News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by carlgreene on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:23PM (#43862213)
This will surely get some skepticism as it's a Waymo study, but it's nice to see a real‐world dataset this large at 56M miles. An 85 % drop in serious‐injury crashes and 96 % fewer intersection collisions is a strong signal that Level 4 ADS can meaningfully improve safety in ride-hail settings. Still curious about how much of that comes from operational design versus the core autonomy, but it’s a big leap beyond “novelty demo.”

Really excited for autonomy to become more and more common place. People drive more and more like distracted lunatics these days it seems

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by xnx on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:56PM (#43862622)
It's good to be skeptical of the source, but I can't remember seeing any substantive criticism of the methodology or conclusions.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by manquer on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:52PM (#43863223)
Here is one,

Humans drive in all weather conditions on all types of roads and also many types of personal vehicles of varying ages and conditions.

Waymo is limited to few specific locations with decent roads and does not drive in poor weather and is limited to a relatively large and safer expensive SUV that is maintained professionally in a fleet.

Studies like this rarely account for such factors , they are compare optimal conditions for self driving to average conditions for humans.

Even if waymo was better when accounting for these factors , if it was much worse in the conditions humans typically are expected to drive [1] they self driving is still less safe than humans on average .

A better comparison could be with professional taxi drivers for the same city (not Uber or Lyft).

I wouldn’t be surprised if Waymo is either on par or poorer than this group .

[1] no study will ever show this as they wouldn’t be able to trial it under those conditions if it is not safe enough

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by jedberg on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:51PM (#43863788)
> A better comparison could be with professional taxi drivers for the same city (not Uber or Lyft). > I wouldn’t be surprised if Waymo is either on par or poorer than this group.

If you've been in both a human drive cab and a Waymo, you'd definitely not say this. I see cabs have accidents all the time. Never seen a Waymo have one.

Also, being in a Waymo feels much safer than a human driven car, even my own when I'm driving!

I highly doubt taxicabs are safer than Waymos.

In fact, here is some data:

Over every 1 million miles driven, there are 4.6 cab crashes, 3.7 livery car crashes, and 6.7 crashes with private cars. And according to Waymo, they have 2.1 crashes per million miles.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by manquer on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:08PM (#43865455)
> 4.6 cab crashes, 3.7 livery car crashes, and 6.7 crashes with private cars.

> Waymo 2.1 crashes

The numbers become much less 80+% plus claim in the article as you remove factors. It comes closer to 30% with professional drivers.

Livery car is still not always well maintained a high sitting SUV with better visibility[1], perhaps with all these factors included if it is 20% better it is impressive technical achievement for sure, but not going to create headlines anywhere.

The point is the methodology is not as objective as it could be, and this is biased/selective claim, not that self driving cannot be better than humans.

[1] Also there is major difference in the price point between Waymo and Livery cars, I cannot say how it will influence rates but the different rates means different class of clients using at different times of day/night to different locations that needs to be normalized for.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by jedberg on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:53PM (#43865703)
The percent improvement doesn't really matter though. The fact that it is better than even just professionals still means that there are fewer crashes, and therefore they are improving overall road safety.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by manquer on Friday May 02, 2025 @02:22AM (#43866725)
* In a better car, serviced much better than the average professional vehicle.

The % matters because it is close enough excluding these factors, so we can not definitely say it currently better than humans yet, close but not conclusively so.

That is not a argument against them. It is a simple function of economics, i.e. as long as it better than Lyft/Uber(they are already) that is the price point that Waymo operates at, so it is safer for most users and easy choice to make.

However if you can afford and regularly use high quality private livery car services then the data has to be lot clearer to make the switch.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by riquito on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:19PM (#43864007)
> Waymo is limited to few specific locations with decent roads and does not drive in poor weather

the study is comparing Waymo to accidents occurred in the same cities where Waymo operates, and my understanding is that Waymo drives 7 days a week, 24h a day in those cities, so same roads, same weather. Seems a legit comparison

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by manquer on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:58PM (#43865395)
Not the same cars though, people are not driving newish mid range SUV with professional maintenance all the time.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by notTooFarGone on Friday May 02, 2025 @03:19AM (#43867060)
Also there is some sort of bias not accounted for: People drive when most people drive and most people are stuck in the most dangerous area: traffic. Waymo driving at night on empty streets is not a good indicator for accident prevention when measured against the average human, who is stuck mostly in traffic.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by ra7 on Friday May 02, 2025 @12:06PM (#43871618)
Why do you believe Waymo's miles are from driving at night on empty streets? They drive when there's rideshare demand, a majority of which occurs during daytime and in the busiest areas of a city. They are no less stuck in traffic than the average human.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by Workaccount2 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:33PM (#43863612)
I am very curious where waymo is at in adverse conditions. Do the cars totally lock up and become useless? Or are they at the level of your 65 year old mother driving in a thunderstorm at night? Passable, but nothing they are gonna put their name on.

