News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by silexia on Saturday April 26, 2025 @12:00AM (#43800833)
4chan is controversial and often very ugly, but it is one of the few old school message boards that allows free speech left.

Like the ACLU used to do, we should help them stay online and exercising their free speech, even if it is annoying and gross.

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by santoshalper on Sunday April 27, 2025 @07:29PM (#43816030)
As a long time ACLU financial supporter, I could not disagree more. 4chan is not and never was a bastion of free speech. Comparing 4chan to the ACLU is like comparing a toddler smearing shit on a wall to art. To practice free speech requires an intent to express a point of view. 4chan had to point of view and was just a shithole.
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by john-h-k on Sunday April 27, 2025 @07:42PM (#43816109)
> To practice free speech requires an intent to express a point of view

Excellent, now we can ban speech we don’t like by just saying it doesn’t actually express a point of view

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by chris_wot on Sunday April 27, 2025 @07:57PM (#43816202)
You can't yell out in a theatre that there is a fire and cause a stampede.
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by mrandish on Sunday April 27, 2025 @08:14PM (#43816293)
In case you're not citing that old debunked free speech trope ironically please see: "Don’t Use These Free-Speech Arguments Ever Again" by First Amendment expert Ken White (https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/08/free-speec...).
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by chris_wot on Sunday April 27, 2025 @08:47PM (#43816457)
I have no idea what you are talking about, and I am unable to read the article as it is behind a paywall.
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by mrandish on Sunday April 27, 2025 @11:17PM (#43817175)
https://archive.is/iZC4v

Hopefully, that works. It's the first time I've done an archive like that. It works for me, but it always did because I'm using the Bypass Paywalls Clean add-on in Firefox https://gitflic.ru/project/magnolia1234/bpc_uploads

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by chris_wot on Monday April 28, 2025 @01:49AM (#43818016)
So, you can yell "fire" falsely and cause a stampede?

Alex Jones would like a word with you.

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by gruez on Monday April 28, 2025 @09:00AM (#43821058)
Yes, because the current supreme court standard is "imminent lawless action".
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by skyyler on Monday April 28, 2025 @12:05PM (#43822988)
Alex Jones defamed families by lying about the details of their children's deaths on his internet show. Courts have decided that his actions count as defamation.

Why did you bring him up here? Do you think his being punished for profiting off of the defamation of school children is a violation of his first amendment rights?

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by chris_wot on Monday April 28, 2025 @09:00PM (#43827711)
No, just the opposite. It wasn't a violation of his first amendment rights. You can't target the families of shooting victims like he did and claim that it was "free speech".
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by mrandish on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:34PM (#43824509)
> So, you can yell "fire" falsely and cause a stampede?

As the article I linked points out, that trope was (and still is) a hypothetical that tells us nothing useful about first amendment speech rights. The reason the article is so valuable and often cited is when one of those first amendment tropes is tossed into a discussion, it's usually to imply some specific speech which is protected - is not protected. They are often deployed either in error by those who don't understand how very narrow and incredibly rare first amendment exceptions actually are, or as a bad faith rhetorical device by those who already know the first amendment protects speech they wish it didn't.

As a student and fan of first amendment jurisprudence, the fascinating thing about the tropes is that most of them come from old, exceptional cases where the court got it wrong. Cases which were either reversed by later courts or so thoroughly disavowed they've never come back before the court. A long time ago, various eras of SCOTUS courts wobbled around in the long process of figuring out first amendment exceptions and some bad decisions were made - then later corrected. After decades of trying (and failing) to work out a set of rules permitting "good speech" while stopping "bad speech", it became obvious it was impossible.

Over the past 50 years or so, SCOTUS narrowed in on a detailed set of precedents which are as consistent and crystal clear as they are radically extreme - always protecting almost ALL speech - including the worst, most vile, offensive and hateful speech that has no redeeming value whatsoever. Speech I personally despise and wish no one ever said. While I hate the speech (and, often, the speaker), I fiercely defend the first amendment which protects it. Tolerating the awful things people I dislike do with their rights is the price of still having those rights when we need them most. After all those decades of trial and error, in the end, I think SCOTUS finally got it just about perfect.

