News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by xattt on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:07AM (#43705029)
There’s an interesting shift in perspective that’s been happening around Nintendo over the last decade.

While the organization still presents as an odd-ball Japanese company with quirky qualities, it’s becoming more and more apparent they are commanded by MBA-types that are seeking to protect as much IP as possible, and squeeze out the last penny from fun.

Things I’ve purchased from them in the last little while are probably at my high-end of tolerance of what things should cost.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by bluefirebrand on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:01AM (#43705696)
> commanded by MBA-types that are seeking to protect as much IP as possible, and squeeze out the last penny from fun

I'm not really sure how you can look at the state of the modern gaming industry, full of gacha/loot box and cosmetic microtransactions and suggest that Nintendo is somehow trying to squeeze pennies when they are one of the least egregious offenders in this area

In a world where Fortnite and Mobile games are vacuuming cash directly from peoples wallets, you're mad at Nintendo who is still releasing games you can just own?

Please help me understand

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by xattt on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:39AM (#43706151)
Nintendo had a conventional approach to gaming for a number of years. No microtransactions, skins, etc.

In the last decade, they’ve been aggressively pursuing emulator hobbyists and “making deals they couldn’t refuse” (Yuzu).

Recently, they started offering a “soundtrack” app as part of the benefits of Nintendo Online where you can listen to music from their first-party games. I see this as an administrative move to demonstrate active marketing of their properties, to delay their copyrights lapse (similar to Disney bringing Steamboat Willy to try to preserve a 100-year-old copyright).

Also see the Switch 2 tech demo app being sold rather than included. Can you imagine if Microsoft charged for the Windows XP tour, or Apple for the Tips app?

There is not one single aspect I can point to that makes you say “gotcha”, but micro-aggressions against fans seem to be adding up and tipping the scale away from a company that gives warm, fuzzy feelings deserving of fandom.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:02AM (#43706460)
I don't know, I actually do somewhat get it.

If there is a product, you pay for the product. People do not respect, or value, things they do not pay for. Steve Jobs had a similar philosophy with refusing to offer free meals at Apple - subsidized meals was okay, free meals was not okay.

Having worked in a small business, I have seen painfully firsthand how giving customers free things almost always backfires and just creates extremely demanding customers. Look at how demanding customers are of Nintendo right now that the Welcome Tour be free; even though they would not be demanding it if Nintendo had just not made the Welcome Tour at all. They would be literally happier and less demanding if it had never been made, which is backwards.

On that note; Nintendo does have to somewhat be cautious about their intellectual property in ways other companies do not. We like to think of things as Xbox, PlayStation, and Nintendo; but this is an illusion. Apple makes four times as much money per year from mobile gaming than Nintendo does in entirety. Xbox and PlayStation have plenty of fallback cash from the rest of their respective companies; Nintendo is the smallest of the three and has no fallback option.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by bluefirebrand on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:07AM (#43706501)
> Nintendo is the smallest of the three and has no fallback option

Nintendo reportedly has $15 billion in cash, while PlayStation and Xbox are both marginal

Framing Nintendo as "the small one" is funny :)

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:11AM (#43706526)
Sony has $20 billion of cash on hand as of December 2024, Microsoft has $70 billion of cash on hand, and Apple has $53 billion of cash on hand. If something goes south, the rest of the company can keep them afloat (and has in multiple cases, see Xbox 360 red ring); Nintendo has no such luxury.

Sony receives 38% of their revenue from PlayStation. Microsoft receives 8% of their revenue from Xbox. Apple's amount is four times larger than Nintendo, but insignificant to Apple. Nintendo, meanwhile, >90% at least comes from gaming-related activity (movie and toy licensing might be the exception).

