It's this, 100%. The nerds that care about charge temperature and battery degradation and proliferation of incompatible charging standards are a rounding error, most people just want to know it can charge fast in case they forget and need to leave soon.
I am happy with my Chargie [1], an interposing dongle which provides a Bluetooth receiver and app that lets you set arbitrary preferences on your phone and fast charge, slow charge, or turn off the charger at configurable state of charge setpoints or times.
It needs an app but doesn't mention interoperability. There, I said it. It is not perfect.
At least they allow you to set-up-in-app-and-use-without-app which is more than many products.
Now imagine the same product but with different physical toggles or buttons on it for all the different charging modes. No apps. That'd be great.
How would it determine when the attached device reaches 80% state of charge? Or what the time of day is? How could you program a schedule for weekdays and weekends?
There are good reasons for Chargie to have an app, it's not just there to siphon up analytics.
The same way it determines that the battery is fully charged. It is a solved problem.
That said "super-fast" charging on it is like 18W and still about an hour from 20%, so it doesn't really qualify as fast charging IMO, and at an hour is certainly not going to be causing any excess battery wear. It's just normal speed.
Quick charge started at 7.5W
My charge "Standard" was set in the time 500mA was supplied by most phone chargers. Just saying I am old.
There's a manual option to turn it off (charge at full rate this time only), but not to manually turn it on (such as giving it a target time to be fully charged). Older Pixels used what time the alarm was set as the target time to finish charging, which I preferred as someone who doesn't wake up at the same time every day; I'm not sure why they took that away.
I would love to see this technology come to all phones. 80% cap might be controversial but I don't think what I am asking for is controversial in the least.
Is that actually the case? Anecdotally, all my devices which spend 99% of their time connected to external power show the least degradation in reported capacity and the best preservation of their original battery life. I'm talking about iPhones, macbooks and hp laptops.
For the latter, I have two basically identical ones, one for work and the other for home (same model number, same generation, same battery p/n). The home one rarely if ever runs on battery, it has something like 50 cycles in 4 years. The battery lasts pretty much as when it was new. The other runs often on battery and it only lasts half as much. I doubt it's a lemon, because it's the standard issue laptop at work, and my colleagues' are in the same boat.
My iphone 14 pro's reported battery health has also degraded much faster than my iphone 7's. I use it much more often on battery than the old one which spent 90% of its time plugged in. But since the devices are different, the comparison isn't as meaningful as with the laptops.
Chemically speaking, Li batteries do degrade much faster when kept at 100% for weeks on end compared to being stored at 50%, but not as fast as cycling it. The absolute worst case (without cycling) is being stored at 100% at warmer temperatures, like 40C. They will lose over 10% within a month in those conditions. I highly suggest a laptop cooler for any desk where you may use a laptop plugged in for extended periods.
Additionally, only the cheapest of cheap garbage phones would behave the way you imply. Charge controllers are readily available from TI et al with battery bypass. When the battery is full, the system runs on external power exclusively, except for the top-off charge.
It's really a pretty standard feature. You can get controllers with and without this, but you'd have to be either extremely cheap or extremely dumb to not use a controller with battery bypass in an application like a phone.
Based on my own testing, my pixel 8 will run on USB. No current fluctuations that would indicate battery cycling, just a constant draw. My previous Samsung also behaves this way.
You're right that cycling the battery this way is bad for them, that's why competent engineers don't.
https://old.reddit.com/r/GooglePixel/comments/1ha8tv9/pixel_...
(I do have an old, lower wattage charger beside my bed to limit the charge rate)
Also, I'd argue it's not obvious that 80% charging is better for most people. You're taking an immediate 20% cut to battery life, and chances are it will take years for it to actually be better than charging to 100%. I guess it's good to have the option, but only if you almost never need that last bit of capacity.
According to [1], the S24 has gone all the way up to 4.45V.
[1]: https://old.reddit.com/r/techsupport/comments/1ayqveg/samsun...
I used to build quadcopters around 2015, and some of the battery mfgs released "LiHV" batteries, which were supposed to be safe up to 4.35v, however if you actually charged them that high, they would puff up like balloons after only a couple flights. Maybe with the cumulative advancements in the last 10 years, they've been able to push up the max voltage more safely.
The arbitrary value is what voltage you stop charging at. You set your maximum cell voltage and stop charging once you reach that voltage AND input current is below a threshold. Once charging is complete, you store the current energy value as the latest full capacity. That value then becomes the 100% mark.
