News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by ecshafer on Thursday May 15, 2025 @03:58PM (#43998721)
As a father, the idea of being told my 1 week old baby is going to die would be my worst nightmare. The fact these doctors and scientists saved this childs life is a monument to modern medical science. This is absolutely insane. Hopefully the child doesnt need a liver transplant, but this is a great leap forward.
[dead]
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by pizzathyme on Thursday May 15, 2025 @04:58PM (#43999275)
In real life, anyone who is a parent knows you would welcome a better chance for your child without hesitation
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by Sammi on Thursday May 15, 2025 @04:56PM (#43999262)
Delete your comment. You're minimising the death of children.

Yeah I'm sensitive about this. I like many other parents of children who have been lost to genetic disease have good reason to be.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by mattcantstop on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:03PM (#43999314)
We can pause and acknowledge that life (and what that means) will change, while also acknowledging that for many it will be the easiest decision in the world for it to change.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by thijson on Friday May 16, 2025 @07:00AM (#44003871)
I think it's a tool that can be used for great good. But also can be used for eugenics. That's why I pasted the link. It's a slippery slope. What a parent will do for their kids knows no bound.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tomhow on Saturday May 17, 2025 @10:52AM (#44014750)
We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43998721 and marked it off topic.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:41PM (#43999602)
But your child will die and that's a fact. Is it only ok to die after you?
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by koala_man on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:53PM (#44000502)
This question is logically sensible but considered emotionally abhorrent. If you haven't been tested for autism you should consider taking a quiz.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:14PM (#44000616)
I'm taking this into consideration. But I don't think the question is that horrible. As a grown ass adult, if you decide on a child, you also have to accept that the child will die at some point. This is how life is, no point of denying it
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by ecshafer on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:34PM (#44000735)
If you dont see the fundamental difference between a one week old baby dying and a 70 year old dying, you are beteft of humanity. One is a baby, one that is completely new to the world and totally innocent. The other is a person that has lives life and experienced life.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:42PM (#44000764)
Please stop with the ad personam. Can you explain how this relates to my question (and you could answer it as well)? Also, is death of an older person worth less grievance?
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by Sabinus on Thursday May 15, 2025 @11:05PM (#44001472)
The medical profession allocates scarce resources based on the amount of quality-adjusted life years it will bring.

Humans see value in living life, so cutting a life short is worse than a life that would be ending soon anyway.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tombert on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:46PM (#44000784)
A parent's obligation is to try and do everything they can to make their child's life good. I think most people would agree that living more than a week is a good thing.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by seandoe on Thursday May 15, 2025 @09:55PM (#44001164)
Yes. Yes it is.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by ecshafer on Friday May 16, 2025 @01:04PM (#44007685)
You are trying to frame this as pure “logic” but if you had read a single book on ethics or even philosophy you would see that’s not the case. You are basically asking “but why is good better than bad?” Acting as if you are logical but failing basic premises of logic or ethics. Any ethical framework is going to have axioms, typicslly these axioms are things that are inarguable for any person, namely its better to live than die, or to reduce suffering, etc. using basically any ethics system and pure logic you will quickly reach a conclusion that a baby living is better than one dying.

This really has nothing to do with the inevitability of death. Death is inevitable, however there is a difference between a child dying and an elderly person dying. A child has potential, they have not lived their lives. A child has not actually lived the full basic human experience, they havent had a crush, or fallen in love or married or had children or had any great successes or failures or close friends or anything, these things everyone does. An older person has, they are not a pure soul who hasnt experienced life. After 70 years you can be sad for the individual passing but happy that they have experienced life. This is why when a parent has a child they arent sad that their child will die in 80 years, but are devasted if they die at a week. The child never even had a chance. When you actually have a child, its an emotional and fulfilling experience, and to have that torn out so early is damaging.