Yes, Nintendo is the smallest, the most dependent on the industry, and it's not even close.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by bluefirebrand on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:20AM (#43706608)
> Sony has $20 billion of cash on hand as of December 2024

Sony is $28 Billion in debt as of 2024 too

> Microsoft has $70 billion of cash on hand

Microsoft has $62 billion in debt

> Apple has $53 billion of cash on hand

I'll leave the rest as an exercise for the reader

How much debt is Nintendo in? (Hint- It's insignificant)

Now you can do the usual capitalist moron MBA shit and moan about how debt is good actually, but frankly

Nintendo is Japans most successful company and Sony isn't even in the top 300

Nintendo is real, Sony is a paper tiger

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by kod on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:27PM (#43707327)
> Nintendo is Japans most successful company and Sony isn't even in the top 300

by what bizarro metric is Nintendo more successful than Toyota? debt to equity ratio is all you care about?

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by bluefirebrand on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:42PM (#43707500)
Successful may have been the wrong term, but Nintendo is (or was last year at least) Japan's richest company.

This is not a trivial thing

https://toyokeizai.net/articles/-/713322

> debt to equity ratio is all you care about?

All I care about? No, but you cannot so easily dismiss it either

Companies, even huge ones, that are highly leveraged are in a precarious spot. A competitor could simply buy them, a bad product launch could lead to investors pulling out and the company being parted out and sold... Many industries are littered with the remains of huge, "untouchable" companies that were vulnerable because of their debt load

Companies having savings and low debt load is good for the company and its employees actually

It is only bad if you are a hyper capitalist investor idiot who doesn't care about the long term success of the company and just want to extract as much wealth as you possibly can for yourself before leaving it to crumble

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by kod on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @01:07PM (#43707791)
So toyota made more in net income last quarter alone than nintendo has in net cash, but they're less successful? Seems like a really weird metric.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by bluefirebrand on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @01:43PM (#43708279)
They also have way more debt than Nintendo's net cash so?

Businesses may be comfortable operating in massive debt but it's clearly only sustainable for so long

Businesses operating under the kinds of debt loads they take on are what leads to irresponsible government bailouts to keep "key industries" from collapsing when they are unable to service their debt

Sure, Toyota is "successful" until it isn't, and then their debt comes due and they can't pay so it collapses

We should be encouraging more companies to be responsible like Nintendo

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by xattt on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:25PM (#43707302)
> I have seen painfully firsthand how giving customers free things almost always backfires and just creates extremely demanding customers

I appreciate that. Running a small business is no small feat, and takes every bit of blood, sweat and tears to make it work.

I also want to draw contrasts to the indie music scene in the mid-aughts and the situation with Nintendo now. A number of bands had their music pirated or offered for free, but truly appreciated by fans. As a result, these bands saw at least moderate successes when they toured: fans saw the effort of touring as actual work, rather than nickel-and-diming.

Nintendo should be following this “indie” path (continue creating innovative games), rather than aggressive rent-seeking (legacy IP property protectionism).

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:42PM (#43707505)
I really don't buy that what worked for the indie music scene, has anything to do with how Nintendo does business. Piracy can, and does, have a serious impact on video game sales - about 20% fewer sales according to the University of North Carolina (https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2024/10/the-true-cost-of-game...).

I also don't buy that Nintendo is forced into an either/or. Their strategy is to do both; and it seems to be working just fine.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by kmeisthax on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:12PM (#43709836)
> I see this as an administrative move to demonstrate active marketing of their properties, to delay their copyrights lapse (similar to Disney bringing Steamboat Willy to try to preserve a 100-year-old copyright).

Copyright doesn't work that way. You're thinking of trademark law, which only covers how you can name things in commerce, not what you can and can't copy.

The only thing about copyright that's use-it-or-lose-it is fair use, and only because of how English-language[0] legal systems work. You may have heard that Japan "doesn't have fair use", but what that really means is that they don't have binding precedent. This gives copyright owners an incentive to litigate novel reuses of their work early and often.

Nintendo, of course, is the kind of company that doesn't need an excuse to sue someone; but it does explain why they tend to be very slightly more litigious in common-law countries.

