News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by philipwhiuk on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:04AM (#43935844)
It's interesting how Amazon is embedding robots in human-designed warehouses whereas Ocado has humans overseeing a robotic warehouse.

The later is a much easier problem.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by alsodumb on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:06AM (#43935863)
It takes hundreds of millions to build a warehouse. Amazon has tons of them. Retrofitting things is capital intensive.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by sschueller on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:41AM (#43936081)
Humans are cheaper than robots too...
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by bluGill on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:25AM (#43936469)
Only sometimes and costs change over time. The first robot is almost always more expensive than a human, but the second robot comes after the design is done and so it generally cheaper than the human (accountants will figure out how to amortize these costs and thus give us a better picture of costs.)

Robots also get cheaper over time because we learn. You can buy many parts in bulk including computer libraries to control them. You can find many people who know best practices who will not make some of the early mistakes that cost money.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by thfuran on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:07AM (#43936301)
How much cheaper? You can hardly get humans to work two shifts a day, let alone three.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CamperBob2 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:33AM (#43937972)
In China, yes, but not here.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by abricot on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:29AM (#43936502)
Only if you don't need to pay them a living wage.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by econ on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:23PM (#43940158)
I've picked orders. If I have to touch your purchase for 20 seconds it is a very long time. There are 180 chunks of 20 seconds in an hour. If the pay is $45 per hour it would cost 25 cents.

It is strange how this isn't obvious

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by jajuuka on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:15PM (#43940494)
Labor is one of the most expensive parts of running a business. So just doing the math of, if we spend X amount of money on robots and can layoff Y amount of people then it's a net gain. Especially if a single machine can replace multiple people.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by whatever1 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:46AM (#43943297)
Also fixed equipment / robots do not ramp up when the demand increases.

On the other hand you can always hire more People to sort more packages. You don’t even need a building, a tent would suffice.

What these companies do is conceptually very simple. Basically sortation of items at different granularities and locations. Not comparable with manufacturing companies.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by vidarh on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:14AM (#43935916)
The Ocado warehouse automation is pretty crazy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssZ_8cqfBlE

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by throw310822 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:49AM (#43936160)
Incredibile!

Also, from the comments:

"My favorite thing about this is how 2 weeks after this video went up, they had an accident where two robots collided and caused a gigantic fire that cost them like 50 million dollars."

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CamperBob2 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:29AM (#43937924)
Meanwhile, the warehouse down the road underwent a strike that put them out of commission for weeks, forced expensive wage concessions, and incurred NRLB fines, costing them like... 60 million dollars.

One of these things can be fixed, the other will always be a risk as long as humans are involved.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by dimator on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:55AM (#43938239)
Those peaky humans and their stupid quality of life needs!
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by littlestymaar on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:43PM (#43938757)
> One of these things can be fixe

That's correct, the second one can get fixed with higher wages and benefits, like when Ford introduced the “$5 a day” (doubling market average).

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CamperBob2 on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:04PM (#43939545)
Yes, if you're going to pay humans to suffer the indignity of doing a robot's job, it makes sense to pay well.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by littlestymaar on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:55PM (#43943108)
There's no indignity in “doing a robot's job” unless if you think working is indignity, because every job is a “robot job”.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CamperBob2 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:04AM (#43943136)
Of course there is! Since you're here, you're probably a programmer or engineer, a student, or a dedicated professional in some other IT-adjacent field. How would you react if someone offered you a job in a warehouse?

Once you've thought that through, apply the same reasoning to human beings in general, not just white-collar HN denizens. Few people want to work a hard blue-collar job for the same reason you and I don't want to: we have better things to do with our time.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CamperBob2 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @11:40AM (#43946537)
I didn't flag your other reply, by the way, but I did vouch for it. Your retort about LLMs is spot-on, as was your point about how "they're all robot jobs." We just currently disagree on whether eliminating such jobs -- all of them -- is a good goal or a bad one.

You defended your perspective by arguing, correctly, that people take undesirable jobs because they don't have a choice. We agree there as well, and my point is that this is a form of coercion in itself. The status quo treats humans as if they were robots.

(And I really don't care if someone thinks I live in a cave. Life in my cave is actually pretty comfy. It beats the hell out of a warehouse or a cube maze at a click farm. It's a privilege, one I'd like to see more equitably distributed.)

