News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by paxys on Friday May 30, 2025 @02:49PM (#44138938)
It isn't surprising at all. There's a reason why tech companies have insanely large engineering teams even though it feels to an outsider (and inept management) that nobody is doing anything. It takes a lot of manpower and hours to keep a complex system working and up to date. Who validates the backups? Who writes the wikis? Who trains new hires? Who staffs all the on-call rotations? Who organizes disaster recovery drills? Who runs red team exercises? After the company has had repeated layoffs and fired, outsourced or otherwise pushed out all this "overhead" eventually there's no one remaining who actually understands how the system works. One small outage later, this is exactly the situation you end up in.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by coliveira on Friday May 30, 2025 @03:14PM (#44139113)
Agreed, and that is a wonderful punishment to these companies.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by phatfish on Friday May 30, 2025 @05:27PM (#44140032)
Yup, it turns out all those Indian contractors/outsourced staff don't really give a shit.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by nebula8804 on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:17PM (#44140934)
And yet somehow Twitter plods along.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by wiether on Saturday May 31, 2025 @04:44AM (#44142916)
I never understood this Twitter thing.

- Everybody in their right mind agreed that, for what they were achieving, Twitter was completely over-staffed. Like most of the big tech co in this period. And like most of those co, they went through a leaning program with mass layoffs.

- If the service is running fine with only 10% of the staff, it doesn't necessarily means that the 90% that got fired were useless. I can get a 6yo to heat their food using a microwave. Does it mean that the kid is a genius, or that the people who made the microwave did it in a way that allows a kid to operate it, even though it's a complex system at its core?

- Comparing Twitter to an international eCom website is disingenuous. If "design Twitter" is a common system design interview question, it's not because the website is popular, it's because the basics are quite simple. Whereas, behind an eCom website, there's dozens of parts going on at any time, with hundreds of interoperability issues. You're not mainly relying on your main DB for your data, most of it is coming from external systems.

Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by cloudsec9 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @04:15AM (#44149395)
"The basics are simple" ... hrm. I think the concepts of how Twitter works is simple; but during their "fail whale" days, they had to reinvent things on the fly to achieve scale and reliability.

Twitter used to have lots of moving parts, and money flowed from various ads and placements, and that was much more complex then I think people appreciate. With their new head twit, they destroyed most of their ad revenue stream and are now hyping paying for APIs and posting privileges, and it shows.

My main irritation is that people say it "works fine", when lots of crap is broken all over, and it now has regular outages. They have shipped like ONE feature that was mostly done earlier since the takeover.

Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by chownie on Saturday May 31, 2025 @05:54AM (#44143159)
It turns out if you login-wall the site you can get away with a few catastrophic outages, people won't even remember them.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by gosub100 on Friday May 30, 2025 @07:30PM (#44140712)
They're paid not to. Disagreement rocks the boat, they get fired and have 2 weeks to pack it up and fly home.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by sunshinerag on Saturday May 31, 2025 @10:49AM (#44144646)
What does race got to do with it?
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by CobrastanJorji on Friday May 30, 2025 @02:56PM (#44138984)
Yep. It takes way fewer people to operating a working system than to build a new one. And the nature of capitalism is that you will pare down your numbers until you have the absolute minimum staffing you need to keep the lights on. Then when everything explodes, you completely lack the know-how to fix it. Then the CEO yells as the tech executive who responds by demanding hourly updates from the two junior devs who operate the site, and nobody wants to admit that they aren't capable of fixing it, and nobody's gonna OK a really expensive "we're gonna spend a month emergency building a new thing" plan because nobody's okay with because a month is obviously way too much time you need to fix it right now, and then three months go by and here you are.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by spacebanana7 on Friday May 30, 2025 @03:32PM (#44139260)
I get the opposite impression. Stale software organisations with steady operating products seem to use massive headcounts, whereas startups building new products often get by with relatively few people.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by esseph on Friday May 30, 2025 @03:50PM (#44139380)
Startups don't have to run a software stack for decades, hardware refreshes or SKU updates and replatforms, dealing with multiple types of turnover and reogs, knowledge transfer, etc.

Plus at least monthly if not daily, even hourly system patching.