Seems they intend to come to Washington D.C. next year, which does get a pretty wide gamut of weather.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by pb7 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:29PM (#43863571)
Waymos drive in all weather in the cities they're deployed in; cities where people crash all the time in all types of weather.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by manquer on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:56PM (#43865386)
Waymo ( and self driving programs as well) have been careful not to go for public large scale deployments in any city with difficult weather and for good reason focused on cities like Austin, Phoenix, Los Angeles, SF[1] so far with easy driving weather.

There have been promising progress and there have been hints of a New York trial soon, but it it well known that self driving cars have not done large scale trial in cities with bad weather.

[1] Yes, I am aware SF gets a bit of bad weather with fog and rain but not nearly not as much to make driving quite unsafe like somewhere that gets a feet of snow in 24 hours in winter, and likely promixity to engineering HQs and favourable regulatory climate influenced the SF choice.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by ra7 on Friday May 02, 2025 @12:14PM (#43871701)
They only compare to human accidents in the areas they operate. It doesn't matter where they don't operate today as they don't try to include human crash numbers from those cities either for the comparison.

Every time someone thinks this is some gotcha, but it isn't. Their methodology clearly attempts an apples-to-apples comparison.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by scld on Friday May 02, 2025 @09:56AM (#43869831)
Maybe humans shouldn't drive in those conditions then.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by manquer on Friday May 02, 2025 @05:15PM (#43874667)
It may not be option to most people in the US (most self driving use case is built around the US market)

In America driving is a economic necessity, from going to work to even the grocery shop needs cars and dependency increases inversely with affluence [1]

Mass public transit is non existent barring very few regions.

So car (for commute) and flight (for long distance) are the only two viable transit options .

People cannot choose to not work because weather is bad, and remote work / work from home applies to only some jobs.

[1] food and other service deserts are more likely less affluent neighborhoods meaning you will need to drive and for longer for food , pharmacy or any other services if you are low income .

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by scld on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @03:19PM (#43908669)
This is a chicken and egg scenario. Before we had cars, people got to work fine. Now we're OK with killing 40,000 people a year and injuring many more so that people can "get to work".
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by darkwizard42 on Friday May 02, 2025 @02:12PM (#43873082)
This isn't even true because the dataset compares against conditions IN THE CITY they operate in. They operate year-round in SF and in the same conditions human drivers do.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by vlovich123 on Friday May 02, 2025 @11:21AM (#43870991)
I saw a Waymo completely freeze in road construction and then pull off into a different lanes through cones.

This is all low speed so wasn’t a safety issue (aside from road rage it might trigger in someone), but focusing only on safety also ignores incidents like this.

Aside from the criticisms about the safety methodology outlined in another chain, I think there’s a bait and switch here where they don’t talk about negative impacts to traffic, freezes, inability to handle situations and don’t evaluate their performance against other drivers.

Don’t get me wrong. I think Waymo is doing well to being the first to truly autonomous, but they’re intentionally putting their best foot forward and trying not to draw attention to any of their shortcomings.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by buckle8017 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:28PM (#43862257)
It's an incentive problem.

Uber/Lyft drivers are strongly incentivized to drive as quickly and aggressively as possible.

The individual drivers are trading risk for cash.

A company like Google isn't going to make that trade because it's actually the wrong trade across millions of hours.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by rozap on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:40PM (#43862411)
There was a study a few years back that showed male uber drivers earned more than female drivers. How could this be so, when the dispatch algorithm doesn't discriminate? Turns out men just drive a little faster in the aggregate so they made iirc around 3% more money.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by zitterbewegung on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:46PM (#43862491)
Not sure if this is the study but this looks like a good study where they found it was 7% when the study was done.

https://economics.uchicago.edu/news/study-finds-gender-pay-g...

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by rozap on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:53PM (#43862591)
Yep that was it, an even bigger gap than I remembered. Thanks for linking it.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by anigbrowl on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:40PM (#43862417)
I think the problem is a general one about drivers, not just ride-sharers. I live in a fairly busy area and I am beset by aggressive drivers any time I need to cross a busy road. So many drivers simply ignore pedestrians by default. Not that many of them have Uber or Lyft signs in the window, if anything commercial drivers tend to be a bit more careful in my experience because the downside risk is being unable to work any driving job.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by bluGill on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:31PM (#43863019)
About half of commercial drivers is my conclusion. (though I'm not collecting statistically valid data) Just judging by the number of commercial vehicles who drive into the crosswalk I use often.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by Terr_ on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:34PM (#43862342)
Good point: Part of Waymo's safety stats comes from settings that are probably tuned right now in favor of safety stats even if it means a longer or less-profitable ride. It doesn't care if you're going to lose your job if you're five minutes late.

