News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by WarOnPrivacy on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:11PM (#44024996)
It occurs to me that Efilists don't need to do much of anything.

Normies (us) are making parenting more untenable every year.

    My parents (and their gen) parented some hours a week.
    My kids required 24/7 adulting. Free-ranging was eradicated by 
    car culture and trespassing culture. Adult-free peer time
    - where critical social and personal growth happened - 
    was replaced with a series adult-curated, adult-populated boxes.
    Kids spend their days moving from one box to the next.

    Compounding the above is the difficulty/impossibility for a 
    modern couple to fully support themselves on two typical wages.
I don't know that we need any Efilist's help to end procreation.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by skissane on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:40PM (#44025144)
If normies don't procreate, then the non-normies will – e.g. high TFR ultra-conservative religious minorities such as the Amish, ultra-Orthodox Jews, traditionalist Catholics, quiverfull Evangelicals, Salafists, Velayat-e Faqih Shi'a, etc

You may eventually find that the normies dwindle and begin to die out, while the non-normies grow and spread and spread – those non-normies may eventually become the new normies

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by seangrogg on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:59PM (#44025260)
That's how societies evolve. If you want your "normies" to perpetuate or even eclipse your "non-normies" you need to give said normies the tools to actually want to propagate that into the future.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by scripturial on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:47PM (#44025185)
Interesting hypothesis, I’ve not heard it before. It would suggest that atheists and nominal/non practicing religious people would decrease in number over time (whereas in the pre industrialized world everyone was incentivized to have children because they help run the farm/family business)

If true, it would suggest a future where the world is much more religious, or a world that somehow deindustrialized.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by conception on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:51PM (#44025208)
It’s the plot to the movie Idiocracy as well.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by mensetmanusman on Sunday May 18, 2025 @10:29PM (#44026102)
This has already been shown to be happening right now.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by kelseyfrog on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:47PM (#44025189)
Some say this has already happened several times over.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by Murfalo on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:52PM (#44025216)
Evolutionary memetics at work!
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by wozniacki on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:03PM (#44025281)
This.

This needs to be repeated early and repeated often no matter what non-abnormal ideology you subscribe to. In as many words.

If you consider yourself a kind, decent & some what enlightened person and you do not procreate, in all likelihood the unkind or less kind people will do the procreating on your behalf. Mind you I did not even use the word tolerant which implies some measure of altruism; I'm merely saying kind & decent.

I do not know why people much older than us do not repeat this mantra more often.

I do not understand what could belie such intransigence.

What is so offensive about saying that line?

Say it early say it often.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rayiner on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:46PM (#44025182)
More resources for my kids.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by saagarjha on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:55PM (#44025238)
You mean more work for them to support all the retirees.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rayiner on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:21PM (#44025387)
Assumes that someone will support the retirees. Especially in multi-ethnic societies like the U.S., you’ll have a majority non-white working population with a majority white retired population. The lack of affinity between the groups will make it much easier to sharply cut retirement benefits.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 18, 2025 @10:52PM (#44026177)
The largest voter bloc will be old people, or soon to be old people. They don’t need affinity for each other, just themselves.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by skissane on Sunday May 18, 2025 @11:50PM (#44026380)
My mother turns 76 this year, and she’s still practising medicine - she no longer has a permanent position, but she’ll work two weeks as a locum in one place, take a few weeks off, spend another couple of weeks as a locum somewhere else, etc.

In my grandparents’ generation, people often retired in their 50s and had another 30-40 years left to live. If you don’t stop working until more than half way through your 70s, you might only have another 10-15 years of life left to financially support instead of 30-40, which makes it more likely you’ll be able to do so with your own accumulated retirement savings instead of having to rely on the taxpayer

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rsynnott on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:37AM (#44028312)
That's to some extent a weird doctor thing, not a general thing (doctors seem to often have difficulty fully retiring). It was never normal for the average person to retire in their 50s, however it is also not normal for someone in their mid 70s to still be working. You're talking about major outliers in both cases.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by skissane on Monday May 19, 2025 @07:21AM (#44028580)
It isn’t just doctors, my father isn’t a doctor (chemistry degree + MBA => pharmaceutical company executive) and I’m not sure if he’s worked this year, but he was definitely working last year (when he was 74/75). And a big reason why he’s cut back on working is his partner has dementia and she’s now deteriorated to the point he can’t really leave her at home alone any more.

