News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by Herring on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:18AM (#44070948)
Vote for republicans => get red state policies.

Trump won the popular vote. America is trying very hard to become one big red state.

Red states have had the worst outcomes for generations but they keep going back to republicans. The reasons escape me. The Civil War was basically southerners strongly preferring to use slaves instead of modernizing.

Maybe China will motivate them to get their act together.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by roenxi on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:38AM (#44071060)
> The reasons escape me.

It could be the quality of the opposition. The frame of "trying to be a red state" seems a bit unfair, the message seemed to be more that voters were really, really disappointed with the Biden's performance as opposed to any specific draw the Republicans had. Kamala making it a close race was miraculous given where the election looked to be going in early June 2024 up to the infamous debate.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by eesmith on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:50AM (#44071400)
It seems very fair given how the Democrats follow Clinton's triangulation strategy to try to appeal to Republican voters through "red state"-lite legislation, on the assumption that Democrats would hold their nose and vote Democrat no matter how disappointed they are.
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by twothreeone on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:52AM (#44071407)
That line of reasoning is actually a classic right-wing gaslighting strategy: "the radical left forced us to act this way, we had no choice". No, voters made an explicit and clear vote of conscience. The democratic campaign may have been a strategic disaster, but the difference in proposed policies - for which the candidate was completely irrelevant - couldn't have been any more stark. The people have spoken. Everybody knew what they were voting for. Pretending they didn't is to disrespect the voice of the people. The majority voted for lower taxes and severely cutting government spending at the cost of higher import expenses, the majority voted for increased US manufacturing at the cost of high-tech jobs and immigration, for more presidential authority and less accountability, for more magical thinking and less science and research. Own your choices.
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by Herring on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:36AM (#44071335)
It’s not a black or white thing. You can be disappointed with Biden, but by itself that’s not a reason to just switch parties ignoring the Republican performance, especially after Jan6. At the end of the day, Trump’s “burn everything down” racist position was not a dealbreaker to the majority of voters, and that’s on them.

It’s much easier to complain and destroy than to create. It takes 30 seconds to cut down a tree, but years, decades or sometimes centuries to grow a big one.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by const_cast on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:36AM (#44094278)
Right but Biden's performance was perfectly adequate, and even quite good in many areas. It's mostly just propaganda against him and the left in general.

The left is bad with money, ooo. Conservative fiscal policy works, ooo! But if you compare the US on the global stage during Biden's presidency, we did quite good. There was a pandemic, people. Expecting nothing at all to happen economically is a delusion.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by tzs on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:26AM (#44070997)
> Trump won the popular vote. America is trying very hard to become one big red state.

He won with a plurality. A majority did not want him.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by the_other on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:30AM (#44071024)
> He won with a plurality. A majority did not want him.

Tomato tomato.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by LadyCailin on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:42AM (#44071080)
No, a majority either wanted him, or didn’t care. Only a minority didn’t want him. In the US, you don’t vote FOR a candidate. You only vote against a candidate. If you cast your vote for the Republican, or don’t cast a vote (or cast your vote for a third party), and live in a red state, then you voted against the Democrat. And vice versa. So the only people that you can fairly say didn’t want him were the democratic voters.

It’s not a good system, it’s utter garbage, but it’s the current reality in the US, and the longer people fail to acknowledge this, the longer it will remain like this.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by tzs on Friday May 23, 2025 @01:58PM (#44074981)
1. Many voters do not know about strategic voting. They vote for the candidate they think is best for the job.

2. A voter who knows their vote won't make a difference in the outcome due to the electoral college might vote third party to increase the chances of there being viable third parties in later elections.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by LadyCailin on Friday May 23, 2025 @02:27PM (#44075215)
I’m happy to excuse third party voters if, after the fact, it’s clear they didn’t spoil anything. In no case will I excuse the non-voters.
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by levzettelin on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:34AM (#44071035)
Ahh, yes, all the blue cities run by democrats are such a breeze to live in: St. Louis, Baltimore, ...