I imagine the real reason they released the soundtrack app is to keep third-parties out of their business. i.e. they don't have to pay 30% to Apple or deal with Spotify's shitty "pay out of a pot" system if their soundtracks are just an NSO benefit.

[0] Yes, I know this is "English-heritage" not "English-language", but in practice this is a language split.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by ericzawo on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @09:30AM (#43705300)
Their hatred for some of their most loyal fans vis a vis their punishment for sharing content, running tournaments and keeping game legacy alive is so brazen it would make entities like the NFL and Ticketmaster jump for joy.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by kjkjadksj on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:18PM (#43707213)
On the other hand they still sell new game cube controllers. Upgraded even from the old ones with a longer cord. They didn’t have to do that. They could have said screw you buy a pro controller. At least for that one product there was a hint of sympathy for the competitive smash community.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by decae on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:30AM (#43706053)
I wouldn't say it's hatred, they're just extremely risk adverse - every situation needs to be entered with caution. It seems to be common across a wide range of Japanese companies.

Recently, there is a certain amount of Disneyesque revenue maximization that seems to be going on though, and keeping control of legacy titles is a part of that for sure.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:04AM (#43706469)
Every time Nintendo tries to set foot in the competitive scene or permit tournaments, this happens.

https://www.reddit.com/r/smashbros/comments/hjfv0y/summary_o...

I don't blame them for trying to keep out. It would seem that professional Smash players are not to be assumed as stable people.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by mrandish on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:12PM (#43709221)
Yes, they're risk adverse but in the last couple of years, Nintendo has also become much more legally expansive than they were. Of course, Nintendo has long been legally aggressive, especially in protecting their trademarks ("Super Mario" et al) but the expansiveness is both new and deeply problematic. It was fine when Nintendo was legally aggressive suing unlicensed Super Mario T-shirt makers but in the past couple of years they're going just as aggressively after retro fan and preservation communities and other non-profit, minor players who they previously mostly ignored.

This change was a conscious decision and makes little sense because these new targets have always tangentially infringed some IP rights but never in ways that had measurable financial impact on Nintendo's current core products. And, arguably, retro preservation and fan communities are net positive for Nintendo's brand. Even notoriously litigious companies like Disney choose to selectively turn a blind eye to cosplayers in Marvel super hero capes. Threatening or suing your hardest core, most loyal brand fans for doing things that didn't make them money or cost you money (at least rounded to the nearest $100) is not only a waste of resources, it's actively bad for your brand.

This has turned me from generally positive toward Nintendo to literally hating the brand. Sure, doing this is technically within their rights but it's just being shitty and there's no compelling reason they had to change from being selectively reasonable to "full-on asshole" toward their fans.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by bzzzt on Thursday April 17, 2025 @04:35AM (#43714343)
Nintendo isn't changing, the world around it is. 15 years ago there were no youtubers who built a business around pasting a talking head over a video game stream. It seems nobody even asks Nintendo if they are ok with that and now people are angry because the answer turned out to be 'no'. That's not how copyright works. The emulator authors who made millions by accepting donations with the explicit promise of facilitating piracy of the latest Nintendo games still for sale also should have known better. There's a lot of hate for Nintendo right now, but imo it's all on entitled gamers who want stuff that Nintendo created for free. There's no company that can safisfy those demands and stay in business.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by seventhtiger on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:38AM (#43706148)
Japanese game companies are a lot more protective about their IP. Nintendo is simply consistent about that in the West. To them it's quite normal to exercise a lot of control over how your work is presented in public, which includes things like tournaments, emulation, fan games, mods, and so on.

A Japanese Youtuber was arrested for posting spoilers of a visual novel: https://www.gamesindustry.biz/japanese-authorities-make-thei...

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by kjkjadksj on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @12:15PM (#43707178)
When you start getting familiar with other japanese companies you realize its not that nintendo is fake “japanese” and has this mba side, its that they are japanese through and through including getting hard up on ip. This sort of thing plagues any japanese company I am familiar with. Car companies. Fujifilm. Same thing. Market on “creative, different, japanese” but its really a locked down product with artificial moats they put in to protect their incremental upgrade models. When you realize the potential of what these sorts of companies could do you get a little sad of the route they instead trot down.