And his dad was a tax accountant, and he had “trouble fully retiring” too. He retired from his job at a mining company, then started an unpaid job doing accounting for a charity. Then he retired from that, but still did the accounting for his church for a few more years thereafter. Yes, he wasn’t getting paid, but that was his choice, I’m sure he could have done the same work for somebody else and gotten paid for it.

If I’m still alive and healthy in my 70s, I imagine I may well follow both my parents’ examples and still be working too-having a job can be good for your health

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by saagarjha on Monday May 19, 2025 @02:50AM (#44027085)
I think there are plenty of reasons why retirement benefits might be cut that don’t require shoehorning some sort of ethnic conflict into the conversation.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rayiner on Monday May 19, 2025 @07:58AM (#44028859)
Ethnic conflict wouldn’t be required. But ethnic factionalism is one of the most potent political forces in every society, I predict it will play a role in justifying cuts to benefits for the elderly.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by saagarjha on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @04:26AM (#44039143)
Yes, but your whole thing is predicting that everything is ethnic factionalism. Of course everything is everything if you look at it at a macro level but there are a lot of other ways that we might cut retirement benefits, and I think if you look at current challenges they are mostly not ethnic at all.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by _DeadFred_ on Monday May 19, 2025 @02:59PM (#44033480)
Good thing the aging white population isn't doing their darndest to alienate the younger non-white population right as they are aging out.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by ip26 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:18PM (#44025371)
This feels like such a commonly missed point. Any “enlightened” movement with a notion of not having kids will by definition extinguish itself in one generation.

I don’t see this as meaning ultra-traditionalists are bound to inherit- I think it’s more likely the discourse would revert to the mean, aka the centrists.

But it also applies at the national level. If country A consistently makes having kids miserable, then in the long arc of time, the way of life in country B (which makes family life great) will win out.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 18, 2025 @10:47PM (#44026163)
> But it also applies at the national level. If country A consistently makes having kids miserable, then in the long arc of time, the way of life in country B (which makes family life great) will win out.

Country C which simply reduces the ability for women to not have kids will win out over county B, since country B is extremely unlikely. Even the Scandinavian countries can’t come close to being country B with a sufficiently large total fertility rate that beats country C.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rsynnott on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:33AM (#44028293)
> Country C which simply reduces the ability for women to not have kids will win out over county B

Counterpoint: Country C is presumably a totalitarian nightmare, which historically tend not to prosper.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by skissane on Monday May 19, 2025 @07:41PM (#44036193)
A century or so ago, most Western countries were "Country C" – certainly in comparison to what they are today. Did that make them totalitarian nightmares? A lot of people would describe 1920s/1930s Russia as a "totalitarian nightmare"; but would they use that language to describe the US or the UK in the same time period?
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rsynnott on Monday May 19, 2025 @09:01PM (#44036697)
So in the UK and US, in general, yes, it was absolutely terrible by current standards, but they were, by and large, getting better, and slowly figuring out that maybe the state should stay out of peoples’ private lives. You know who was really backsliding on this topic around then? I’ll give you a hint; think stupid moustaches.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by skissane on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @05:31AM (#44039594)
I still don’t think “totalitarian” is the right word. People called the Soviet Union, Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy “totalitarian” because they aimed at complete (“total”) state control of all organisations-you weren’t allowed to run a recreational club or a youth group without state approval. The state also put severe limits on your freedom to criticise it or disagree with its policies and claims.

By contrast, countries like the US and the UK at the same time, while no doubt there were injustices, unfairness, discrimination, even oppression (and they still haven’t completely put those things behind them)-the state never tried to exert total control over civil society or public criticism-which is why “totalitarian” isn’t the right word to describe them. And I don’t think whatever direction they might have been moving in makes a difference-if you aren’t “totalitarian”, you aren’t “totalitarian” regardless of whether you are moving “further away” from it or staying completely still.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by Johanx64 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:35PM (#44025462)
I'd posit that the people that don't procreate aren't and can't even be called normies.

