Where do you draw the line between "When there are no judicial penalties [...] eventually people seek extrajudicial ones" and "some nutjob went on a shooting spree"? There's no shortage of people killing because of "the great replacement" or "pedophile elites", issues the government aren't exactly in a hurry to address. Are those also examples of "When there are no judicial penalties [...] eventually people seek extrajudicial ones", or can we just chalk them up to the shooters being nutjobs? Is the former just what people say when they're sympathetic to the shooter, similar to how terrorists you support are "rebels" or "freedom fighters"?
The converse question is also valid - when do we accept that the system is so unjust and broken that people need to take justice into their own hands? Where do YOU draw the line?
In my view when police are kidnapping people off the streets for expressing political viewpoints, when government power is nakedly being used to benefit the individuals wielding it, and so on, we're moving pretty quickly towards a situation where there's not much rational basis for believing the system will hold wrongdoers accountable. That's setting aside the fact that the wrongdoing by the health insurance industry has been going on for decades with little accountability.
I wouldn't say we're at the point where a killing like this is justified, but we're a lot closer than we were a year ago.
The particularly frustrating and worrisome bit is that there are obvious moves forward that I think would greatly reduce the likelihood (and perceived acceptability) of vigilantism, but the people in power are unwilling to make those moves. These are things like passing laws to make large swaths of current health industry behavior illegal, with specific penalties against executives, board members, large shareholders, and others who profit from the bad acts, and then rushing in to prosecute and imprison those people and confiscate the majority of their wealth. No more mister nice guy, no more dithering, just direct, forceful, unstinting action against everyone who has gotten rich off other people's suffering --- but doing it via the mechanism of law and justice to demonstrate that it is an implementation of the will of the people. That would make people feel like the system is working. But when those in government are unwilling to do that, it makes people feel like those in government would rather have the occasional vigilante killing, and that they are on the side of the executives rather than everybody else --- and that in turn makes a small minority of people more willing to give those officials what they asked for.
A lot of people's understanding of the American health insurance system is closer to one of the "lunatic ones".
Single payer healthcare. At least governments are (at least somewhat) accountable to the people.
Progressive wealth taxes. It's possible that the only solution is for CEOs to be accountable to the general public. Currently, their wealth insulates them from normal methods of holding them accountable (e.g. loss of social standing, stores refusing to do business with them, etc.) so people turn to methods like shooting them. Perhaps if taxation made them more accountable then people would have other methods available.
The murdered United Healthcare CEO wasn't even all that wealthy. IIRC he had something like 20 million. Way more than the average American, sure, but not even wealthy enough to be impacted by the wealth taxes proposed by Bernie Sanders. Compared to the likes of Musk or Thiel, his wealth was nothing.
Wealth taxes are controversial. I suspect they should be based on a combination of aggregate wealth and financial transaction taxes. IMO, $20 million should have been enough to trigger a wealth tax.
What's your silver bullet to make healthcare better? The companies are already spending almost all their revenue on healthcare, there is very little profit anyway.
It would be more accurate to say that insurance companies are paying most of their revenue to healthcare providers (many of which are owned by the same people who own insurance companies), who are known to charge obscene amounts of money for services that cost a fraction of the cost elsewhere in the world.
Looking at the financial reports of insurance companies in isolation is insufficient when they're part of a much larger corrupt system.
The point of the steelmaning isn't so "the great replacement" can be declared as "true", it's to point out it's not hard to come up with a slightly revised cause that isn't "wingding nonsense". Sure, it's easy to write off the guy who shoots up a school because of "the great replacement", but what if the next guy is shooting over Biden's immigration policy? Does he get a pass now because "The Biden administration really are evil", on the basis that "they're putting immigrants ahead of Americans" or whatever?
>We can't have a standard applies to both real political grievances and fake lunatic ones.
I'm so glad that there's a universal standard of what counts as a "real political grievances" that everyone can agree on!
This is where individual opinion basically doesn't matter. This is where collective opinion ends up setting discourse.
There is a reason no one really mourned for the CEO. And a reason Luigi is seen as a hero in the vast majority of circles.
source? Only 17% of americans find the killing was "acceptable", which isn't same question as "hero", but I think most would agree that an action being "acceptable" is a prerequisite to being a "hero". At best, he's anti-hero.
https://www.axios.com/2024/12/17/united-healthcare-ceo-killi...
I think private support - the kind you can’t poll - is far far higher
1. the opposite can also be true, ie. people taking anti-establilshment stances to be edgy or whatever. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/03/05/online-op...
2. Your argument seems to basically "17% or 41% is far lower than I observe, therefore it must be because people are cowed into hiding their actual opinions". That might be the case, but it's also possible you're in a filter bubble that's not representative of the public as a whole. For instance if you were on reddit last year you might have gotten the impression there was a universal consensus that Trump had zero support and that Mangione did nothing wrong, but know now that the former was obviously false.