For example fujifilm is resting on their laurels during the modern film resurgeance. They have stopped making film for the american market and let kodak make it for them and slap their logo on it. Every film lab in the world worth their salt still uses their 30 year old Fronteir scanning system because there is literally nothing better made as film industry investment fell off a cliff 30 years ago and large scale engineering efforts in that sector ended. And of course the cameras. Everyone is using an old slowly dying film camera because they don’t make new ones. And fujifilm had some of the best of the best in their “texas leica” medium format cameras. It is like civilization died in this sector and we are living off the scraps of what was left from the great civilization. Why does fuji do this? Avoiding their seat on the throne in this growing newfound industry?

Because hubris. They are japanese. They made the decision to forget about film and they are set on it damnit. They don’t want to cannibalize the sales of their modern day digital cameras (even though they probably won’t). They have a good thing going where they increment features on a couple hundred dollar camera bodies. What they don’t realize is the film buffs today probably pay vastly more in film than digital shooters pay upgrading their camera bodies a year on average. So much money left on the table just totally obsinate reasons for leaving it too that boil down to a certain hubris you see in japanese companies.

Don’t even get me started on Toyota.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by numpad0 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:19AM (#43705921)
You don't know what "MBA-type" is.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by xattt on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:43AM (#43706208)
Maybe, but do you have a term for someone that makes decisions based on spreadsheets, market surveys, and maxing out profits while ignoring years of goodwill from fans?
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by skyyler on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:23AM (#43706631)
If they were making decisions based on maxing out profits, there would be a Mario Wonder Battle Pass and the gacha mechanics in the new zelda would include microtransactions.

Mario Kart for $80 is not MBA stuff, even if it makes the gamers really upset.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by egypturnash on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:17PM (#43709279)
According to online calculators, $20 in 1980 dollars is worth about $80 today. $77.something to be precise, close enough.

I chose 1980 because that's when Space Invaders came out for the VCS. And $20 was, IIRC, the going rate for the average VCS cartridge.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by skyyler on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:45PM (#43709555)
For a more direct comparison, Mario Kart: Double Dash!! came out in 2003 on the Nintendo Gamecube, at an MSRP of $49.99.

That is $86 in today money.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by numpad0 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @11:37AM (#43706783)
The guys you don't mess with.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by wan23 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @01:02PM (#43707731)
If that's the case, imagine if you were trying to buy games back in the SNES days. The cost for many new games was the same or higher in absolute dollars as today, but much higher if you do the calculation to 2025 dollars.
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by jjice on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @02:54PM (#43709027)
As a long time Nintendo fan, I've always joked with my friends that the people who design the games are incredibly talented and passionate, and the people that run the business throws all of that good will alone.

They've had the worst online stores for a while now. They're not up nearly as long as Microsoft and Sony have kept their older console's stores around, and they've been hostile with transfers too.

I remember playing N64 games on the Wii for $10 a pop. Then, if I recall, the Wii U didn't support the N64 games and then the Switch didn't until a few years ago, all under a $50 per year subscription and a much smaller library.

The business side of Nintendo has been brutal for a while. It's a shame they make some of the best games...

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by rightbyte on Thursday April 17, 2025 @02:52AM (#43713840)
> They've had the worst online stores for a while now.

Oh I see that as a feature. I buy Switch games over disk.

Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by jjice on Thursday April 17, 2025 @07:49AM (#43715422)
Absolutely - I only buy physical for Nintendo. Seems like they’re going to be attempting to make a move away from that from what I’ve heard. Something about physical boxes just having download codes instead of a cart for some Switch 2 games?
Re:Nintendo Bled Atari Games to Death by rightbyte on Thursday April 17, 2025 @02:49AM (#43713817)
Have you played Super Mario Odyssey? They are not copy pasting SM64.