From an empathy and emotional pov these things are so extemely basic and foundational aspects of being a human, a 10 year old from any culture on earth can undersrand this with no difficulty. And any person with even a passing familiarty with logic, ethics or philosophy will dismiss you as being earnest. Which is why people are assuming you are a troll.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by squigz on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:42PM (#44001379)
> that the child will die at some point

So what? So a father shouldn't celebrate medical advances that mean their kid doesn't have to die after a week? And if it does, they should just be like "Ah, that's life!"

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @11:13PM (#44001497)
I never said any of this
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by squigz on Thursday May 15, 2025 @11:15PM (#44001508)
I didn't say you did. I was trying to understand your point, and so was inferring what you could possibly have meant with your original comment.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @11:49PM (#44001678)
Oh, sorry. I definitely think a father can (should?) celebrate medical advancements like this, and definitely shouldn't undermine death like "Ah, that's life". My point is that people often worry about their children's death when they themselves are still alive. Death seems okay if it's when they don't get to see it
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by Tade0 on Friday May 16, 2025 @02:08AM (#44002274)
Death of someone whose potential was largely realized is a very different thing than the death of someone who never got a chance at the same.

I would be deeply unhappy to learn that my children won't live to old age.

Also witnessing the death of a loved one is obviously traumatic. People grieve their parents dying of old age.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by sedatk on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:47PM (#44000790)
Only 1% of the population has autism. Presenting autism as a considerable possibility for trollish behavior isn't much different than what the parent commenter did.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Friday May 16, 2025 @12:16AM (#44001792)
[delayed]
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by sedatk on Friday May 16, 2025 @12:43AM (#44001905)
now, confirmed.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by concordDance on Friday May 16, 2025 @04:03AM (#44002876)
What was the question? The rampant flagging here is quite annoying.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Friday May 16, 2025 @04:11AM (#44002925)
My original comment said:

> But your child will die and that's a fact. Is it only ok for it to die after you?

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by imacomputertoo on Friday May 16, 2025 @09:58AM (#44005618)
Is there more context to this question? I couldn't read the article because of the pay wall. But in isolation, this is a dumb question. All decent parents want their child to live as long as possible and be as healthy as possible. Is there something deeper you were trying to get at?
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tomhow on Saturday May 17, 2025 @10:56AM (#44014779)
Please don't comment like this, no matter how bad the comment you're replying to. The guidelines apply to everyone equally:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by koala_man on Saturday May 17, 2025 @01:26PM (#44015733)
My bad. I had been reading about how there's a frustration in the community that allistic people refuse to explain why such statements are wrong, and instead just repeat "you know what you did!" to people who genuinely don't.

I tried to be the one who didn't do that, but missed the mark. I'd delete it if I could.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by bigs on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:27PM (#44000007)
Hopefully after living a long and fulfilling life? Geez
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by morepedantic on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:45PM (#44000121)
Edgy! No one has ever considered the mortality of their children ever, or contemplated the difference between death before and after the realization of potential. Wow!
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:24PM (#44000364)
Genuinely don't know why this is edgy. I was trying to understand his logic
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by cluse on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:42PM (#44000447)
Having a child predecease you is one of the worst things that can happen to a person in general. This is a common sentiment in humans. The strange thing is that you mentioned you're trying to follow "logic." This is not logic. These are emotions.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:10PM (#44000594)
I understand this. My question arose from the fact that it seems like he only cares about the child dying before him, not the child's death overall. It was

> the idea of being told my 1 week old baby is going to die

not

> the idea of my child dying

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by viewtransform on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:37PM (#44000744)
"I am simply a machine. I do not experience death as humans do. It is just a cessation of function." - Data in Star Trek The Next Generation,
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by philsnow on Friday May 16, 2025 @08:20AM (#44004539)
It’s less of

> my baby is going to die, woe is me

and more of

> have I failed my baby so much as a parent that he won’t even grow to adulthood (much less have a wonderful, happy life)

It’s not exactly a rational feeling; it’s not like this baby was going to die through lack of parental effort or care or anything else that the parents have any real control over, so it’s not like they could have done anything differently.