Hence suspect. I didn't state it definitively for that reason alone. I can only infer based on things like sentiment analysis and reading volumes of comments, reports (news and otherwise) and of course, polls. It all offers very conflicting ideas of how people really feel about him, what he did, and the CEO. That all take in sum, seems to suggest there is more support than any one poll captures.
That said, I understand that is all sociological qualitative analysis, therefore must admit it could be wrong.
>2. Your argument seems to basically "17% or 41% is far lower than I observe, therefore it must be because people are cowed into hiding their actual opinions". That might be the case, but it's also possible you're in a filter bubble that's not representative of the public as a whole. For instance if you were on reddit last year you might have gotten the impression there was a universal consensus that Trump had zero support and that Mangione did nothing wrong, but know now that the former was obviously false.
It does not, which is why I never said anything like that. See my response above. Its based on a number of factors, of which anecdotal evidence is not a factor.
This is still a very useful signal if you’re thinking long term society health.
This should have an opportunity for folks to have serious conversations about reform and making things better, but my expectation of what I think will happen vs what is happening unfortunately don’t match
> of which anecdotal evidence is not a factor.
Comments are absolutely anecdotal. Luigi was extremely popular with the typical politically active Reddit base. Additionally, the people that don’t support him aren’t going to come out and say “well I’m against murder”.
So you end up with huge echo chambers that vastly overstate the support because it’s 2% of the people cheering each other on.
Perhaps the point where people like you try to depict regular people acting out of despair as nut jobs.
Think for a minute: one of the most popular tv shows in modern history is a story of a man with an elite education going to the extreme of running a small criminal organization due to financial pressure caused by a life-threatening medical condition. That was what the US watched for years for escapism.
Mangione was most certainly not "acting out of despair". He came from a wealthy family, had ivy league education, and wasn't even denied coverage. At best you could argue he was in "despair" because of his botched back surgery, but that's hardly a reason to shoot the UNH CEO.
>Think for a minute: one of the most popular tv shows in modern history is a story of a man with an elite education going to the extreme of running a small criminal organization due to financial pressure caused by a life-threatening medical condition. That was what the US watched for years for escapism.
It really isn't. Any critical viewing of the series would reveal that Walter was doing it out of pride rather than necessity. His ex-business partners at Grey Matter even offered to pay for his treatment, but he refused.
You’re arguing despair is only driven by socioeconomic factors. This ignores the very real despair one can go through and have a lasting effect on going through the medical system, seeing loved ones, friends and colleagues struggle with it, and a myriad of other vectors that can and do cause feelings of despair
Surely if he was pushed to violence for personal reasons, you'd expect him to shoot up the hospital that botched his back surgery? Why shoot the CEO of a company where he had no personal connection to? Does "despair" just mean any sort of grievance? Can you say that someone shooting up a planned parenthood clinic was because "despair" at "babies being killed" or whatever?
Theres 2nd order effects at play in this case that make it unique and unlike other ones. Even including other cases where there are acts of violence for what on the surface would seem like similar reasons.
Therefore no I don't think you can extrapolate this into broader politically motivated violence and/or forms of despair. This case is sufficiently unique in its context and should be viewed as such.
Folks are free to disagree, that is how I feel about it though.
And as for the accused, I will not try and speak for the accused, as its not my place to.
Was Luigi already tried and found to guilty? Don't let your bias show.
Also, your blend of argument feels like a straw man. You're not actually debating who pulled the trigger, but why millions of people suddenly and enthusiastically support a random assassination of a CEO of a health insurance company. Why do you think that happens? Can you conceive any explanation?
People didn’t care about the premise of medical debt at all. It could have just have easily been coercion to pay a ransom. The plot only needed him to be innocent for the initial hook.
I and others swarm on here to shut down people who try to justify the crimes committed by right wingers motivated by the same reasoning. It's only when it comes to Luigi Mangione that I feel suddenly alone.
What is the next step in your mind?
Humans are so interesting when you put them in groups.
UnitedHealthcare was my health insurance provider when my daughter got her heart transplant. They paid over $2M over several years, without a single hitch. I think the only thing we were rejected for was when we asked them to cover baby formula (it was a long shot).
Mangione wasn’t even a UHC customer.
The only machine of death here was in that lunatic’s hand.
The fact that you dragged up your daughter's open heart surgery to try to "make [me] look ridiculous" is honestly one of the more disgusting things I've read in the comments here, no other way to put that (I'm not gonna do the reddit "have a nice evening" games after something that depraved). Real sick stuff man, I hope that's not a trend. Kinda depressing to read.
No one's setting it. Things have been that way in the past. A lot of laws now are designed to avoid allowing organizations to brutalize people so badly that those people view violence as the only recourse.
When there are no judicial penalties for running a vast machine of death like UnitedHealthcare, then eventually people seek extrajudicial ones. Our goal should be to make sure that this doesn't happen. Luigi is a symptom, not the sickness to be treated.