So a fairer comparison would be contrasting Waymo rides to trips conducted by the Ultra Safe Even If It's Slower Chauffeur Company.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by notatoad on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:55PM (#43862610)
>a fairer comparison would be contrasting Waymo rides to trips conducted by the Ultra Safe Even If It's Slower Chauffeur Company.

no, comparing them to real alternatives is the fair comparison. that they've got their settings tuned in favour of safety stats is the whole point, not something that you should be trying to factor out of the comparisons.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by Terr_ on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:52PM (#43863225)
> they've got their settings tuned in favour of safety stats is the whole point

For now, yes. My point is that there's very often big gap between "how safely does it work in a lab when the people running it are trying to play up its safety" versus "how safely will X actually work once we start using it everywhere."

Manually-driven vehicles could be a lot safer if they were being prototyped under strict guidance as well!

If we want self-driving cars to retain the same safety later, there needs to be something which prevents humans from flicking the safety-versus-speed dial a little bit over and over in order to make quarterly earnings projections.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:21PM (#43864463)
> Manually-driven vehicles could be a lot safer if they were being prototyped under strict guidance as well

But they aren’t. These are. Planes could be less safe if pilots flew them into cliffs on the regular, but they don’t and so are not.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by Terr_ on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:36PM (#43865290)
> But they [manual vehicles] aren’t [being operated by a corporation with a very strong incentive to publicly demonstrate safety]. These [automated vehicles] are.

Uh, yes, you're kinda repeating my thesis, and two copies don't cancel each other out.

> Planes could be less safe if pilots flew them into cliffs on the regular, but they don’t and so are not.

I don't understand what you're trying to convey with this tautology.

_________

Imagine two fleets of cars/planes/whatever with utterly identical equipment and expertise. The only difference is that for one of them, the management is being pressured by politicians to demonstrate a high degree of safety.

For that scenario, wouldn't you agree that the better-safety comes from temporary external cause? And also agree that the better-safety is unlikely to persist long after the incentive disappears?

[TLDR] Some portion of Waymo's safety-stats are due to the investor/regulatory context in which it currently operates, rather than the underlying technology; the effects of that portion will not be permanent; this should affect how we do comparisons.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:13PM (#43865497)
> Imagine

We don’t need to. I could also imagine every human driver is always drunk. But those are suppositions. You’re comparing actual and hypothetical risks.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by Terr_ on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:25PM (#43865559)
Isaac Newton: "Did you see that apple fall? Now imagine that both an elephant and a feather were to begin falling at the same moment, in a place where the atmosphere was--"

Your ancestor: "No, we don't need to. I could also imagine them underwater. Those are suppositions. You're comparing actual and hypothetical falling."

*headdesk*

____

How about this: Which parts of the final TLDR do you disagree with?

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by ChadNauseam on Friday May 02, 2025 @02:34AM (#43866792)
I disagree that "the effects of that portion will not be permanent". The safety level can be set to whatever is desired by governments, since governments control how much liability Waymo has. We haven't seen cars get less safe, we've seen governments force car manufacturers to make them more safe. (As well as institute seatbelt requirements, speeding cameras, etc.) I expect the same to happen with self-driving tech. The benefits to driving more aggressively are also likely to be pretty small to the company - I don't think I've ever been in a Waymo ride that's spent more than a minute waiting for pedestrians. So even if they were twice as aggressive, that's saving 30 seconds per ride. Probably not going to have a huge impact on the bottom line.

Also, if you want to include the speculation that they'll make their cars drive more aggressively, you should also include the speculation that the technology will become better and the driving tech will become even safer than they are now.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by AlotOfReading on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:55PM (#43862614)
Ultra Safe Even if it's Slower Chauffeur company doesn't exist and doesn't have data that can be compared. This is a comparison against the thing Waymo is actually replacing.
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by Mawr on Friday May 02, 2025 @02:43AM (#43866851)
> It doesn't care if you're going to lose your job if you're five minutes late.

Good. I don't want my kid who's crossing an intersection to be endangered by an Uber driver that you paid $30 to go extra fast. Nothing like externalizing your poor planning skills onto others.

Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by somanyphotons on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:31PM (#43862304)
I may be out-of-date here, but I had thought the accelerometers in the phone detected if drivers were too jerky in the movements of the car and that the drivers would be informed of poor service
Re:New Study: Waymo is reducing serious crashes and making s... by pests on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:33PM (#43862328)
DoorDash (so food not people) will give you a report for hard braking / acceleration but it doesn't actually affect anything afaict.