Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by Aeolun on Saturday April 05, 2025 @08:49PM
(#43598048)
I think the article mentions banning “sold advertising”, which seems like a fair way to go about it. You can still advertise your own stuff, but you cannot pay a marketplace to do it for you any more. Advertising would by necessity become a lot more local.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
How would I advertise my app? Or my TV brand?
[delayed]
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by Tempest1981 on Saturday April 05, 2025 @10:08PM
(#43598402)
Reputable review sites are better than random advertisements
[delayed]
The context of this thread is that vendors wouldn't be able to pay review sites.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by onemoresoop on Sunday April 06, 2025 @02:15AM
(#43599317)
Because its not illegal to do shenanigans and they indeed invaded all product review sites with dishonest reviews
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by etempleton on Saturday April 05, 2025 @10:17PM
(#43598433)
How do those sites make money if advertising doesn’t exist?
A major challenge in journalism is because of the collapse in value of banner ads. No one but the very largest newspapers have sustainable businesses in the United States and they only do because of the critical mass they have reached with subscribers.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by polygamous_bat on Sunday April 06, 2025 @01:01AM
(#43599063)
Good information is valuable. When internet didn’t exist people paid good money for newspaper and magazines because they provided good information which people found valuable.
I subscribe to a magazine that publishes tests and reviews of everything from lawn fertiliser to spices, via vacuums and mobile phones. It costs money and I trust that they are not bribed.
It seems rather certain an end to advertising would mean the death of lots of low-quality "media".
Then they can't be free, consumers need to pay for them.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by onemoresoop on Sunday April 06, 2025 @02:20AM
(#43599327)
Or consumers could contribute back to them making them free resources. Remember the early internet? It was free and it had no ads. That until the pop-ups and flashy banner ads showed up murkying the waters. It appears that advertising inherently wants to agressively take all out attention.
The problem here is that I'm not subscribing to a magazine that reviews lawnmowers, if I need a lawnmower once every 10 years.
Some kind of micro-transaction system is needed for this, so that I can easily buy just that one review.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by Tempest1981 on Sunday April 06, 2025 @02:59PM
(#43603984)
If I couldn't find a reputable reviewer, I would ask my neighbors. More trustworthy than a banner ad.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by singpolyma3 on Sunday April 06, 2025 @08:03AM
(#43600824)
Except that reviews are ads...
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal?
by dismalpedigree on Sunday April 06, 2025 @08:19AM
(#43600919)
Yet another reason to ban paid ads.