Planting a garden is one thing.

Weeding it is another.

Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by donnachangstein on Friday May 30, 2025 @07:30PM (#44140713)
> whereas startups building new products often get by with relatively few people

90% of startups fail within 5 years so probably not the best example of how to run things.

The few that do "succeed" often carry over mountains of cruft and garbage code into perpetuity (for example Reddit).

Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by chatmasta on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:42PM (#44141054)
A friend of a friend told me about an organization that has a steady income from existing products maintained by just enough engineers to keep the lights on, while the other 80% of the organization is building the “new version” that no customer asked for and that nobody is currently paying for. There’s one product that is used by more than 80% of customers that’s maintained by 2 developers and that the CEO isn’t aware even exists.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by jemmyw on Friday May 30, 2025 @09:21PM (#44141206)
Ya I've been there. I even tried pitching to management that a small team of us wanted to move to the legacy product and iteratively improve it because it had customers and revenue and we could make an impact while the new product was under development. They said no. I left about 6 months after. 9 years later the legacy product is still running. I can't find any evidence that they launched a new one.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by nebula8804 on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:16PM (#44140930)
There is way too much disrespect of true technologists. I get frustrated with right wing 'bros'(eg. Joe Rogan and other online right wingers) who benefit so much from what the technologists provide while at the same time calling them a bunch of 'dorks' because they don't believe the same stuff that he does or because they push for progressive ways of thinking (ie support of LGBTQ+).

These same people also claim that "Real America" do real work like running a farm whereas tech people get paid too much to do nothing all day. So many people don't understand how much work and effort it takes to keep all these online systems running. Its only when you've been humbled by these systems as a tech worker that you truly understand.

Tech CEOs who are 'in the know' have a way of treating technologists like crap as well. I go to DEFCON and other conferences often and it's crazy how little all these security researchers get paid for their countless hours of work.

People like Musk who are 'in the know' used to get kudos from places like DEFCON because they were willing to just drop their car in Automotive village with an employee or two and watch others do free work for them "for fun" or for tiny prizes.

Technologists empowered people like Musk and now that he is nearly invisible monetarily and security wise, he shows his true colors.

I think the powers that be realized the disrupting powers of technologists early on and so they pushed nonsense like 'learn to code' to reduce their sway. Now the technologists are losing their power because there is enough desperation that someone will do the work for less money and less headache.

The only coming back from this is if there is a giant collapse from the vibe coded disasters that AI might produce + enough of these 'learn to code' people have already exited the industry into something else. Then I could see some power returning to technologists.

Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by levocardia on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:35PM (#44141016)
I'm sorry but if an enterprise team can't at least get a stopgap ecommerce site up and running in a week, what are you even doing? Literal amateurs can launch a WooCommerce site from nothing in a weekend; two Stanford grads in YC can do a hundred-fold better than that. Yes, a big site is more complicated, maybe there will be some frazzled manual data entry in Excel sheets while your team gets the "real" site back up, but this is total madness.
Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by donnachangstein on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:52PM (#44141098)
> what are you even doing?

Forensics, among a hundred other things.

> Literal amateurs can launch a WooCommerce site from nothing in a weekend

Selling low-volume horseshit out of your garage is in no way comparable to running a major eCommerce site.

> two Stanford grads in YC can do a hundred-fold better than that.

No they literally can't.

> Yes, a big site is more complicated, maybe there will be some frazzled manual data entry in Excel sheets while your team gets the "real" site back up

Great idea, we'll have Chloe in Accounts manage all the orders in a million-row Excel sheet. Only problem might be they come in at 50 orders a minute, but don't worry I hear she's a fast typist.

Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by chatmasta on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:37PM (#44141027)
Sure, but for every efficiently run company, there’s another with 80% of its engineers working on a “new vision” with zero customers, while the revenue-generating software sits idle or attended by one or two developers…

And maybe this is intentional, rational strategy - why not reinvest profits in R&D? But just because an organization is large does not mean that it’s efficient.

Re:When will M&S take online orders again? by ksec on Friday May 30, 2025 @08:48PM (#44141076)
Which means it is an opportunity for most of these to be SaaS and not internal. I wish Shopify could help them to migrate to their own.