The number of accepted papers is absolutely currency and measure of worth in academia.
Both of which are currency.
Silly example: if I ever find out a prove saying that "P=NP", that will also be the title of my paper. No cleverness required to grab attention.
If I have a more pedestrian result, I'll think up some clever title.
Another reason might be that clever titles stand out as bold claims, working counter to the common practice of academic humility. If a paper seems to be downplaying its own significance, then why should a casual reader (or reviewer, at first impression) give it the benefit of the doubt?
That's not to say that papers should over-claim, and I suspect that doing so might lead to a harsh counter-reaction from reviewers who feel like they've been set up to have their time wasted. Nonetheless, "project confidence" might be good practice in academia as well as one's social life.
This tends to not manifest as "We need one of these" but "If we have one of these, lets be sure to use it."
Evaluators are human.
This article is spot on. what are you talking about? have you ever published a research paper and gone through peer review?
I think it's ultimately due to a lack of theory, which creates the expectation that the results from trying an idea will be a random draw. From that point, you get the behaviors of trying as much as possible and taking each attempt as a fixed object to then go try and get over the threshold.
> Could you imagine someone saying, "be sure that the graphic for the molecule in figure 1 is 3D and has bright colors?"
I doubt the reviewers asked for that, but yes that kind of thing happens all the time prior to publishing and there’s nothing wrong with it. If it reduces the amount of time it takes to understand the paper then do it..
Chemists are extremely brand-aware regarding their figures.
In synthetic chemistry many chemists could guess the author based just on the color scheme of the paper's figures.
For instance, look at the consistency here: https://macmillan.princeton.edu/publications/
And it comes with rewards! The above lab is synonymous with several popular techniques (one, organocatalysis, which garnered a Nobel prize) - the association would be much less strong if the lab hadn't kept a consistent brand over so many years.
The most disturbing thing about it is the way advice to forget about science and optimize for the process is mixed with standard tips for good communication. It shows that the community is so far gone that they don't see the difference.
If anyone needs a point of reference, just look at an algorithms and data structures journal to see what life is like with a typical rather than extreme level of problems.