Anyone who doesn't like this must be a racist. Got it!

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chrisco255 on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:52AM (#44071136)
With respect to red states, they're the only ones that still grow:

https://www.bea.gov/news/2025/gross-domestic-product-state-a...

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by hshdhdhj4444 on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:12AM (#44071246)
> Real gross domestic product (GDP) increased in 48 states and the District of Columbia

> Personal income, in current dollars, increased in all 50 states and the District of Columbia in the fourth quarter of 2024

These are from your link. Where did you get the idea that red states are the only ones that grow?

GDP growth is higher in red states in that link, but red states also received something like 80–90% of the funding from the trillion dollars or so passed by the Democratic Congress and President.

Also to see how this actually plays out, compare CA to TX. gdp Growth in TX is much higher. But personal income growth in CA is much higher than in TX.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chrisco255 on Friday May 23, 2025 @10:46AM (#44073389)
Yeah ~1% growth is anemic while states like Arkansas are growing at more than 5%.

California is losing population at all income levels. Texas is growing. Meanwhile the personal income growth is about the same between the two.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by nebula8804 on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:22AM (#44071288)
Its all a giant scam:

Red states block anything and everything that could help anyone but themselves. To "compromise" Dems put investments into bills that help Red states in the hopes that something will get passed(Sometimes it still fails). Examples include all these battery factories being located in purple states so that those senators will be forced to vote for the package. Dems help out the red states just to try and move the needle forward.

Red politicians then get elected and further cut things that help Blue states. See all the medicaid cuts, soon social security, last trump admin cut the homeowner tax exemptions that mainly helped blue states, cutting tax benefits that encouraged companies to hire software engineers and timing it so that it takes place after trump left office.

Red states typically get more out then they put in in terms of taxes: https://usafacts.org/articles/which-states-contribute-the-mo...

The blue states are held hostage by the Red states because of the structure of the system(a mess left over from the post Civil War).

You can argue that Blue states drag the rest of the country kicking and screaming into the future: Ex: The California CARB mandates setting emission standards forcing manufacturers to adopt their standard for emissions, The East and West coast define culture in the arts that the rest of the world see and knows as American, top universities are where the future ways of thinking are challenged and explored.

Every time the Red side gets into power they try to claw back even this stuff so that the Blue states are essentially nothing more than vassals contributing more but getting little back in return. Blue states need a Democratic party that will play extremely dirty just like the Republicans.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chrisco255 on Friday May 23, 2025 @11:37AM (#44073816)
Battery factories are being placed in red states because they're still largely functional governments with fast go-to-market permitting and are pro-growth in general. Tesla built their new HQ (which is the largest building in the country) in Texas in 14 months, which would be impossible to do in California. It would take 5 years if they allowed them to do it at all.

Blue states have ineffective, slow, dysfunctional governments that tax heavily and regulate heavily. They also do indescribably stupid things, like Prop 47 in CA.

Red state / blue state categories have nothing to do with the civil war. CA wasn't even in the civil war, obviously, and for the longest time, they were a red state (until the early 90s). All of California's foundational industries (tech, entertainment, agriculture, aerospace, etc) were brought there when it was red.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by tzs on Friday May 23, 2025 @02:07PM (#44075054)
What in particular do you disagree with in Prop 47?
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chrisco255 on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:18AM (#44079658)
Criminals should be punished, actually. Legalizing crime or treating it as an unserious problem leads to situations like you have in SF and LA today, with window smashings and retail theft etc. highly common despite recent improvements in law enforcement.
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by tzs on Saturday May 24, 2025 @01:13PM (#44082388)
The biggest change I recall it making is raising the boundary between misdemeanor and felony from $400 to $950, but raising that is something that most states were doing in the first couple of decades of this century, with most going to $1000 or $1500. $950 is the 12th lowest.

