> Note that local -> local is not a local network request
So your use case won't be affected.
1: https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc1918
btw, I've seen that kind of network. I was young, and it took me a while to realize that they DHCP assign global IPs and double NAT it. That was weird.
The reality is that each network interface has at least one Internet address, and these should usually all be different.
An ordinary computer at home could be plugged into Ethernet and active on WiFi at the same time. The Ethernet interface may have an IPv4 address and a set of IPv6 addresses, and belong to their home LAN. The WiFi adapter and interface may have a different IPv4 address, and belongs to the same network, or some other network. The latter is called "multi-homing".
If you visit a site that reveals your "public" IP address(es), you may find that your public, routable IPv4 and/or IPv6 addresses differ from the ones actually assigned to your interfaces.
In order to be compliant with TCP/IP standards, your device always needs to respond on a "loopback" address in 127.0.0.0/8, and typically this is assigned to a "loopback" interface.
A network router does not identify with a singular IP address, but could answer to dozens, when many interface cards are installed. Linux will gladly add "alias" IPv4 addresses to most interface devices, and you'll see SLAAC or DHCPv6 working when there's a link-local and perhaps multiple routable IPv6 addresses on each interface.
The GP says that their work computer has a [public] routable IP address. But the same computer could have another interface, or even the same interface has additional addresses assigned to it, making it a member of that private 10.0.0.0/8 intranet. This detail may or may not be relevant to the services they're connecting to, in terms of authorization or presentation. It may be relevant to the network operators, but not to the end-user.
So as a rule of thumb: your device needs at least one IP address to connect to the Internet, but that address is associated with an interface rather than your device itself, and in a functional system, there are multiple addresses being used for different purposes, or held in reserve, and multiple interfaces that grant the device membership on at least one network.
Like, at home, I have 10/8 and public IPv6 addresses.
The proposal here would consider that site local and thus allowed to talk to local. What are the implications? Your employer whose VPN you're on, or whose physical facility you're located in, can get some access to the LAN where you are.
In the case where you're a remote worker and the LAN is your private home, I bet that the employer already has the ability to scan your LAN anyway, since most employers who are allowing you onto their VPN do so only from computers they own, manage, and control completely.
It would block a site from scanning your other 10.x peers on the same network segment, thinking they’re “on your LAN” but that’s not a problem in my humble opinion.
Yes. That's a gross generalization.
I support applications delivered via site-to-site VPN tunnels hosted by third parties. In the Customer site the application is accessed via an RFC 1918 address. It is is not part of the Customer's local network, however.
Likewise, I support applications that are locally-hosted but Internet facing and appear on a non-RFC1918 IP address even though the server is local and part of the Customer's network.
Access control policy really should be orthogonal to network address. Coupling those two will enivtably lead to mismatches to work around. I would prefer some type of user-exposed (and sysadmin-exposed, centrally controllable) method for declaring the network-level access permitted by scripts (as identified by the source domain, probably).
Think of this proposal's definition of "local" (always a tricky adjective in networking, and reportedly the proposers here have bikeshedded it extensively) as encompassing both Local Area Network addresses and non-LAN "site local" addresses.
fc00::/8 (a network block for a registry of organisation-specific assignments for site-local use) is the idea that was abandoned.
Roughly speaking, the following are analogs:
169.254/16 -> fe80::/64 (within fe80::/10)
10/8, 172.16/12, 192.168/16 -> a randomly-generated network (within fd00::/8)
For example, a service I maintain that consists of several machines in a partial WireGuard mesh uses fda2:daf7:a7d4:c4fb::/64 for its peers. The recommendation is no larger than a /48, so a /64 is fine (and I only need the one network, anyway).
fc00::/7 is not globally routable.
e.g. Imagine the following OpenWRT setup:
ULA: fd9e:c023:bb5f::/48
(V)LAN 1: IPv6 assignment hint 1, suffix 1
(V)LAN 2: IPv6 assignment hint 2, suffix ffff
Clients on LAN 1 would be advertised the prefix fd9e:c023:bb5f:1::/64 and automatically configure addresses for themselves within it. The router itself would be reachable at fd9e:c023:bb5f:1::1.
Clients on LAN 2 would be advertised the prefix fd9e:c023:bb5f:2::/64 and automatically configure addresses for themselves within it. The router itself would be reachable at fd9e:c023:bb5f:2::ffff.
Clients on LAN 1 could communicate with clients on LAN 2 (firewall permitting) and vice versa by using these ULA addresses, without any IPv6 WAN connectivity or global-scope addresses.
One internal site I spend hours a day using has a 10.x.x.x IP address. The servers for that site are on the other side of the country and are many network hops away. It's a big company, our corporate network is very very large.
A better definition of "local IP" would be whether the IP is in the same subnet as the client, i.e. look up the client's own IP and subnet mask and determine if a packet to a given IP would need to be routed through the default gateway.