They are outliers. One-offs. Selected out within generation. Where's the "normy-ism" in that?

It just don't even make sense.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by comrade1234 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:29PM (#44025084)
Previous generations just yolo’d it when it came to having kids. My parents were definitely not financially secure when they had us and we suffered for it our entire lives and my brother and I were a huge burden.

No easy answer. If you want kids maybe not think about it so much and just yolo it. For my wife and I we didn’t really want kids in he first place and we’re much better off for it.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by chmod775 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:42PM (#44025159)
> For my wife and I we didn’t really want kids in he first place and we’re much better off for it.

And that's the crux of the issue: Individuals in most western societies are currently better off not having children, while society as a whole absolutely needs individuals to have a certain amount of children or run into serious issues down the line.

Many societies (for example South Korea) are feeling this more and more. Way too many old people and not enough young to run the country and take care of the old. In those places not enough is being done supporting those who chose to have children for everyone's sake.

Foregoing children and having saved for retirement does not mean much if in 40 years you're competing for the now extremely limited basic services against people who are in the same boat. Worse, young people may now decide that they don't feel like feeding and providing for a large population of old people through sky-high taxes and being the victim of rent-seeking. They just might throw in the towel and leave for a more functional country, using their now higher income to support their own parents, but none of the others. Who now takes care of the childless?

It's going to be human misery on a scale you would expect to see in a modern society.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by comrade1234 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:57PM (#44025250)
It’s funny - I had lunch today with a woman from South Korea who has a phd in physics from Harvard (not MIT - confusing) and she said she “doesnt like babies” and will never have children.

Most people I know with higher degrees don’t have children even though they have the means to support them.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by chrsw on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:57PM (#44025248)
> In those places not enough is being done supporting those who chose to have children for everyone's sake.

Who is going to pay for other people's kids?

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by chmod775 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:01PM (#44025267)
Yes, that's precisely the mindset that's going to bite them down the line - is already biting some.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by chrsw on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:36PM (#44025470)
For many people it's not a question of mindset. There's simply no money to do that.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by chmod775 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @11:30PM (#44026322)
There's never been a time in the history of mankind when there was greater abundance than now, but we suddenly cannot afford children anymore? Maybe we ought to task scientists with figuring out what precious secret to raising children mankind forgot when we were too preoccupied with discovering fire and electricity. Hopefully they left us some carving in a deer antler that will give us insight into their superior budgeting skills.

I'm sorry, but that's absolute nonsense.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by ip26 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:06PM (#44025669)
At a national level, it’s hard to see how (assuming the country grows enough food and has other basic necessities) it is possible for the country to be “unable to afford” children, Baumol be damned.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by chrsw on Monday May 19, 2025 @09:18AM (#44029555)
Just because we have more billionaires than ever doesn’t mean a lot people aren’t struggling. Back in the day, someone could pay for a mortgage, wife, and kids with one job without a college degree. Where I live, that’s not happening.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by mensetmanusman on Sunday May 18, 2025 @10:33PM (#44026109)
A life contribution is on average $10,000,000 to the US economy.

Opportunity cost of a kid for the parents is currently around $500,000.

Subsidizing babies with three zeros has no effect.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by neilv on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:02PM (#44025271)
> My parents were definitely not financially secure [...] If you want kids maybe not think about it so much and just yolo it.

Same here. As someone middle-aged and thus far childless, I've been thinking that "just do it" would've been the way, maybe starting as soon as a couple years after graduation.

An exception might be career planning for the woman who'd be carrying, in some career tracks.

Other than that, even the US has various ways that young parents are supported, and there are safety nets.

While one is waiting for the perfect timing, maybe partly because one's parents didn't, most other people are busy having babies in circumstances no more ideal than one's own.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by ip26 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:13PM (#44025704)
There’s also a huge lag factor. Decide to have a kid when you are 24, and that kid isn’t in kindergarten until you’re 30. A lot of personal growth & professional growth can happen in that timeframe, improving your circumstances.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 18, 2025 @10:56PM (#44026199)
Not for a woman, who is will most certainly have to sacrifice professional development if she wants to breastfeed and “be there” for the baby’s first couple years.

