News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by aucisson_masque on Saturday April 19, 2025 @05:19PM (#43739563)
It's interesting but so far there is no definitive proof it's happening.

People are jumping to conclusions a bit fast over here, yes technically it's possible but this kind of behavior would be relatively easy to spot because the app would have to make direct connections to the website it wants to scrap.

Your calculator app for instance connecting to CNN.com ...

iOS have app privacy report where one can check what connections are made by app, how often, last one, etc.

Android by Google doesn't have such a useful feature of course, but you can run third party firewall like pcapdroid, which I recommend highly.

Macos (little snitch).

Windows (fort firewall).

Not everyone run these app obviously, only the most nerdy like myself but we're also the kind of people who would report on app using our device to make, what is in fact, a zombie or bot network.

I'm not saying it's necessarily false but imo it remains a theory until proven otherwise.

Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by throwaway519 on Saturday April 19, 2025 @08:15PM (#43740517)
Given 5his is a thing even in browser plugins, and that so very few people analyse their firewalls, I'd not discount it at all. Much of the world's users hve no clue and app stores are notoriously bad at reacting even with publicsed malware e.g. 'free' VPNs in iOS Store.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by abaymado on Saturday April 19, 2025 @06:58PM (#43740129)
> iOS have app privacy report where one can check what connections are made by app, how often, last one, etc.

How often is the average calculator app user checking there Privacy Report? My guess, not many!

Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by gruez on Saturday April 19, 2025 @08:38PM (#43740632)
All it takes is one person to find out and raise the alarm. The average user doesn't read the source code behind openssl or whatever either, that doesn't mean there's no gains in open sourcing it.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by dewey on Sunday April 20, 2025 @12:54AM (#43741611)
The average user is also not reading these raised “alarms”. And if an app has a bad name, another one will show up with a different name on the same day.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by aucisson_masque on Sunday April 20, 2025 @01:44AM (#43741763)
You're on a tech forum, you must have seen one of the many post about app, either on Android or iPhone, that acts like spyware.

They happens from time to time, last one was not more than two week ago where it's been shown that many app were able to read the list of all other app installed on a Android and that Google refused to fix that.

Do you really believe that an app used to make your device part of a bot network wouldn't be posted over here ?

Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by dewey on Sunday April 20, 2025 @02:02AM (#43741835)
"You're on a tech forum", that's exactly the point. The "average user" is not on a tech forum though, the average user opens the app store of their platform, types "calculator" and installs the first one that's free.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by nottorp on Sunday April 20, 2025 @05:56AM (#43742758)
The real solution is to add a permission for network access, with the default set to deny.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by CharlesW on Saturday April 19, 2025 @05:34PM (#43739645)
Botnets as a Service are absolutely happening, but as you allude to, the scope of the abuse is very different on iOS than, say, Windows.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by andelink on Saturday April 19, 2025 @08:37PM (#43740619)
This is a hilariously optimistic, naive, disconnected from reality take. What sort of "proof" would be sufficient for you? TFA includes of course data from the authors own server logs^, but it also references real SDKs and business selling this exact product. You can view the pricing page yourself, right next to stats on how many IPs are available for you to exploit. What else do you need to see?

^ edit: my mistake, the server logs I mentioned were from the authors prior blog post on this topic, linked to at the top of TFA: https://jan.wildeboer.net/2025/02/Blocking-Stealthy-Botnets/

Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by jshier on Saturday April 19, 2025 @08:53PM (#43740703)
> iOS have app privacy report where one can check what connections are made by app, how often, last one, etc.

Privacy reports do not include that information. They include broad areas of information the app claims to gather. There is zero connection between those claimed areas and what the app actually does unless app review notices something that doesn't match up. But none of that information is updated dynamically, and it has never actually included the domains the app connects to. You may be confusing it with the old domain declarations for less secure HTTP connections. Once the connections met the system standards you no longer needed to declare it.

Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by zargon on Saturday April 19, 2025 @10:10PM (#43741039)
I wasn't aware of this feature. But apparently it does include that information. I just enabled it and can see the domains that apps connect to. https://support.apple.com/en-us/102188
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by hoc on Saturday April 19, 2025 @11:15PM (#43741272)
Pretty neat, actually. Thanks for looking uo that link.
Re:The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2 by Galanwe on Sunday April 20, 2025 @01:14AM (#43741676)
There is already a lot of proof. Just ask for a sales pitch from companies selling these data and they will gladly explain everything to you.

Go to a data conference like Neudata and you will see. You can have scraped data from user devices, real-time locations, credit card, Google analytics, etc.