Nonetheless, it can make you feel like an utter failure of a parent. To some people (I admit, not everybody), that is absolutely crushing.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by morepedantic on Sunday May 18, 2025 @01:52AM (#44019259)
>It’s not exactly a rational feeling

It only looks irrational if you don't understand what people and feelings are.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by bloomingeek on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:44PM (#44000458)
Not only a hurtful question, but a stupid one as well. Well done.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:12PM (#44000603)
Care to explain why it is stupid? And what's hurtful about it, too? Deciding on a child, you KNOW it's going to day at some point
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tombert on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:51PM (#44000807)
I don't really know what you're going on about? We're all going to die, we all know that that's going to happen, but none of us want to suffer and most of us would like to live relatively long lives.

I am not a parent but I think if I did have a kid I would try everything I could to keep my child alive and minimize pain in my child's life.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by blacksmith_tb on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:09PM (#43999846)
Typically yes? But surviving infancy is the first step on the road to immortality (but that will require more than CRISPR... probably?)
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by 331c8c71 on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:22PM (#43999958)
Immortality? (rolleyes)
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by foxglacier on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:55PM (#43999730)
If you're being pedantic, babies usually never die - they transform into an adult which is the form that dies.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by frankfrank13 on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:45PM (#43999637)
bro read the room
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tomhow on Saturday May 17, 2025 @10:51AM (#44014742)
We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43998721 and marked it off topic.

Please observe the guidelines, especially these ones:

Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents. Omit internet tropes.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Sunday May 18, 2025 @03:16PM (#44023676)
can you tell me which rule the comment broke?
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tomhow on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:26PM (#44025411)
I suggested a few that covered your multiple comments in the subthread, and also people who are sincere about using HN in accordance with the guidelines and the site's intended purpose have a way of demonstrating it through their actions. If you want to contribute here, please make an effort to be a positive contributor.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Monday May 19, 2025 @12:05AM (#44026419)
> I suggested a few that covered your multiple comments in the subthread

I genuinely can't link any of these to any of my comments, that's why I'm asking. I reread those a couple of times. I really think I've been polite, and I really tried to be, even when called "beteft of humanity", "earnest" and accused of trolling. I did not insult anybody, didn't want to and I certainly didn't want to bring anyone down. I just asked a question that seemed (and still seems) logical to me, only to get shutdown by mass flagging, now by removal of the comment with no real explanation what rules I broke and why I was negative

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tomhow on Monday May 19, 2025 @02:30AM (#44026988)
OK, maybe there's a cultural or language disconnect here, so, if you're genuinely confused as to why this came across as offensive, I believe you.

Please just understand that it can be upsetting to many people in the HN audience, as evidenced by the votes and comments, when the topic of death is addressed in this way: i.e., in a way that seems hyper-rationalist and diminishing of the way premature death – especially of infants and children – is particularly devastating to parents and loved ones.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:44PM (#44035749)
[delayed]
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by efilife on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:45PM (#44035754)
> OK, maybe there's a cultural or language disconnect here

I might be just shit at expressing my thoughts in English

> when the topic of death is addressed in this way: i.e., in a way that seems hyper-rationalist

This is why I kept pushing and asking - I thought that HN is all about logical thinking and not letting your emotions go through and think for you.

I don't know if you are still insisting that I broke the rules - you don't have to explain in which way I broke them, I understand that I don't understand. A simple yes or no would suffice, if I could ask you.

And thank you for taking the time for discussing this with me. Regardless of the answer for the above question I will refrain from talki

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by alexashka on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:09PM (#44000589)
We live on a planet with limited resources.