A woman’s best bet to acquire financial security is to work through their 20s.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by delta_p_delta_x on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:33PM (#44025107)
> It occurs to me that Efilists don't need to do much of anything.

Quite. The fertility rate is plummeting worldwide. I'd suggest these 'Efilists' visit South Korea to get their fix of low fertility. Even the nice Scandinavian countries are struggling to get their fertility rates anywhere near replacement—they are all at around 1.4 to 1.5 children per woman.

At this rate we will erase ourselves in about 200 years.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by protocolture on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:47PM (#44025190)
>At this rate we will erase ourselves in about 200 years.

Hang on let me check how much horse manure london is covered with rn and get back to you.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by AnimalMuppet on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:45PM (#44025179)
> At this rate we will erase ourselves in about 200 years.

Not at all. Two hundred years is, what, 8 generations? (1.5/2)^8 = 0.1. We'd have a tenth the population in 200 years, so 800 million people. That may erase modern civilization, but it won't erase us.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by UncleMeat on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:33PM (#44025447)
The global population is still rising. Erase ourselves?
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by delta_p_delta_x on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:39PM (#44025831)
Perhaps I was being a tad hyperbolic, but yes, the human population is strongly expected to collapse after a peak some time this century. To precisely what extent is still debated, but there is consensus that it will happen.

Many studies have consistently revised and brought forward their 'peak population' estimates over the past two decades. In 2000, the estimate was around twelve billion by 2150. In 2025, whether humanity will reach even ten billion by 2075 is in question. It is highly expected that many sub-Saharan countries will reach replacement rate by the mid-century. China's population has already started falling. Many Indian states are below replacement. Nigeria—a good proxy for the rest of Africa—was expected to reach ~900 million by 2100 in 2012; in 2024, that estimate was essentially halved.

There is a strong correlation between education levels and emancipation (especially for girls and women), improved sanitation and health care (which means easier access to contraceptives), and fertility rate. This is what drove the fertility rate collapse in the post-war period for much of the West and East Asia.

Further reductions are a result of worse work-life balance (in the case of the 'Asian tigers'), a desire to enjoy one's freedom in young adulthood (coupled with a desire to 'stick it to society'), a lack of 'a village to raise a child' in urban lifestyles, and more.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by greatquux on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:28PM (#44025070)
It's true, though I try not to do this, I really try. But it's so easy for some kids (like my 11-year old firstborn) to just go play Roblox or Pokemon or watch stupid shorts on YouTube unless I'm enforcing some activity for him. And yeah I have screen time restrictions. It's a constant battle with him. We spend quality time with him for sure, and the taekwondo and drum lessons are great extra activities. But he only has one best friend he has regular hanging out time with, and one neighbor kid he knows that he plays with due to less people around us having kids. Family has spread out too, also due to needing to have dual incomes and car culture. So yeah all these contribute to the birth rate going down, but it's not so much parents fault entirely as it is the modern world's.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by jimbokun on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:41PM (#44025152)
Antinatalism is the default world view in most of the world.

Birth rates are plummeting and most people are far more passionate arguing reasons to not have children than the opposite.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rayiner on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:49PM (#44025199)
“Antinatalism” is arguably distinct phenomena in individualist societies like the U.S. versus collectivist societies like Asia. The latter were heavily propagandized in the 20th century to believe that lowering birth rates was key to societal progress. It’s not a moral stance against children.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by jimbokun on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:01PM (#44025266)
Maybe.

It’s striking that birth rates are plummeting globally across very different cultures.

It may be the reasons are completely different in different places, despite it happening everywhere all at once.

Or there could be common causes that are at work all over the world.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 18, 2025 @11:00PM (#44026207)
That is because a woman’s cost of having a child is roughly the same across all cultures.

Not just the biological costs and risks of pregnancy/childbirth/breastfeeding/infant rearing, but the financial cost that forces most to give up independence and have to rely on and compromise with someone else.

If I was a woman, I could see having one kid, maybe two kids. Having 3 kids? Absolutely out of the question. I would never expect anyone to do what I saw my wife do (relatively uncomplicated pregnancies with secure finances) 3 or more times.