It's hard to blame increased crime on that since so many other states (big and small, red and blue) have a higher limit.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by supertimor on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:33PM (#44082946)
As the other poster pointed out, California, in fact, has one of the lowest felony theft thresholds out of any of the states. In fact, it has the 12th lowest felony threshold in the union. [1]

Of the top 15 states with the highest felony thresholds, only 4 of them are Democratic states. Two states are purple (but have voted red in the last election). So, it would seem Republicans states actually tend to have the highest felony threshold amounts across the US.

It was actually Oklahoma who started the trend to increase the felony threshold in the early 2000s.

Do you want to know which states have the highest felony theft thresholds? It’s Texas and Wisconsin at $2500. In 2014, California went from a threshold of $400 to $950. In 2015, Texas went from a threshold of $1500 to $2500, so California’s threshold has always been much lower even in the recent past. [2]

On top of that, California actually repealed parts of prop 47 in 2024.

[1] https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/felony-thef... [2] https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/issue-bri...

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by yamazakiwi on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:50PM (#44076493)
The state was red but all those foundational industries come from traditionally "Blue Cities" that have expanded to fill the state as those industries have grown.

A faster time to market is beneficial for companies, but it's also an excuse to avoid quality, safety, and ethics.

Sure there are groups and legislation that slow things down to the point it becomes a problem, but with most things, it's about balance and context, but I guess it's easier to speak in extremes and act partisan.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chrisco255 on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:13AM (#44079648)
> those foundational industries come from traditionally "Blue Cities" that have expanded to fill the state as those industries have grown.

In the 50s and 60s, when Silicon Valley was founded, it was heavily Republican. David Packard was a conservative. Nixon and Reagan were CA Republicans. In the early 90s it flipped blue, partially due to demographics and partly because Gore and Clinton (both Southern Democrats) courted them and pursued pro-tech policies, in particular Gore played a role in opening up the internet to commercial markets, enabling the dot com boom of the 90s.

CA flipped blue largely because of migration into the state from Asia and Mexico, and a shift in industries and focus post-Cold War, as well as some trends towards environmentalism and social progressivism while the GOP became more socially conservative in the 90s.

> A faster time to market is beneficial for companies, but it's also an excuse to avoid quality, safety, and ethics.

A faster time to market is beneficial to human progress. By slowing everything down by a factor of 5 humanity shrinks in its potential, dramatically so, and it hurts the trajectory of our whole country in the face of rivals that move at lightning speed with no such pretenses. In large part, its just bureaucratic rot that holds back everything in the name of safety or ethics while we conveniently import things from nations which have no such ethics. You simply export the problem at the cost of long term financial, industrial, and logistical security. The Tesla HQ was built in Texas in 14 months perfectly safely and soundly.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by yamazakiwi on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @11:42AM (#44108032)
>In the 50s and 60s, when Silicon Valley was founded, it was heavily Republican. David Packard was a conservative. Nixon and Reagan were CA Republicans. In the early 90s it flipped blue, partially due to demographics and partly because Gore and Clinton (both Southern Democrats) courted them and pursued pro-tech policies, in particular Gore played a role in opening up the internet to commercial markets, enabling the dot com boom of the 90s.

David Packard is one person versus literally 99.9% of technical workers and innovators that held more progressive views of the future and technology.

>CA flipped blue largely because of migration into the state from Asia and Mexico, and a shift in industries and focus post-Cold War, as well as some trends towards environmentalism and social progressivism while the GOP became more socially conservative in the 90s.

This is just not true. Most large cities in America shifted blue due to population density in general and the wants that arise through dense population alone. I'm not going to argue with you but I can tell you that is very obviously not the whole picture and politicians position have little to do with how innovators and technologists identified politically.

>A faster time to market is beneficial to human progress. By slowing everything down by a factor of 5 humanity shrinks in its potential, dramatically so, and it hurts the trajectory of our whole country in the face of rivals that move at lightning speed with no such pretenses. In large part, its just bureaucratic rot that holds back everything in the name of safety or ethics while we conveniently import things from nations which have no such ethics. You simply export the problem at the cost of long term financial, industrial, and logistical security. The Tesla HQ was built in Texas in 14 months perfectly safely and soundly.