So the next time you feel like hauling out the "fire... crowded theater" thing, consider instead just saying "The goddamn first amendment fully and absolutely protects this offensive, vile, bullshit speech - and I hate that these assholes said this shit because it's wrong - and here's why..." This would have the benefit of very likely being correct regarding the first amendment and I'd totally respect your feelings and even probably agree with you.

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by chris_wot on Monday April 28, 2025 @09:05PM (#43827749)
You could more easily have quoted ''Brandenburg v. Ohio'', 395 U.S. 444 (1969) [42]-[44]:

The line between what is permissible and not subject to control and what may be made impermissible and subject to regulation is the line between ideas and overt acts.

The example usually given by those who would punish speech is the case of one who falsely shouts fire in a crowded theatre.

This is, however, a classic case where speech is brigaded with action. See Speiser v. Randall, 357 U.S. 513, 536—537, 78 S.Ct. 1332, 1346, 2 L.Ed.2d 1460 (Douglas, J., concurring.) They are indeed inseparable and a prosecution can be launched for the overt acts actually caused. Apart from rare instances of that kind, speech is, I think, immune from prosecution.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/395/444

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by mikestew on Monday April 28, 2025 @04:08PM (#43825528)
Alex Jones would like a word with you.

As TFA helpfully points out, defamation is outside First Amendment protection.

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by ternaryoperator on Monday April 28, 2025 @07:16PM (#43827134)
Alex Jones lost a civil case to the families of the victims. There was no first amendment issue because the first amendment specifies what the government can and cannot limit w.r.t. speech.
Re:Still Standing [4chan] by hn_acker on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @03:09PM (#43836747)
> There was no first amendment issue because the first amendment specifies what the government can and cannot limit w.r.t. speech.

Defamation is by definition unprotected speech, but in the US the legal criteria of what is protected and unprotected speech fundamentally revolve around the First Amendment. The courts, part of the government, enforce civil disputes. The First Amendment applies to civil lawsuits which would directly or indirectly restrict or compel speech.

Alex Jones met the criteria for defamation in multiple civil cases because he spread false statements (conspiracy theories, to be clear), he ignored every indication that his statements were false (in a way that I believe fulfills at least the "reckless disregard of whether it was false or not" branch of the actual malice standard established in Sullivan [1]), and his statements harmed the families reputations (to the point where people motivated by or hiding behind his lies threatened the families [2] and defaced at least one victim's grave [3]).

Disclaimer: I personally believe that Alex Jones knew his statements were false and spread them anyway (the "with knowledge that it was false" branch of actual malice).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._Sullivan

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Jones

[3] https://apnews.com/article/alex-jones-infowars-bankruptcy-sa...

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by john-h-k on Monday April 28, 2025 @08:16AM (#43820590)
Absolutely. Point is we have to judge it in context. People saying horrible things for no reason on a message board is fundamentally different to causing a stampede in a cinema.

I agree that we need laws to make "yelling fire and causing stampedes" illegal. I do not agree that "free speech requires an intent to express a point of view" is the correct way of implementing this.

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by RIMR on Sunday April 27, 2025 @07:40PM (#43816093)
Absolutely not. Free speech exists just fine on the Internet, evidenced by the fact that a site like 4chan is capable of existing in the first place. We don't have to financially support repulsive communities just to protect their ability to exist.

If 4chan were taken down by government action, I might be inclined to speak up for them in some capacity, as I don't consider that anything 4chan is currently doing illegal, but that's not the situation here. If 4chan dies because it's a poorly-managed shithole with no allies, then we can and should let it die, and rest easy knowing that it wasn't censored, it collapsed under it's own debt.

Re:Still Standing [4chan] by rideontime on Monday April 28, 2025 @03:08PM (#43824857)
What are you planning to do to help them stay online?