And that is generally what you see, very few women having 3+ kids, and most with 0, 1, or 2. The large proportion of 0s and 1s really drags the TFR down to below replacement rate.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by rayiner on Monday May 19, 2025 @09:24AM (#44029622)
> but the financial cost that forces most to give up independence and have to rely on and compromise with someone else

Yeah, that’s the natural state of human existence. That you say that as if it’s something obviously detrimental is bizarre.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 24, 2025 @10:18AM (#44081288)
I am not saying it is bizarre, I am saying people try to avoid it because it reduces their power (obviously). It is the "natural" state when people don't have power, i.e. they don't have a choice. The change seen in the last 10 to 20 decades is what happens when people do have the power, i.e. they have the choice.

What is natural or bizarre is merely a function of circumstance.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by Johanx64 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:22PM (#44025394)
It absolutely isn't default world view in most of the world.

The reason people don't have children - most of them anyway - have nothing to do with antinatalism.

Having children simply would be a massive, major inconvienience, and would negatively affect their quality of life, income, expenses, career prospects, housing, etc, etc.

Ie. their decision making for having children and not having them is exactly the same. I want to, I don't want to (inconvenience, etc), there's no deeper reasoning behind it in most cases.

Plummeting birth rates have little to do with antinatalism, and is a self-correcting problem. It will - without doubt - self correct. You just might not see the change in your lifetime.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by jimbokun on Monday May 19, 2025 @07:45AM (#44028782)
How is that not antinatalism?

All of those circumstances you described were there throughout history. Yet people had many more children than today.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by Johanx64 on Monday May 19, 2025 @11:14AM (#44030741)
So you don't see the difference between:

1. I'm not going to have children because it's WRONG, unethical and unjustifiable to inflict serious harm and suffering (without their consent)

2. I'm not going to have children, because it will inconvenience ME, because then I'll have less time and money to jerk off and play video games, travel, etc? Or some temporary economic circumstance.

Like even if you don't have children because you perceive the world to overpopulated at this moment in time, you're still pretty firmly in the (2) camp. There's quite a lot of people that claim to be antinatalists that are simply in the economic circumstances camp.

And lots of things have changed now, contraceptives, less societal pressures, etc.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by jimbokun on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @02:48PM (#44044623)
Those are both antinatalist arguments.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by Johanx64 on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @08:59PM (#44047372)
Have you bothered to, you know, do the bare minimum and check atleast the vulgaris definition of antinatalism.... on say, wikipedia?

I'm not going to argue your private distorted perception and misunderstanding that falls completely outside of even the most pedestrian understanding of what antinatalism is - even the wikipedia, etc.

(2) isn't an antinatalist argument.

Now an antinatalist might try to convince a regular Joe-Schmoe not to have kids, by pointing out how much of an inconvenience it might be. And Joe-Schmoe might not have kids, because it would be incovenient for him and get in the way of more important things, like playing video games and jerking off.... or point out how expensive it would be economically and such.

Which means Joe-Schmoe does not operate on, or even considers or contemplates the antinatalist argument at any point, in any shape or form. Which is to say Joe-Schmoe would absolutely have kids if it cost him less, there were different economical social pressures and so on, or if he simply... wanted to.

Focal point here is the Joey-Schmoey and what he WANTS. That's all there is to it.

That however does not make it into an antinatalist argument, nor does Joey Schmoey think in any antinatalist capacity at all.

The fact I have to explain this also makes me suspect that... sadly not a lot of cerebral action is going here either....

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by mensetmanusman on Sunday May 18, 2025 @10:34PM (#44026119)
They aren’t anti-natalists, all the data from the people who answer why is that they are materialists. Having kids means less stuff.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by jimbokun on Monday May 19, 2025 @07:47AM (#44028798)
That sounds like an antinatalist argument.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by mensetmanusman on Monday May 19, 2025 @04:23PM (#44034406)
Only as a second order phenomenon, intent matters.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by Aurornis on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:52PM (#44025217)
Reading these comments as a parent is a reminder of much internet bubbles continue to exaggerate difficulties while ignoring anything that doesn’t fit the narrative they want to see. There’s a constant theme in the internet where people imagine the past as some golden era where life was easy and raising kids was a walk in the park. We’re supposed to believe that the modern era is uniquely terrible and raising kids is impossible.

