It's not about using the most powerful tool always, it's about knowing how to leverage modern standards rather than reinventing and solving problems that are already solved.
Maybe, but it doesn't necessarily need to be a SPA framework though. There are simpler libraries/frameworks like htmx that considerably reduce complexity and also let you avoid direct DOM manipulation.
However, in general, whatever's most popular is a strong signal (like a crowd-sourced signal) that it's probably indeed "the best" all around, which are two words that can also, of course, be debated endlessly based on one's personal definition of "best".
People who say stuff like this have obviously never actually used modern day FE frameworks, because they have all been very stable for a long while. Yes, APIs change, but that's not unique to JS/frontend, and also nothing really forces you to update with them unless you really need some shiny new feature, and at least IME Vue 3 has been nothing but gold since we got on it.
This is just intentional ignorance.
As I’ve become more senior I’ve realized that software devs have a tendency to fall for software “best practices” that sound good on paper but they don’t seem to question their practical validity. Separation of concerns, microservices, and pick the best tool for the job are all things I’ve ended up pushing back against.
In this particular case I’d say “pick the best tool for the job” is particularly relevant. Even though this advice is hard to argue against, I think it has a tendency to take developers down the path of unnecessary complexity. Pragmatically it’s usually best to pick a single tool that works decently well for 95% of your use cases instead of a bunch of different tools.
Further, being against a bloated framework is not the same as being against frameworks. Those frameworks are actually principles. It’s possible for a team to come up with or use existing principles without using a framework.
Finally, “always use React” brings other costs. You need a team to build your system twice. That means you need bigger teams; more funding to do the same thing, and so on. You add complexity at the team level and at the software level when using frameworks. The person above you said that blindly “following best practices” is bad while stating a “best practice” of always start with React. That particular “best practice” not always being the best practice is the entire point of this thread.
Having been a web developer for a quarter century, I know how tempting it is (yes, for small projects) to try to just wing it and do everything without a framework, and I know what a tarpit that way of thinking is. If you disagree, then you were certainly welcome to share you own opinion.
> Most people seemingly advocating for non-React are actually saying to start simple and add the complexity where and when it’s needed.
In my experience that’s actually not the case. That might be what people claim, but in my professional experience some people really don’t like frontend work and they try to avoid frontend frameworks because they think it’ll make their work more tolerable, but what usually happens is they start out “simple” but pretty quickly product requirements come in that are hard to do without some framework, then there’s a scramble to add a framework or hack it into some parts of the app.
You can't just switch horses in the middle of the stream. You have to ride back to the ranch, saddle up on a different horse, and restart your entire journey on a better horse.
The second assumption where I believe you are going wrong is that 'product requirements' will always come in and force using a framework. Imho if I look around at most of the webapps I am using, very few of them actually need a SPA framework. Take Jira for example. Does it really need to be fully a SPA? It has some highly interactive parts, which could be done with eg web components, but it's mostly a boring CRUD app that would work fine with eg htmx.
This assumes that non-React approaches are simple.
So you delete the non-framework garbage code and start over. lol.
I've heard people say they just want "Pure JS" with no frameworks at all because frameworks are too complex, for their [currently] small app. So they get an app working, and all is good, right until it hits say 5000 lines of code. Then suddenly you have to re-write it all using a framework and TypeScript to do typing. Better to just start with an approach that scales to infinity, so you never run into the brick wall.