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by nemomarx on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:57PM (#43939461)
if you incurred nrlb fines aren't you breaking the law?
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by RaSoJo on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:11AM (#43936336)
Ocado did run into multiple fire issues due to these robots colliding with each other. In 2019 and 2021 [1]

Wonder if the matter has been resolved.

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/business-57883332

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by kevin_thibedeau on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:42AM (#43938100)
I'm curious how Amazon handles fire in the midst of their Kiva pods. Do they have procedures for retasking an army of robots to clear a path for humans to get access?
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by foobarian on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:01PM (#43938312)
If there are really no humans there they could just fill the warehouse with nitrogen or something. No fire!
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by kevin_thibedeau on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:29PM (#43938614)
Lithium battery fires don't feed on atmospheric oxygen. That's the most likely ignition source.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by littlestymaar on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:45PM (#43938787)
True, though the problem isn't just robot batteries burning up, but setting all the stock ablaze and this part is indeed feeding in atmospheric oxygen.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by havblue on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:49AM (#43936708)
I'd suggest robots with fire extinguishers.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by ido on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:06PM (#43939559)
Or non-combustible robots
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by jajuuka on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:12PM (#43940476)
Need to quit running all the robots on gasoline and building them out a wood.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by tombert on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:43AM (#43937344)
Walmart isn't considered a super high-tech company, but I took a tour of one of their warehouses in Bentonville and even that was quite cool. There were tons of conveyor belts everywhere, it kind of felt like something you'd see in Satisfactory.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by burningChrome on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:18PM (#43938500)
Back in the early aughts when I was still in college, My roommate was an IE and worked as an efficiency engineer intern during his Summers. I vividly remember him talking about the company he was working for had a huge project to improve UPS's efficiencies. Their big improvements was to add dozens and dozens of conveyor belts in order to move the packages faster. He concluded his experience by saying, "Yeah man, its crazy, this is what the future is going to look like. This is how they're going to automate everything."

Interesting to know companies are still using them as a means to automate their work.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by yurishimo on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:25AM (#43937861)
I would argue Walmart is quite high tech! They’ve been approaching their business goals from lots of different angles. Tech, finance, logistics, etc are all a huge part of their business operations.

It’s a shame that the problems being solved are embedded within a business that embodies throwing things away at the first sign of weakness. I’m still upset they bought what seemed on track to be a nice successor to Simple Bank. Now it’s been pivoted again for the third time since acquisition.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by tombert on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:32PM (#43939247)
Oh it wasn't trying to diss Walmart in this case. I used to work there (Jet.com -> Walmart Labs -> Walmart Global Tech), and I generally liked it. Some of the smartest humans I have ever known came from Jet and Walmart Labs.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by Closi on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:25AM (#43935979)
Not sure why Ocado gets so much credit for the latter though, they just copied AutoStore which has a fascinating history!

They purchased an AutoStore, then reverse engineered it, made a few changes, and claimed it as their own invention.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by gjm11 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:48AM (#43936146)
There was a big patent lawsuit related to this, which as I understand it Ocado won pretty comprehensively. (https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/ocado-wins-... -- case in UK court concluded that AutoStore's patents were all invalid and in any case Ocado didn't infringe them; there were a bunch of related cases in other jurisdictions but https://www.ocadogroup.com/media/news/autostore-and-ocado-se... indicates that shortly after the UK judgement they settled on terms very favourable to Ocado.)

This seems difficult to square with your claim that Ocado "just copied AutoStore". (I suppose it's not quite inconsistent with it; maybe Ocado copied a pile of things that AutoStore never patented, and the patented bits were always a sideshow?)

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by Closi on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:33AM (#43937241)
AutoStore losing a patent dispute doesn't mean that Ocado didn't copy them. Just looking at the patent dispute ignores that the first automated Ocado distribution centre was actually purchased from AutoStore, who had been selling their robot-digging tote system since 1996.

Ocado's initial patents as well were actually modifications of Autostore's robots, running on an Autostore grid, and Autostore manufactured the robots to Ocado's specification before Ocado decided to build the whole thing themselves.

So hard to argue that it wasn't a copy.

IMO I think the UK patent victory was a bit of a joke... Ocado's innovation of the robot above a single cell is both obvious, but also has it's own obvious downsides.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by omneity on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:52AM (#43936182)
> This seems difficult to square with your claim that Ocado "just copied AutoStore".

I just looked at videos of the two technologies and it seems difficult to ignore the relationship.

