLP-1s preventatively for weight and medicate them for attention we should probably think about how we relate to our environmental conditions long term and prevent patterns from repeating.
There are lots of people out there not living their best lives
It's not just the West.
"Obesity in India has reached epidemic proportions in the 21st century, with morbid obesity affecting 5% of the country's population" [1]. (It's about 7% in America [2].) Meanwhile in China, "the incidence of overweight and obesity among school-age children...was 15.5% in 2010, rising to 24.2% in 2019 and soaring to 29.4% in 2022" [2]. Same story in Vietnam: "The prevalence of overweight among children aged under 5 years increased from 5.6% in 2010 to 7.4% in 2019. For overweight and obesity among children aged 5 to 19 years, prevalence rose from 8.5% and 2.5% in 2010 to 19% and 8.1% in 2020, respectively" [3].
OP is right. "If everyone just..." is shorthand for wishing upon a star that the world were different. It's not a serious solution for reality as it is. (To the degree there is a social trust variable at play, it's in folks doing mental gymnastics to reject the clinical data.)
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_India
And you think that addiction is a moral/spiritual problem? Nope, it is an endocrinological problem. And precisely drugs like Ozempic have made it very clear, because it doesn't just treat obesity, but many other addictive behaviors like compulsive shopping or gambling. By "merely" altering hormonal balance in the target organism.
People once thought that smallpox was divine punishment for sins. It is 2025, we are on Hacker News, and yet the very same pattern of thinking emerges here, against all the scientific knowledge.
Interesting point. Addiction needs a drug. Drug needs dealers.
Thankfully, dealing drugs is forbidden.
Selling unhealthy and bordeline addictive "food" is défini legal though. Should we regulate this more?
> Thankfully, dealing drugs is forbidden.
This is an example of equivocation: Insofar as there is a definition of "drug" for which "Thankfully, dealing drugs is forbidden" is (well, minus the subjective judgement "thankfully") categorically true, it is not one for which either "Addiction needs a drug" or "Drug needs dealers" is also categorically true.
Treating addiction as a disease would probably be less violent and less likely to produce major human rights violations.
There is a middle road of simply taxing highly processed foodstuff more without banning it outright, but that also creates perverse incentives for governments which now have a source of income that they don't want to jeopardize.
Your buzzwords are useless.
What are you basing this on? Everyone I know who went on and off Ozempic kept off clinically-meaningful amounts of weight.
There is religious intensity to this popular unsaid (and blatantly incorrect) assumption that the human body left alone is perfectly made, and that any intervention in its mechanism is prima facie evil.
The human body left alone in a modern supermarket world is way off its original evolutionary envelope. I am a descendant of 300 generations of agricultural people and I still struggle with processing of milk. Most of our commercially sold foods aren't 300, but 1-2 generations old. We just cannot be adapted to that.
One, we don't know that. But two, it's fair to assume they didn't because their constraint was starvation.
Look, metabolic disease makes sense from a preservation angle. It's a safe assumption, in the wild, that one will not suddenly come across permanent sources of excess calories. So if one assumes starvation is the enemy, and the body finds itself amidst excess calories, it must assume this is a finite resource to be competed for. Herego, stuff your face. Build fat cells. And under no circumstance shoud you give up a fat cell. No, reduce voluntary motion and--if necessary--cut basal metabolism to ensure we can get these calories into our bodies before someone else exhausts them.
For what it's worth, I'm on the other end of the spectrum. My body happily burns away fat stores. This is frankly great in the modern world! But if I get seriously sick (or thrust into a starvation environment), my odds of dying are high--it's why folks with a mid-twenties BMI have a longer life expectancy than those of us closer to twenty. Not techhnically underweight, and with plenty of muscle. But also with less of a buffer.
> human body left alone in a modern supermarket world is way off its original evolutionary envelope
It's arguable that the evolutionary envelope was leapt off around the development of agriculture and animal breeding. (We're still on patch Tuesday from c.a. 10,000 BCE on lactase.)
What you are describing is so-called "thrifty gene hypothesis", it makes a lot of sense, but it hasn't been corroborated by actual genomic observations yet.
The problem with thrifty genotype is hunter-gatherers seem to have had less caloric volatility (if we control for habitat quality) [1]. So to the degree such genes might have emerged, it would have had to have been selected for during migrations. That, in turn, requires it be a relatively human-specific adaptation, which frankly makes me sceptical.
There is a lot of money riding on these drugs, and there is a story as to how we have got here. The drug companies that are marketing these weight loss drugs switched up their game after their previous cash cow, insulin, ran out of patent protection. Sure, they have got a new fix, but they care about their shareholders, not anyone's waistline. This does not make them evil, it is just business.
Standard practice for all drugs is to get them through the regulatory hoops for one thing, in this case diabetes (2) and then go off label, to get them prescribed for weight loss and now, fatty liver disease.
All of these conditions are one an the same, metabolic syndrome. So it does make sense to have these 'off label' uses, but you have got to respect the hustle.
If the article was properly researched then it would have outlined how that lifestyle interventions are preferable to prescription drugs, and that plenty of research papers have shown that Mediterranean and whole food, plant based diets (devoid of processed foods and animal products) have had some success at reversing fatty liver disease and enabling patients to obtain a healthy BMI.
I know some people throw a temper tantrum if a banana or a chickpea is placed on their plate, but the heart of the problem is lifestyle choices. Nobody is selected by a cruel roll of the dice to get metabolic syndrome, it is a lifestyle of car dependency, processed foods and saturated fats from animal products, probably washed down with fizzy drinks and alcohol.
Your mates that took Ozempic is anecdotal. Also anecdotal, everyone I know that follows Michael Pollan's advice to eat (mostly) plants has a healthy BMI.
Are you disputing GLP-1's efficacy?
> If the article was properly researched then it would have outlined how that lifestyle interventions are preferable to prescription drugs
This would have struck me as CYA filler. We know diet and exercise work. Nobody reading Lancet is confused about that. And if they're reading The Guardian and are confused about that, they're not going to have the ephiphany halfway through a medical opinion.
> plenty of research papers have shown that Mediterranean and whole food, plant based diets (devoid of processed foods and animal products) have had some success at reversing fatty liver disease and enabling patients to obtain a healthy BMI
Compared to GLP-1?
I have a sore throat right now. I'm eating lots of ginger and garlic and foods rich in vitamin C and zinc. (Taken with hot teas.) If it were to progress into serious tonsillitis, I'd be pretty pissed off at the surgeon throwing a honey-lemon tea reference into their briefing.
> the heart of the problem is lifestyle choices. Nobody is selected by a cruel roll of the dice to get metabolic syndrome
Sure. Yes. If people made better decisions in the past we'd have fewer problems today.
In reality we have a lot of people who didn't make good decision in the past. Their bodies are failing. If GLP-1 works, it works. Getting conspiratorial about Big Pharma or butthurt that nobody mentioned feta cheese and hummus isn't useful for the targets of such an article, people thinking about the health of their loved ones as well as the arc of public policy.
I wouldn’t call you cynical; I’d go so far as to call you conspiratorial.
That is, i wonder if the article possibly mentioned the eyeball-attracting names of the weight-loss drugs as more enticing than just saying "cut out added sugars and these livers may well fix themselves".
Call me cynical, but every article in a newspaper is published for a reason, and I think I know where this is going.