News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by krapp on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:56AM (#43935812)
That's still far slower than a human being, and those bins are far too neat.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by WillAdams on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:16AM (#43935930)
Yeah, I worked in an Amazon Warehouse on two separate occasions:

https://old.reddit.com/r/EDC/comments/dmnuts/53mamazon_fulfi...

and Inbound (or the previous person picking) was usually a bit less careful.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by dlt713705 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:12AM (#43935901)
The challenge is not only stowing objects. It is also optimizing space and keeping it clean. In that matter robots are faster and better.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by krapp on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:22AM (#43935960)
Optimizing space and trying to keep things neat is a futile effort. Pickers and counters are constantly pulling things out of the bins and putting them back in, and during high demand it's a chaotic mess. If there are going to be robots being this meticulous at every step of the process, then it's too slow.

There's a reason human beings are worked to the point of exhaustion in these warehouses - the goal is to move as much product as fast as possible. Quality and productivity are at cross purposes, and between the two only the latter makes money.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by dlt713705 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:27AM (#43935998)
That is why, in the end, only robots will remain. They are inexhaustible and strictly meticulous in all circumstances.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by maintainarmsx on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:12AM (#43936350)
Real life interaction is anything but strictly meticulous. Inside an application (in silicon without bugs, not being hit by stray cosmic rays, not having software logic bug) things may seem ideal, but the moment you try to move a pole on a motor 5 cm forward, and 5cm backward, every day at the same time, you'll notice that ideal will have dismantled itself off the mount within two weeks
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by mapt on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:45AM (#43936673)
"Meticulous" in industrial automation does not mean "Precise without the use of feedback-driven control loops".
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by krapp on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:29AM (#43936008)
Robots aren't inexhaustible. They break down a lot and are far more expensive to repair and maintain than a human being.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by bigtunacan on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:11AM (#43936342)
I agree robots breakdown a lot, however if you think robots are more expensive to maintain you may want to take a look at the cost of American medical costs.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by reverius42 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:37AM (#43936065)
They're going to get better a lot faster than humans, though. The fact that they exist at all is remarkable.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by immibis on Sunday May 11, 2025 @11:03AM (#43954306)
Didn't they say this about LLMs but we still only have highly advanced slop generators, highly advanced autocomplete, and highly advanced search?

While they're impressively good in each of the aforementioned three fields, they're still not the world-changing technology they were supposed to be, right? (At least, not by themselves. When a very powerful human ties themselves to a slop machine, believing the output to be real, this can change the world)

The main achievement, besides search which is a very useful application, has been in how effectively we can get real people to believe total bullshit.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by bluGill on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:14AM (#43936370)
Mechanical engineering has a lot of practice on looking at failures and changing designs to make those less common or a maintenance item easy/cheap to fix. (they might have other options too, I'm not a ME)
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by FirmwareBurner on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:24AM (#43936458)
>and are far more expensive to repair and maintain than a human being

Fillpy the robot will not:

  - need vacations
  - go on maternity leave
  - call in sick
  - steal from work
  - be rude to customers
  - go to work hungover from drinking
  - come in high/stoned at work
  - sue you for X,Y,Z
  - sexually harass colleagues
  - go on strike
  - start a union
All those pale in comparison to repair costs. That's why companies are pushing for automation. Because Flippy does its job quietly and diligently 24/7 without complaining.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CraigRood on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:06AM (#43935860)
Part of my day job is Warehouse Automation - not Amazon!. I would agree with you on being slow, but it probably suffices to what Amazon want to achieve here. If your entire process, so stow, store and retrieve is automated, you wouldn't use these "pods". A lot of these problems seem so simple and easy to automate out, but it's really not!
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by wielebny on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:04AM (#43935853)
Slower than a human making one operation.

Not slower than human stocking items for a whole day.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by vntok on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:08AM (#43935878)
Surely the robot does not stop at the end of the day.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by nosrepa on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:20AM (#43935950)
The article says they plan on it operating continuously for 20 hours at a time.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CoastalCoder on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:38AM (#43936067)
Until they unionize.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by ta1243 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:46AM (#43936135)
Do robots rely on being ionized? I'd have thought a robot which wasn't ionized would work just fine
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by CoastalCoder on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:51AM (#43936177)
You're thinking of "Onionized", when their exploits are covered by one of the world's best publications.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by cusaitech on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:18AM (#43937078)
Are you talking about the "Soviet Onion"?
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by dataviz1000 on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:45AM (#43936122)
The tortoise and hare allegory? Slow and steady wins the race.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by usrusr on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:46AM (#43936128)
It's not about throughput per unit, it's about throughput per unit of cost.