We should definitely spend even more of them on feelings of the very rich at the expense of everyone else. Feelings of the rich are what's most important, we all agree.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by silver_silver on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:23PM (#44000660)
What an insanely callous and shallow take. I don’t even know where to start. You’re trying to claim the moral high ground by complaining that a privileged child didn’t suffer and die? Do you even understand the point of reducing poverty?
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by cayley_graph on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:36PM (#44000742)
An absolutely terrible and tone-deaf way to phrase that thought, but the fact of the matter is that most of the world (you and I included, in all likelihood) will not get access to this sort of thing in our lifetimes. Not because modern medicine won't have been there yet, but because our lives (and those of our children) are simply seen as being worth significantly less than a rich person's desire to become richer.

How many people can even afford to get multiple opinions for a weird lump on their back? Or go to the dentist for a strange toothache? How many people can afford to get consistent exercise and eat healthy? How many lives would be saved or at least massively bettered? We already have the means to extend the life expectancy of the average person, and it's not being used. Obviously this is a wonderful medical advance, but it's depressing to wonder who it's for.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by piloto_ciego on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:29PM (#44001312)
So obviously we should not be excited about it? Lose me with that noise.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by cayley_graph on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:31PM (#44001325)
Do point out where that was said, and I will be happy to correct it! It's important to have nuanced opinions and discussions about things.
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by squigz on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:40PM (#44001374)
> An absolutely terrible and tone-deaf way to phrase that thought, but the fact of the matter is that most of the world (you and I included, in all likelihood) will not get access to this sort of thing in our lifetimes. Not because modern medicine won't have been there yet, but because our lives (and those of our children) are simply seen as being worth significantly less than a rich person's desire to become richer.

I'm as negative about the rich and powerful as anyone but this is such a cynical take - that might have been applied to many medical treatments in the past that have become relatively commonplace and easily accessible to people of all classes, at least in sane countries with sane healthcare systems.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by cayley_graph on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:49PM (#44001407)
Indeed, my view is heavily American-centric. And the trends of the past-- which you're right about-- may not apply to the future given increasing wealth inequality, the cost-of-living crisis, and the climate crisis (for which undoubtedly the poorest of us will be forced to shoulder most of the burden).

I'm explicitly not saying this work shouldn't be done, it should! But it does not exist in a vacuum, and it would be silly to pretend that it is not colored by vastly unequal access to modern healthcare. The reason I get excited about technology is because of the potential it holds for making us all happier and freer to do the things we like for longer. We are lost if we do not at least speak about the thunderclouds on the horizon for this philosophy of technology.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by squigz on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:57PM (#44001442)
> We are lost if we do not at least speak about the thunderclouds on the horizon for this philosophy of technology.

I think, every once in a while, it's okay to just celebrate without looking for the the clouds :)

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by cayley_graph on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:59PM (#44001449)
That's fair, I respect that view. :)
[dead]
Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by cayley_graph on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:45PM (#44001385)
Certainly, you may choose to conduct yourself like this. I won't stop you! And other people who might've otherwise seen your point will be turned away from it. I prefer to have constructive conversations with people I view as equals, not stupid or infantile.

Observe that the replies to my post do engage with the argument I made.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by casey2 on Friday May 16, 2025 @09:18AM (#44005151)
What are you talking about? Since the 1800s people have been shipping vaccines to "most of the world"

Everyone could afford to "eat healthy" and get exercise if governments and social planners put in a modicum of effort. Unfortunately they aren't directly incentives to do so.

Framing either of these things as a wealth issue ignores both how wealthy even the poorest in the world are and the systems responsible for the problem. For everything else there's health insurance, yet another horribly mismanaged system.

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by tomhow on Saturday May 17, 2025 @10:51AM (#44014736)
We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43998721 and marked it off topic.

Please observe the guidelines, especially these ones:

Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents. Omit internet tropes.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Baby Is Healed with First Personalized Gene-Editing Treat... by alexashka on Saturday May 17, 2025 @05:49PM (#44017248)
[flagged]