Yet looking back, history doesn’t match this narrative. I’ve worked with younger people who get ideas from Reddit that everyone in the mid 1900s was living in giant houses and living a life of luxury on the income of a mailman (literally a meme that circulates on Twitter and Reddit). They all seem confused when I explain how my grandfather on one side had to work two full-time jobs, one of which was in a mine. My other grandfather operated a farm and still had to get jobs to make ends meet. Their kids slept 2-4 to a room in small houses. They worked hard and struggled. Kids were getting jobs in their teenage years to make ends meet at the house. The list of counter-examples goes on and on, but they just won’t believe it. They’ve been so convinced by the internet that the modern world is uniquely bad and history was easy mode for raising kids.

I think the weird internet communities discussed in this article are just an extreme version of this type of distortion: They gather together to reinforce some narrative, downvoting or banning the nonbelievers while rewarding those who amplify the message with upvotes, praise, and a sense of belonging. It’s scary stuff.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by mschuster91 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:26PM (#44025066)
> Free-ranging was eradicated by car culture and trespassing culture.

Add on top of that the disappearance of shopping malls, arcade centers and other "third places". The game arcades went during my parents' generation. My generation, we had electronics stores that had game consoles where one could play some car race game or whatnot against a friend. Today's youth? They got to deal with "mosquito youth repellent".

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by wlesieutre on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:29PM (#44025081)
The last arcade in my hometown hung on until 2003. Adults didn't like it because they heard someone bought weed there once.

Which was probably true, but the drug fear mongering was another big piece of making sure kids didn't have anywhere they were allowed to exist without adult supervision.

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by jleyank on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:46PM (#44025181)
What age ranges are you talking about? Assuming people go to college or university at 17-18, they can complete their teen years breaking free of childhood while learning adult skills. I did 8 years of that stuff back in ancient times, and my day to day existence and academic survival was up to me. Yeah, my folks paid the bills for the first half, then TA'ing people paid the second. The whole schmere was a pay to play deal but the good parts really outweighed the bad. Socially rich environment, it was.

Looking back, there is/was only one great difference - social networks. I played with computers from 13 onwards. Required going to a computer centre somewhere or finding a desktop minicomputer. In a car or on foot, but it was "elsewhere". The big advantage of that era is that it wasn't a solo activity. Weird society, yeah, but one had to be civil (enough) to be able to get help and access. Micro's ended that need.

Not having to be on line all the time gave me some slack until I got a handle on scheduling. In that I was (quite) lucky.

And I figure "joining the military" isn't freeing oneselves from supervision, rather the reverse. Is there still social agencies that let you go elsewhere and help out or have they all been branded NGO's and eliminated?

Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by lesser23 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:43PM (#44025165)
The term is helicopter parenting. Studies have shown children born after 1995 are significantly more stunted (they grow up more “slowly”) due to this. There are interesting consequences like, for example, the condition of college campuses and identity politics. There are also laws that punish parents for allowing their children unstructured, safe, adult-free time (the expansion of the definition of “neglect”). A great book called “The Coddling of the American Mind” covers this and more in great detail. These days, we have more than ever replaced the physical helicopter parent with devices.
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by scripturial on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:53PM (#44025224)
Where did these laws come from, why do they exist? My childhood (independent playing outside, going to the park by yourself, etc…) is not literally illegal, or did these laws always exist and no one cared?
Re:An Efilist Just Bombed a Fertility Clinic. Was This Bound... by jleyank on Sunday May 18, 2025 @07:53PM (#44025228)
Keep in mind that ancient times (60's and 70's) also saw save-somebody's-ass politics. There's been a strong undercurrent of (counter)culture on campuses since then. Perhaps that was always the case, as the students would be the ones being shot on the barricades. At least that's why musicals and histories say.

Perhaps the lack of an external threat or insufficient motivation vs. failure leads to a lack of focus? Certainly, helicoptering does horrible things to the younger participants. Might that see-saw from generation to generation, or have we not seen those participants becoming parents yet?

I recall "good luck, we'll do all we can do to help you. F*ck up, and you're on your own...".