News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by gexos on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @05:52PM (#43910029)
You're not wrong that Windsurf and Cursor feel transitional—they’re clearly riding the AI wave without quite nailing the execution yet. But calling them "stopgaps" might undersell their role. They're experiments in what developer tools can become, and even if they stumble, they’re shaping the direction the industry is heading.

As for Microsoft tightening its grip on VSCode, yeah, that's a strategic play. It's the classic embrace-extend-extinguish arc we’ve seen before. But the community won't just roll over. If they start walling off features like TypeScript 7.0 from forks, the open source pushback will be fierce—and that could backfire hard.

The bugs and instability in Cursor and Windsurf are real, especially in the AI layers—but that's what happens when you ship fast. Microsoft might catch up and polish those ideas, sure. But raw innovation rarely comes from the behemoths—it bubbles up from the scrappy contenders.

And you're absolutely right about the endgame: the shift from "smart tools" to "smart collaborators." But we need both. Editors like Cursor are the testing ground for those future teammates. They're rough drafts of a new paradigm, not just forks of VSCode with AI duct-taped on.

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by john-h-k on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:14PM (#43910973)
Was this written by an LLM? Not accusative but something about the vibe strongly suggests it
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by blueblimp on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:20PM (#43911000)
I feel it too:

- Plenty of em-dashes

- "you're absolutely right"

- "They're X, not just Y"

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by absqueued on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:32PM (#43911066)
Not just that, also notice the curly apostrophe (’) vs the usual keyboard straight apostrophe (') mark.
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by op00to on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:48PM (#43911146)
The sheer number of AI written message board posts might just make me stop reading the comments on sites like Reddit and HN. I wanted to stop anyway, this seems like a good push to encourage me to wean myself.
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by sally_glance on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:12PM (#43911265)
Every one of us leaving (not engaging/commenting) increases the share of AI generated comments (vs real users) the next iteration will train on. I'm not even sure which option is worse. Withdraw and let everyone dilute their own training data, or stay and feed them our mindset and experience...?
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by resize2996 on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:36PM (#43911403)
Build our own spaces.
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by DrammBA on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:23PM (#43911328)
also the

- "some introduction or callback: description or phrase"

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by noncoml on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:02PM (#43911209)
Post history indicates that user likes em-dashes('--'). Probably written on a phone that converts -- to em-dash.
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by haint_ on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:13PM (#43911595)
Or they are just a bot.
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by noncoml on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:18PM (#43911621)
Their post history doesn't seem suspicious to me
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by john-h-k on Wednesday May 07, 2025 @04:05AM (#43913248)
To be fair, only 3 posts within "possible LLM usage" timeframe. Also I don't think using LLM to comment == bot. More curious about the motivation behaviour such behaviour, if it is occurring
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by ninetyninenine on Wednesday May 07, 2025 @02:05AM (#43912682)
This is beginnings of AI discrimination. If an answer is written by an LLM but equal or superior in quality to a human answer why question or disparage it?

I don't know but it looks like you're probably a white guy. Your mannerisms and vibes make it look like you're white. Nothing wrong with this, just wanted to point it out. See what I'm saying.

It's like the blade runner movies.

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by john-h-k on Wednesday May 07, 2025 @03:37AM (#43913118)
I find this comment odd but not at all discriminatory and will happily inform that yes, I am white British. I can see the point you’re going for but I do think it’s more complex than that. I don’t think LLMs are equivalent to another human race. Principally, LLMs have many pretty major differences to humans which you don’t really see at the inter-racial level. Secondly the reasoning for why asking someone their race in this context would be weird involved a lot of human history. If you’d asked my height or eye colour there’s nothing discriminatory feeling about that. That historical context doesn’t exist with LLMs
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by ninetyninenine on Wednesday May 07, 2025 @07:51AM (#43914494)
The LLM provided an answer that has superior quality or equal quality to a human. Then instead of judging the statement rationally on this quality we decided to judge the question on whether or not it was AI.

This is the same irrationality we used to discriminate humans. There is no difference in logic. The reasoning you used here about how LLMs are not equivalent to human beings is the same reasoning Hitler used on Jewish people.

And here’s the thing. I agree with you. If you gassed and holocausted LLMs wouldn’t give two shits.

The main point here is that the logic and irrationality and evil present in racism is all at work here. We are literally being discriminatory, there’s no difference.

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by matheusmoreira on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @06:29PM (#43910304)
> If they start walling off features like TypeScript 7.0 from forks, the open source pushback will be fierce—and that could backfire hard.

Do they have the man power to compete with Microsoft?

Linux managed to do it but Linux is the biggest, most successful free software project there is. Firefox and its forks are a better example. If Mozilla stopped working on Firefox, the forks would be pretty much dead in the water: they simply do not have the man power necessary to maintain a modern browser.

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by mathgeek on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:06PM (#43910928)
> Do they have the man power to compete with Microsoft?

There are a fair number of examples where smaller companies and/or open source beat Microsoft's entrenched products. Usually a key indicator is that MS's products stagnate (which doesn't yet appear to be happening currently).

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by cwkoss on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @06:54PM (#43910499)
Does microsoft have the wisdom to predict where this line of technology is headed, and/or the agility to course correct when their predictions don't quite hit the mark?

Cursor blows copilot out of the water in my experience. Man power clearly isn't the most decisive factor in this battle.

Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by rockwotj on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @07:47PM (#43910830)
Copilot is limited to 64k context window. Even if the underlying model is gemini with 20x that. It’s gotta be a major reason copilot is so bad in comparison. They are all the same sets of models under the hood
Re:OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for around $3B by horns4lyfe on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:54PM (#43911171)
Microsoft’s army of cheap offshored labor isn’t going to be useful for something like that. And they already have copilot, which is miles behind cursor, where was the manpower on that?