If five cheap robots outperform a single skilled worker, robots win. But depending on jurisdiction, those five robots might still lose to a dozen or so slaves kept near starvation. For the skilled worker it's bad news one way or the other.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by bluGill on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:51AM (#43936171)
What skilled worker? This is a low skill worker they are replacing.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by usrusr on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:23AM (#43937833)
Skilled. Not pedigree-filtered and trained and certified into a scarcity that may or may not actually be natural. Chances are most doctors or lawyers or software engineers would perform rather sub-par picking and putting in a warehouse.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by bluGill on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:36PM (#43939268)
Day one yes. put us in the warehouse for a few months and we would be as good as everyone. I'm guessing the woule only give a few days of training before setting us loose.

Several months of me as a doctor and I'd still be incompetent.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by DrillShopper on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:56AM (#43936207)
For now.

Wait until LLMs get better and destroy the ability for junior developers to get their foot in the door.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by warrenmiller on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:21AM (#43936439)
How do you get senior developers if you replace the junior developers?
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by _Algernon_ on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:35AM (#43936556)
Sounds like a problem for some future CEO, long after current CEO has gotten a fat bonus from improving quarterly profits now.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by DrillShopper on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:16AM (#43937741)
That's the neat part - you don't.

(The suits think that's a good thing)

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by dec0dedab0de on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:52AM (#43936756)
By then the senior developers will be obsolete too
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by mystified5016 on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:38AM (#43936606)
You don't, you slowly cannibalize your business and industry. By the time consequences show up, you've already jumped ship with your golden parachute
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by absolutelastone on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:05PM (#43946724)
Well the obvious answer is training. Medicine requires 4 years undergrad plus 4 years grad plus 3+ years residency. You might argue medicine can be replaced by AI similarly, but the issue is risk. That 11 years is to reach the point you can be trusted to make the really high-risk and high-value decisions, not to do the easy stuff analogous to entry-level software.

Software has been an outlier in terms of its high salaries requiring only minimal training. That implies automating it will disproportionately be both easier and more valuable than many other skilled tasks.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by LoganDark on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:57AM (#43936211)
Have you read the article?

    "The fastest humans at this task are like Olympic athletes. They’re far faster than the robots, and they’re able to store items in pods at much higher densities."
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by Dylan16807 on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:09AM (#43936961)
They're not paying for the fastest. If they get some by accident that's great, but otherwise they just want someone reasonably mobile that will be good enough after a week or two of practice.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by bluGill on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:12AM (#43936347)
Compare to a doctor who needs nearly a decade of special training. Or an engineer who needs a complex university training program.

Yes some are better than others. However there is still a vast gulf in skill between those people than engineers (much less doctors), while the gap between them and someone off the street is much less. (the article doesn't say how long it takes someone to get to that high skilled state or even if it is possible to train to that level - if someone can show me data on this I might change my mind on skill)

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by LoganDark on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:16AM (#43937740)
If your point is that experience is not necessarily skill, I suppose that's fair, but in that case skill does not always tell the full story.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by dullcrisp on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:52AM (#43936758)
What data? Just try it yourself and see.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by pixl97 on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:54PM (#43940374)
Of course the robots don't trip and fall breaking their back and sue the company, nor do they want vacations or raises. In fact the robot performance is probably rather consistent versus human performance.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by bluGill on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:06AM (#43936289)
Neat is very important for consistent performance.

A restaurant can improve performance during the "lunch rush" by letting neat slip, but that carelessness is already costing them performance at the end of the lunch rush - this works because just as this catches up they get several hours in the afternoon to clean things up. Then supper crowd where they do it again - then they have the rest of the night to clean up from that. (the restaurants I worked in didn't have a breakfast rush, YMMV)

A factory by contrast needs to keep things neat and consistent all the time because there is never a rush/downtime. They want things rolling off the line at a consistent pace all day. Any compromise for speed now is a cost latter in the day.

I have never been in an Amazon warehouse so I don't have great insight into what things are like. I would expect they want to be more consistent all day - but I don't know. Maybe all the trucks arrive at once and then they get time when they are gone to clean up. I wouldn't expect that, but maybe.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by zaphar on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:35AM (#43936562)
Slow is fast is a saying for a reason. It is just as true for a human as it is for a robot.
Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by potato3732842 on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:44AM (#43937354)
Like every other Reddit-ism and internet worshipped rule of thumb. The reason for the popularity has far more to do with what makes a sound byte marketable to humans than it does with anything quantitative.

Look at the above restaurant example, the system has a built in buffer to handle spikes so it can be cheaper or make other tradeoffs everywhere else compared to an equivalently performant system that can do 100% duty cycle.

A robot or human that can deal with messy inventory is facilitating positive tradeoffs elsewhere in the system.

Re:Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans by seadan83 on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:57PM (#43938925)
Smooth is fast, slow is smooth, so slow is fast. You're applying that to the restaurant as a whole though, which makes human or robotic immaterial.

The saying I do believe has a difference between robots and humans. The idea largely being that human inaccuracy increases exponentially relative to speed. Ergo, slowing down can lead to dramatically bette accuracy and throughput. Though, robots don't necessarily lose accuracy because they are moving more quickly. Though, I'd agree it is likely that both humans and robots need "smooth" in order to be fast. The key difference is robots do not always lose smooth when moving at high speed.