Perhaps this is a case of "technically correct", i.e. that they technically did not infringe the patents, but that in practice they leveraged as much as they could around the patent claims?

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by Closi on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:37AM (#43937281)
Ocado's first automated warehouse installation was also purchased from Autostore (before they built their own solution, and now market/sell it)
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by voakbasda on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:45AM (#43937377)
Truth has no place in a court of law. The fact that they won the lawsuit does not imply they are innocent. It could simply mean that they had better lawyers.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by gamblor956 on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:10PM (#43940048)
AutoStore's patents were deemed invalid in the U.K. because they disclosed the invention prior to filing for the patents, which apparently is not allowed under U.K. law.

Their patents were invalidated in the U.S. due to "inequitable conduct or equitable estoppel" meaning either that Autostore violated someone else's patents or that they led Ocado to believe that Ocado was not violating Autostore's patents in some way. Both parties indicate that the latter happened, but the usual remedy is just a mandatory license, so the invalidation of the patents indicates that the former also occurred. (https://www.autostoresystem.com/investors-press-releases/aut...)

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by Closi on Saturday May 10, 2025 @11:06AM (#43946245)
I think the story is probably something like:

* AutoStore sold a solution to Ocado

* Ocado started modifying their own installation. AutoStore gave them the rights to do this naively thinking it was for their own use.

* Ocado started aggressively patenting their own modifications.

* Ocado then decides it’s going to build everything themselves, and also start selling their own version of the solution and compete directly with Autostore.

* Then the legal battle begins!

Broadly the main thing in contention is that Ocado patented the concept of the robot sitting above a single cell (ie tote). Autostore thinks this is obvious and shouldn’t have been allowed - their main reason for usually implementing a lower robot that sits across two cells is that it’s more reliable (lower centre of mass, simplified mechanics) but that they have now been blocked from just doing a smaller design of their original invention.

Autostore were probably naive at the time (they were still reasonably new to the automation market) and Ocado definitely had better patent lawyers - or at least as they were UK based had a better grip of UK patent law.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by gamblor956 on Sunday May 11, 2025 @01:14PM (#43955221)
That can't possibly be what happened. First to file would not allow Ocado to have patented the concept of the robot sitting above a cell/tote as that was already part of the system they got and copied/reverse-engineered from AutoStore. Indeed, if what you hypothesized had happened, Ocado would be the poster child for an immediate return to the first-to-invent system as this would be precisely the scenario that critics were warning about: an unscrupulous licensor "stealing" an invention from the actual inventor.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by Closi on Monday May 12, 2025 @11:28AM (#43964134)
> First to file would not allow Ocado to have patented the concept of the robot sitting above a cell/tote

Ocado patented the concept of a robot sitting above a single cell/tote, not the concept of the robot sitting above a cell/tote.

AutoStore's initial system was the first to have the robot sitting above a stack of totes, however the robot sat above two cells in it's original design. The settlement actually means that AutoStore cannot develop a robot sitting above a single cell/tote.

> Ocado would be the poster child [for being] an unscrupulous licensor "stealing" an invention from the actual inventor.

They absolutely are the poster child for this in the material handling world! This is widely known in the logistics industry.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by michaelt on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:17AM (#43936404)
The warehouse automation industry has long had problems with scaling systems up.

A system that works well with 15 robots will often fall apart if scaled up to 150 or 1500 robots. Reliability, planning algorithm complexity, radio performance, all sorts of issues start to come up.

That’s why Hatteland patented the autostore tech in ~1995 and by the time the patents expired they only supported ~100 robots.

It’s not always easy to appreciate, because everyone publicises when they install a new automation system, but nobody publicises it if they scrap it 18 months later. Being discreet about it is better for the share price.

Of course there’s still a perfectly good market for less scalable automation; grocery just has crazy financials.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by AIoverlord on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:52AM (#43936186)
I just watched a video of theirs and i have no clue at all if this is more efficient or not.

Amazon uses a lot higher stacked spaces than Ocado does.

Are there any real numbers you can reference than just stating that Ocados way is better?

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by philipwhiuk on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:19PM (#43939131)
I didn't say it was better, I said it was easier to design robots that don't have to work in an environment originally designed for humans.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by mmmlinux on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:40AM (#43938069)
Yeah but then you cant pretend like your going to hire a bunch of humans in the local poor area that you built the warehouse.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by beambot on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:53AM (#43938207)
Symbotic also has a fascinating solution.