Obviously cheating is unacceptable, but empathy can really help the student in this situation.
A disciplined character will handle hard times well. An undisciplined character will not.
Compassion exists, sure. But morality doesn't disappear just because something bad happens. Compassion should be sought after before resorting to cheating, not after.
If you are disciplined in morality and have a well-trained conscience, that will tend to follow you as long as you keep up the discpline.
Everyone is capable of murder in the right circumstances.
That doesn’t make everyone a murderer.
Citation needed. I don't think this is true, and if it was it wouldn't change anything. Notably, the individual level of circumstances required matters a lot, pragmatically even if you don't care in principle.
Think about training soldiers and the concept of “non-firers”. I’m not an expert on those things but the fact that training soldiers to kill is hard, and no one has a great solution even after a lot of effort, and passive combat personnel concepts even exist at all, I think gives evidence to the idea that not everyone can be a murderer, even under extreme circumstances.
“ Gen. S.L.A. Marshall once described war as “the business of killing”. And yet many war-fighters throughout history have gone out of their way to avoid it. Marshall himself estimated (though some say he exaggerated, or even fabricated) that only 15-25 per cent of infantry soldiers in the Second World War fired their weapons in any given battle. The rest were so-called “non-firers”; they had the opportunity to shoot at enemy soldiers but failed to do so. Marshall added that even those who did shoot often deliberately missed their target — they were so-called “mis-firers”. These “passive combat personnel”, as they are sometimes called, have long been a thorn in the side of military institutions. War is a “competition in death and destruction”, in the words of Henry Shue, and these individuals deliberately forego opportunities to score points for their own team.”
https://www.abc.net.au/religion/ned-dobos-military-training-...
However, the part you miss is the keyword discipline. To be discipline in morality means that you are aware you can be a monster and you actively choose not to be, even if it means what appears to be a negative outcome for you, relatively speaking.
Morality isn't free. It's not easy, and it requires diligent practice, aka it's a discipline.
By the time your in college, you should have enough discipline to not cheat. If you don't, you have a very untrained conscience.
Sorry it wasn't harder to counter your response. I would really implore you to change your perspective and attitude. Other people generally aren't psychopaths trying to take shortcuts. they are as i said, often just very desperate.
Like i said, others have similar criticism to yours but don't include this dismissive bit.
"In some cases", maybe. In a world where the majority of cases are effectively punished, we could start talking about that. Today, we live in the world where it's accepted, even when the offender is just an entitled college brat. We should change that.
Oh, and "but my boss/my friends/the president does it" remains exactly as valid excuse as it always has.
Properly aligned incentives need to be enforced from day 0.
It immediately replaces the ideal result, which is a true assessment, with a feelings-based assessment, and it undermines academic honesty for all students.
What must be done is to teach the students that failing an exam is OK, and help them recover the learning mindset. Evaluations are intended to measure the things learned and the things that need to improve. Evaluations are not a punishment.
This is easy to argue, people do it all the time (hello, TOS). So there is nothing incontrovertible about it.
It also contradicts the goal for pledges expressed by those setting this policy, they want to "strengthen the dedication to academic integrity" etc
Focus. The only goal here is creating a paper trail, and signing the honor code once does that and exactly that.
To me it seems completely congruent with your quotation.
And then there is face-culture, which assumes that everyone puts up a show anyway and the grades are created by a bribe competition of the families heads in some backroom.
There is a reason, why academia refuses to read a ton of papers from certain countries unless they get propelled by other trusted sources to the top of the heap. A mediocre, honest student is worth 20 fake doctors with accolades.
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1296860.pdf
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10805-021-09391-8
Instead of having a (useless in this context) knee-jerk reaction, you can read the links and find that the reported countries with the highest cheating in each link were France and UAE.
US and California are in the opposite side of that spectrum, with less cheating.
It’s not just about the reputation of the schools, it’s about society as a whole. A chronic problem in the third world is widespread cheating and low level corruption. The last straw that convinced my dad to leave our home country was a phone line installer asking for a bribe when he came to install a second line. If we don’t police our culture we will degenerate into that sort of behavior over time.
I am confused as to why anyone would need to sign a pledge to provide proof that they are aware cheating is bad. If you don’t know that by the time you are in university, then tough luck. One would hope a defense of “I didn’t know cheating was frowned upon” would get you laughed out.
Also, cheating in a personal card game might not result in consequences, but in a casino it could result in prosecution:
https://www.8newsnow.com/investigators/group-accused-in-225k...
Same with cheating in a spouse, you won’t go to jail, but it will adversely affect you in divorce proceedings. Point being that society has some expectations of people knowing what the rules are without people signing a pledge.
Consent forms are normal in whole range of areas, because society does not expect people to know all the rules that exist.
Trump went to Wharton.
Given a few minutes of thought, it's not hard to imagine one side calling the other cheaters, while holding themselves to higher standards (even holding up those "others" as reasons why its important to be honest). That's just how politics seems to go.
2) maybe the universality of team sports in the United States, where again winning is all that matters and if you aren't bending the rules and burdening the referees, you aren't trying.
3) this all gets cranked up based on socioeconomic stress, which also is being steadily ratcheted up each decade.
What I think teachers could do is to come up with truly novel and strange assignments that require real curiosity and creativity (and some do, which is great). I can only assume this to get harder and harder with modern AI readily available to everyone but perhaps the key is to assign something that would take a long time even with these tools. It should be as hard as necessary which is only all the more fulfilling to a curious student.
I've heard many a story about professors treating it like a trap door, paying no attention to prevention and much more to detection/punishment to the point you'd think they're sadistic pleasure out of it. (I doubt they are, but you'd have to numb yourself to it in that position.) In certain ways, I guess this is better than pushing people through to the next class—giving them no option but to catch up quickly or cheat more—but it isn't great...
OP mostly talks about detection/punishment, but I think it's also the job of course staff to make cheating as impossible as possible before it happens. Engaging and novel assignments are great; putting more weight on exams is low-cost and acceptable.
There are flaws in every method of measuring competency but I thought this was one of the better ones, and it is very difficult to cheat on. His exams were by far the least grumbled about and I don’t recall a single student that thought the method was unfair. And even though this required more upfront work from the professor he said it was ultimately less time consuming than grading written exams, and far more enjoyable.
I do like the idea, though. My parents from the former Soviet Union had oral examinations for their entire schooling.
What is the incentive to censure/eject a sucker, uh, student that is paying 50-100k per year for a social class badge?
These institutions are professional sports programs, have satellite universities in Saudi Arabian for oil money grift, use minimum wage labor for their putative core mission of education, have suspicious numbers of overseas and legacy but not legacy admissions.
Lost in the Harvard trump battle is the 50 billion endowment Harvard has, and how expensive it still is to go there, and how Harvard basically refuses to expand its enrollment.
We regularly catch cheaters in our classes; I do so every term and report all the cases I see up to the dean. In my experience these have not resulted in catastrophic declines in teaching evaluations; the few unhappy with getting caught cheating are drowned out by the 80-90% who don’t cheat.
It is actually critically important that institutions take cheating seriously. Rampant, well-known cheating can tank the reputation of a program or institution, or at the very least serve to cheapen the value of the degree.