Texas also loves to cover up any problems they have, and had one of the worst power crises due to traditional conservative business practices recently. So if you want to compare examples we can, I have hundreds more about how ignoring ethical and environmental concerns is net negative for America and the world.

What do we gain by having an Tesla HQ in Texas? They literally moved there for the exact reason we're talking about. They wanted to avoid dotting their i's and crossing their t's and they can do that in Texas. Building a new Tesla HQ is not "Progress"

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by const_cast on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:40AM (#44094304)
Most red states are economically defunct, essentially relegated to be welfare states with those with successful economies support them. They let their infrastructure crumble and they barely resemble a developed nation. Ever just driven through Louisiana or South Carolina? These are poor, poor states. The people who live there know it - it's just dummies online who like to pretend red states matter.

The only exception is Texas. I live in Texas. We're actively self-sabotaging and have for a long time. I give it like 10 years before we reach California levels of COL and then companies flee to whatever desperate backwater state they can find and the cycle repeats.

But don't worry, it's okay! We have 1 trillion dollars of oil damage in the state so we'll have something economically productive to do for a while.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by Herring on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:06AM (#44071214)
I think you’ll need a better analysis (longer timescale, more fine-grained, more explanations - education, age, productivity, investment, r&d, immigration etc)

https://www.brookings.edu/articles/america-has-two-economies.... (2019)

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by aucisson_masque on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:44AM (#44071091)
> The Civil War was basically southerners strongly preferring to use slaves instead of modernizing.

I thought that was all northern propaganda. The real reason being that the south refused to be in a confederation where there was more and more power given to the presidency and the senate while the states had fewer.

The north of course couldn't say they fought to force these states to remain in the confederation, negating their right to self determination, and instead pushed the slave narrative which was really secondary.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by jccalhoun on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:11AM (#44071239)
If the slave issue was secondary is seems weird that so many of the states explicitly mentioned it:

>"Following the election of Abraham Lincoln in November 1860, the seven states that would constitute the future Confederate States of America before Fort Sumter was bombarded began the process of seceding from the Union. Those states were South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas. All of them formed "conventions of the people" to adopt ordinances severing the tie with the Union. (2) Five of them--South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Georgia, and Texas--commissioned delegates to their respective conventions to draft public documents detailing the reasons behind the secession. (3) Historians call these documents "declarations of causes," a phrase used in the titles of several of these documents. Although, for reasons unknown, Florida never officially completed its declaration, a draft of it exists in the Florida state archives. All of the declarations are explicit: maintaining slavery was the reason for secession. For example, the Mississippi declaration begins, "Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery--the greatest material interest of the world."

https://www.thefreelibrary.com/The+cause+of+the+civil+war+ac...

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by orwin on Friday May 23, 2025 @06:22AM (#44071534)
And even if you didn't have a huge archive to support the claim that slavery was the primary reason for the secession and had to guess, i would buy the economics explanation over the political one almost each time.
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by aucisson_masque on Saturday May 24, 2025 @04:49AM (#44079758)
That's interesting.

I had watched Ken Burns' "The Civil War" documentary and came to this conclusion, it seemed balanced and thorough but I guess I would need more digging.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by sky2224 on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:53AM (#44071145)
The Civil War was 100% about the Confederacy's desire to preserve slavery. The "State's Rights" argument is revisionist to downplay things, especially given the fact that southern states would be hypocritical and demand that the northern states enforce laws like the Fugitive Slave act, which directly went against the rights of the states that had declared themselves as free states.
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by hshdhdhj4444 on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:15AM (#44071259)
The States Rights argument also falls apart the moment you dig 1 level deeper.

Which Right were these states worried about when Lincoln was elected?

It was the right to keep Slaves.

So to the extent it was about “states rights” it was about the “states rights to keep slaves” ie about slavery.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by Jensson on Friday May 23, 2025 @07:40PM (#44077600)
But then they removed a lot of states rights in general afterwards, not just the right to keep slaves.

