But the very second things change on the top, they flip.
Yes quite a few people are upset at this. They concretely damaged their brand, ruined trust, and pissed off a bunch of their target market. There is an intentional boycott now and it is clearly affecting their stock
It wasn't because Costco embraced DEI as much as Target actively dropping it as quickly as possible after Inauguration Day. They didn't even wait for a challenge. To me that means they were happy to drop it as quickly as they could. Which means it was all for show in the first place.
I've also seen a few half-assed attempts to go viral and bring customers back, which only makes me want to spend more elsewhere.
- Demographics https://www.numerator.com/snapshots/target/
- More demographics https://www.contimod.com/target-statistics/
What might be interesting is to sample your persons more broadly (across country) and in more quantity?
And granted, their furniture design is pretty nice, compared to what their competitor big-boxes stock.
May not be needed to say: in an authoritarian society, compliance paradoxically breeds more authoritarianism.
(From AI, and I agree with) The idea of the impact of compliance in authoritarian societies is .., Active Compliance > Passive Compliance > and finally, Pre-Compliance.
- Bonus: discussion of the assertion that those in upperclass authoritarian societies DO comply with, and aren't affected by authoritarian policies ( Note this is for INDIVIDUALS not corporations, I speculate it works the same however ) https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/paradox-voluntary-compliance-...
So, watch as Us here on Hacker News start to encourage Active compliance, move to Passive, and then encourage Pre-Compliance!
Then, BINGO! "You're an authoritarian enabler!"
Yes. This is an anecdote but I personally know people who are boycotting Target and a lot of other companies that backtracked on DEI and LGBTQ rights. I think these companies are all posturing and will say what they think will get you in the door but other people I know are taking this personally and changing their spending habits to reflect that.
Executives at Target made the calculation that their sales wouldn't decline much (if at all) by publicly canceling their DEI programs.
To the question about Target and Costco's prices: Typically these retailers will have price matching policies in place to keep foot traffic.
Quick google search implies (not sure how accurate this is), that approximately 12% of Target's demographic is black [0]. Seeing close to a 10% drop in foot traffic for a low margin business like Target when a competitor is seeing almost the near opposite gains is a signal someone really screwed up.
I've never met a single person that had a mindset of "I need to pick up some stuff at Target... oh wait I just remembered they cancelled their internal DEI program, I'd better do some research and shop at a retailer that still has a DEI program instead"
I guess I'm just not sure how the causality was determined. How do I know foot traffic isn't decreasing because of Target's prices compared to Costco's prices?