Remember that batteries lose capacity over time. You must continually scale your state of charge percentage to the actual state of the battery.
The final charge voltage is a tradeoff between safety, longevity, and usable capacity. Higher voltages squeeze a few more joules into the cell at the cost of much faster degradation and increased risk of catastrophic failure.
A cycle count figure on lithium cells is pretty much worthless. It depends quite a lot on exactly how you cycle the battery. A 100 to 0% cycle is much, much more damaging that a 100-50% cycle. Higher currents and temperatures degrade the cell faster. Most cell manufacturers I've seen do give cycle counts under specific test conditions, but that's hardly applicable to real use cases.
Rather than worrying about charge speeds and charge %, I’d rather just slap a new battery in after 4 years.
And it is only thin until you put on the bulky case. If phones put a real battery and intigrated basic protection, it would still be thinner than the current small battery/outer case situation. Most people don't need tank-like Otterbox protection, they just need something that keeps bumps and small drops from shattering something.
The same way my Game Boy worked in the nineties with NiMH batteries. Why did we abandon that pattern?
I’ll take the reduced size, lower weight, sturdier construction, and better waterproofing I get from the current build style.
Saving tens of dollars and an hour or two of my time every 4 years isn’t worth the compromise.
All to have a slight thinner device.
Battery life is much better now. I put phone on wireless charging pad and it is always charged when I need it. I use it all day and still have power. I carry power banks in bags if need it. External battery is better because it works with any device without having device specific batteries. Also, there are now batteries that magnetically attach to phone and wirelessly charge.
It would be nice if it was easier to replace battery, but don't need replaceable battery every day for something that happens in couple years.
The big difference is simply that battery chemistry has improved and new cells have more energy per volume.
There is no technical reason at all that we can't have replaceable cells with the capacity of current internal batteries. Unless you count waterproofing, which I've always viewed as nothing more than an excuse for planned obsolescence. There are definitely ways they could engineer water-resistant phones with replaceable cells.
"Don't you want to be online all the time, so we can spy on you ?" . Sincerely, FAANG /s
Yes, it does heat up due to energy losses, but I suspect that's way less hard on the battery than the same amount of heat from actual high current charging (please correct me if I'm wrong).
This means the only drawback is that my phone charging is cost-inefficient.
Maybe that's too much fuss for most people, but I'm still using a five year old Pixel 4A on the original battery and its showing no signs of reduced battery performance. I probably wouldn't put in the effort if it was easy to replace the battery, but it is not. I might be a little less aggressive about it if I liked any current phones, but I do not.
Yeah, I need my phone to just last until the end of the day. The charger is on the night stand. To Android's credit, if I have an alarm set, it'll time the charge to reach 100% as the alarm goes off.
With these habits, I've never had to replace my phone due to the battery, so going the extra mile to preserve the battery seems like an exercise in futility...
On my current phone I use wireless charging overnight and the 80% limit and I think that gets me most of the benefits of that hacky solution without requiring root.
The Samsung phone I had was pretty good, you had separate options to disable fast charging on either wired or wireless.
But really my solution is quite simple: none of my habitual charging spots have a fast charger, they're all 5V 2A adapters. I do have a couple of fast chargers around the house, I just don't use them unless I really need to. It's a deliberate decision to fast charge.
That and where applicable I limit my devices to 80-90% full charge. My Linux thinkpad has firmware level support for this, it's very nice.
There's one for battery protection (the 80% thing) but not for fast charging.
This is Windows 95 style UI. We don't do that anymore. We are "smart" now. With blockchain security. And you can choose any colour you like, as long as it is a shade of grey. /s
Its pretty bad that only recent phones have started to add the ability to charge to only 80% to keep the battery in the optimal zone to extend the life given how long we have known that 80% was the optimal maximum. There are also a few phones now able to power themselves from USB without using the battery which if you leave them in chargers a lot throughout the day and night seems like a good feature to have to preserve the battery further.
Maybe all the complexity around this is too much and people just want to plug it in and quick 100% as quick as possible and will change their phone regularly but its pretty wasteful. We ended up going through lots of special chargers that all do very similar things and now you get a device and it often doesn't even come with a cable let alone a charger and you are digging through the specs of your charger, cable and device to work out if its all going to mesh correctly together or you'll be stuck on slow mode. We have ended up with so many standards for getting quicker than the basic charge its going to take a while for all these devices to age out and in the meantime chargers are going to be doing QC and PD and a host of other things besides for a while.