Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by kmfrk on Monday August 13, 2012 @07:11PM
(#4378627)
I think this looks interesting, as long as you don't apply the same "X of Y" comparisons.
Someone likened it to a forum, and I think it's a nice take on it. Not necessarily something with SOCIAL all over it.
The promo video was pretty horrible, though. I'm also getting a little tired of Valley videos that make it sound like we're curing cancer or something.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by wamatt on Tuesday August 14, 2012 @12:08AM
(#4379353)
Yeah, the whole "curing cancer" meme always sounded murky and a bit lame TBH. It's unlikely it's a binary thing or state that get's magically achieved by one person or a team, and much more likely the result of small, incremental advances.
Cancer itself is not even "one thing" phenomologically speaking (IAMNA oncologist) it's a broad class of diseases, that may or may not have a single 'solution'.
Solution, in this context, being a state where the population does not need to worry about cancer as a statistically significant cause of death. It could equally likely linger in a status that is managed but not 'cured' in the traditional sense of the word, aka HIV.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by jessepollak on Monday August 13, 2012 @04:54PM
(#4378102)
Also, there seems to be some sort of bug with the email collection modal. It refuses to go away, even though I've signed in with Twitter and provided my email. Makes it impossible to click the features stories.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by jessepollak on Monday August 13, 2012 @05:12PM
(#4378176)
This is unrelated to the actual product, but it's interesting that they'd choose to feature that branch on Obama. While a lot of the other branches seem to be highly informed discussions among experts who supply real evidence, that conversation seems shallow at best, very uniformed at the worst. Seemed more like a discussion you'd find in a Facebook comment thread and less like the conversations branch wants to foster. Did anyone else get that feeling?
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by natrius on Monday August 13, 2012 @05:44PM
(#4378318)
Let's ignore how they're pitching the service. I've participated in a Branch[1], and as a replacement for Twitter conversations, it is extraordinary. That's enough for me to keep the bookmarklet handy.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by kloncks on Monday August 13, 2012 @06:55PM
(#4378582)
I hate to be that guy. (And really, I almost never say this). But, coming from the guys who made Twitter, can we talk about how and why this could possibly be monetized?
Neat idea. Gorgeous design. But how is Branch Inc sustainable?
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by ceslami on Monday August 13, 2012 @07:59PM
(#4378758)
He's making a good point -- how can it be sustainable without profit? Of course it needn't be sustainable to generate profit, but that's not what he meant, or said.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by chimi on Tuesday August 14, 2012 @01:25AM
(#4379553)
It's neat. It's basically a different take on forums or twitter. Where your twitter page is a jumble of comments about N different conversations, Branch separates them into threads.
It's a new way and it'll get a lot of attention, but it's really just a way to communicate and there are lots of them. If Branch succeeds, it'll do so in the adoption of its style into other communications media, including existing forums or twitter.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by im_dario on Tuesday August 14, 2012 @04:49AM
(#4379997)
Cool concept! I'm glad to see something like that working. I wrote down almost a year ago a very similar idea (I called it Flow) in a "incubator" project of mine: https://github.com/imdario/lyd/wiki/Analysis
Maybe it is time to code what I thought ;) It was meant to be a liquid democracy citizen participatory system.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by smarx on Monday August 13, 2012 @07:03PM
(#4378605)
Branch seems to want write access to my Twitter account, even just to "request an invite." Does anyone know why? It looks intriguing, but I'm not ready to trust it to that degree.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by josh_miller on Monday August 13, 2012 @07:06PM
(#4378611)
Sorry for the confusion! We should be more clear about our intentions. We need write access so when you do get an invite, you can invite your friends to branches (via DM or @mention). But we'll never send anything without your explicit permission.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by smarx on Monday August 13, 2012 @07:26PM
(#4378675)
Thanks for the explanation! I would suggest telling users this during signup (right before they auth).
Word of warning to everyone: when you request an invite, there's a pre-checked checkbox labeled "Follow @branch to find out about the best new branches." I like that it's easy to see, but I don't like that it's opt-out.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by look_lookatme on Monday August 13, 2012 @05:42PM
(#4378311)
I like the idea and what I've seen so far, but how is this not still a private site? I can't contribute or be a part of branch until my time comes on the invite list.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by ceslami on Monday August 13, 2012 @08:51PM
(#4378882)
Threading in Gmail was definitely huge. They beat a lot of desktop mail clients to the punch, too, which always surprised me.
Seems like Branch would become One More Thing To Check, as opposed to a replacement for e-mail. I don't think they're going for an replacement, either. I think I get their point, but I also can't see it as much more than Twitter repackaged with unique slang and a squeaky clean UI.
Re:Obvious Corp. backed Branch comes out of private beta
by ceslami on Monday August 13, 2012 @09:34PM
(#4378973)
Haha, I'm sure. As far as product design goes, I think you've done a bang-up job. Individual branches are easy on the eyes and comfortable to consume for extended periods, and the primary actions are easy to identify. congrats on the launch.
Out of curiosity, where does it fit into your workflow specifically? Do you find yourself using either/any of Facebook, Twitter, Email, etc. less in particular?
http://branch.com/b/choosing-the-best-technology-for-my-webs...
Someone likened it to a forum, and I think it's a nice take on it. Not necessarily something with SOCIAL all over it.
The promo video was pretty horrible, though. I'm also getting a little tired of Valley videos that make it sound like we're curing cancer or something.
Cancer itself is not even "one thing" phenomologically speaking (IAMNA oncologist) it's a broad class of diseases, that may or may not have a single 'solution'.
Solution, in this context, being a state where the population does not need to worry about cancer as a statistically significant cause of death. It could equally likely linger in a status that is managed but not 'cured' in the traditional sense of the word, aka HIV.
Examples (no sign in required):
http://branch.com/b/barack-obama-the-second-time-around
http://branch.com/b/alternatives-to-the-boyscouts
http://branch.com/b/buying-equity-in-people-what-do-you-thin...
If you enter your email now it should go away :)
Sorry about that!
[1] http://branch.com/b/for-years-news-developers-have-debated-t...
Neat idea. Gorgeous design. But how is Branch Inc sustainable?
It's a new way and it'll get a lot of attention, but it's really just a way to communicate and there are lots of them. If Branch succeeds, it'll do so in the adoption of its style into other communications media, including existing forums or twitter.
Maybe it is time to code what I thought ;) It was meant to be a liquid democracy citizen participatory system.
Word of warning to everyone: when you request an invite, there's a pre-checked checkbox labeled "Follow @branch to find out about the best new branches." I like that it's easy to see, but I don't like that it's opt-out.
Branch : Invite-Only Online Conversations. Email : Invite-Only Online Conversations.
Can someone help me bridge the gap?
Email has notoriously not been updated for a while. I remember when Gmail putting threads as conversations being revolutionary.
Seems like Branch would become One More Thing To Check, as opposed to a replacement for e-mail. I don't think they're going for an replacement, either. I think I get their point, but I also can't see it as much more than Twitter repackaged with unique slang and a squeaky clean UI.
Out of curiosity, where does it fit into your workflow specifically? Do you find yourself using either/any of Facebook, Twitter, Email, etc. less in particular?