And today we have the result of that, and it isn't pretty, wouldn't you be happier if states had more rights today?

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by sky2224 on Saturday May 24, 2025 @12:27AM (#44078774)
What were some of those rights exactly?
Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by const_cast on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:43AM (#44094320)
As long as we're being bad faith, would you be happier if we had slaves?

I don't know man, things seem pretty fucking fantastic today all things considered.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by thrance on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:34AM (#44071323)
You're talking about "Lost Cause Theory" [1], a negationist re-narrativization of the Civil War. Any serious Historian will tell you the Civil War was 100% about slavery if you ask them.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Cause_of_the_Confederacy

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by defrost on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:50AM (#44071131)
Sounds like you have a wikipedia article to heavily edit to bring into line with your thinking:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origins_of_the_American_Civil_...

For the several decades I've been alive and reading multiple takes on history slavery has always featured as one of the major three causes of the US Civil War for the majority of historians of note.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chneu on Friday May 23, 2025 @10:44AM (#44073369)
Conservatives and a lot of moderates are single issue voters.

As long as trump protects babies or props up the right religious ideology, they're fine with everything else.

I recently read "Strangers in their own Land". The author interviewed hundreds of conservatives in the south. The jist was that as Christians they should protect the environment, but the oil refinery will bring jobs. The jobs are more important. So they'll vote for the jobs.

It's really that simple. Republicans have mastered single issue stances. They don't need to be honest or trustworthy.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by Herring on Friday May 23, 2025 @04:15PM (#44076239)
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/america-has-two-economies.... (2019)

Going by that analysis (specifically age, education, immigration) it looks kinda like massive brain drain from red to blue areas. Single issue voting is a low-nuance likely low-iq thing.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chneu on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:54PM (#44112375)
This is exactly what conservatives say. That colleges are cesspools of woke liberal ideology.

What that really means is colleges give people experiences that aren't possible in conservative areas. Then those people don't return because living in conservative areas sucks.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by seec on Saturday May 24, 2025 @02:19AM (#44079140)
Maybe you lack perspective because you have been confortable your whole life?

What use does "the environment" have if you cannot afford to live? The jobs necessarily come before the environment because they are the requirement for survival that makes any of it matter.

Only rich self-righteous people can afford to care about the environment and the irony is that those people are rich and can do a lot of posturing around these issues, precisely because those poor people exist to take those jobs.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by Herring on Saturday May 24, 2025 @03:01AM (#44079286)
> What use does "the environment" have if you cannot afford to live?

There are plenty of extremely poor people in the world who don’t use that as an excuse to try destroy others - and often themselves. Plenty. Travel and you’ll meet a few. Selling your soul to the devil is always a choice.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by seec on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:05AM (#44085667)
You are misrepresenting exploitation of local ressources as "selling your soul to the devil". This is such a bad faith way to present the situation. There is absolutely no plan to "destroy others" the fact that you try to argue that this is one of their goals is just bonkers.

The externalities around oil are not just local but also global, so if they accept to deal with the consequences locally because they think the benefits are superior, who are you to judge in their place. It's not like if they refuse to drill and get the oil, someone else won't provide it to the market from somewhere else. They would be subjected to the global externalities just as well but zero benefits and just avoidance of local externalities (which they could at least control somewhat).

You are speaking as if they are simple-minded and this is an easy problem. The only one over-simplifying things there, is you.

Are you supposed to be a "well-traveled" person? If that is the case, one could argue that it comes with the side effect of dishonesty and bad faith arguments.

You should get dumped with no money/ressource somewhere in Africa (let's say Congo) to see how long it takes you to start working on a cobalt mine or something similar to survive.

Pretending to have the moral high-ground is extremely easy when you lack nothing and don't have to fight for your survival.

Re:America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain by chneu on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:52PM (#44112366)
I grew up rural, poor, and conservative. Ranching, hunting, farming. That was me until I traveled and experienced people who aren't selfish conquerers who believe all their actions are justified if you just say sorry to god.