News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by harimau777 on Sunday March 30, 2025 @08:28PM (#43529289)
One big difference is that one is true and the other isn't.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by gruez on Sunday March 30, 2025 @08:35PM (#43529343)
If the framing is merely "When there are no judicial penalties [...] eventually people seek extrajudicial ones", then it doesn't really matter whether it's objectively true or not, only whether people think it's true or not. And to the people who are aggrieved by "the great replacement" or "pedophile elites", they most certainly think it's true. Moreover, it's not hard to think of steelman versions either conspiracy theory that are true. For instance there might not be an actual coordinated conspiracy to replace white American voters with foreigners, but there's certainly a push on the left to allow for more migration, and just a decade ago Democratic strategists were bragging about how demographic change was going to mean they were going to be assured victory for the next few decades.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by ElevenLathe on Sunday March 30, 2025 @08:44PM (#43529403)
Steelman as much as you like, the fact is that health insurance companies really are evil, and the "great replacement" is wingding nonsense. We can't have a standard applies to both real political grievances and fake lunatic ones.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by Manuel_D on Sunday March 30, 2025 @10:32PM (#43530201)
United Healthcare had a 6% profit margin last year. They spend something like 85% of revenue on medical care. Health insurance is one of the most regulated industries in the country. What is your proposed change to fix healthcare in the US?

A lot of people's understanding of the American health insurance system is closer to one of the "lunatic ones".

Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by harimau777 on Sunday March 30, 2025 @10:48PM (#43530329)
I can think of two potential solutions:

Single payer healthcare. At least governments are (at least somewhat) accountable to the people.

Progressive wealth taxes. It's possible that the only solution is for CEOs to be accountable to the general public. Currently, their wealth insulates them from normal methods of holding them accountable (e.g. loss of social standing, stores refusing to do business with them, etc.) so people turn to methods like shooting them. Perhaps if taxation made them more accountable then people would have other methods available.

Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by Manuel_D on Sunday March 30, 2025 @10:52PM (#43530368)
How does single payer healthcare solve problems? You point out that this means people can blame the government for poor quality service, but you don't actually explain how this will improve service.

The murdered United Healthcare CEO wasn't even all that wealthy. IIRC he had something like 20 million. Way more than the average American, sure, but not even wealthy enough to be impacted by the wealth taxes proposed by Bernie Sanders. Compared to the likes of Musk or Thiel, his wealth was nothing.

Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by rickydroll on Monday March 31, 2025 @09:23AM (#43534778)
Most research into the outcomes of single-payer healthcare universal coverage systems shows that they deliver better patient outcomes for less money. I don't know how they give better service, and I'm not familiar with the oversight mechanisms, but the documented results are that they do.

Wealth taxes are controversial. I suspect they should be based on a combination of aggregate wealth and financial transaction taxes. IMO, $20 million should have been enough to trigger a wealth tax.

Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by nothercastle on Sunday March 30, 2025 @11:14PM (#43530516)
I think there is probably a lot of claim denial and bullshit rolled up into the 85% number. You make it seem like they are an efficient distributor of healthcare where which they are not. Every provider hates them because they create a ridiculous amount of Paperwork overhead and cost to the entire system. They are the healthcare equivalent of DOGE.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by Manuel_D on Sunday March 30, 2025 @11:35PM (#43530629)
People have contradictory expectations of healthcare. They want it to be more efficient and avoid waste, but when the healthcare company institutes systems of accountability people complain about paperwork.

What's your silver bullet to make healthcare better? The companies are already spending almost all their revenue on healthcare, there is very little profit anyway.

Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by dns_snek on Monday March 31, 2025 @08:13AM (#43534067)
> The companies are already spending almost all their revenue on healthcare, there is very little profit anyway.

It would be more accurate to say that insurance companies are paying most of their revenue to healthcare providers (many of which are owned by the same people who own insurance companies), who are known to charge obscene amounts of money for services that cost a fraction of the cost elsewhere in the world.

Looking at the financial reports of insurance companies in isolation is insufficient when they're part of a much larger corrupt system.

Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by nothercastle on Tuesday April 01, 2025 @11:06AM (#43547681)
Honestly the Keiser Permanente insurer/provider hmo model is pretty decent. There isn’t a lot of profit in it but it does a decent job rationing out care in appropriate and ethical ways.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by gruez on Sunday March 30, 2025 @08:53PM (#43529474)
>Steelman as much as you like, the fact is that health insurance companies really are evil, and the "great replacement" is wingding nonsense

The point of the steelmaning isn't so "the great replacement" can be declared as "true", it's to point out it's not hard to come up with a slightly revised cause that isn't "wingding nonsense". Sure, it's easy to write off the guy who shoots up a school because of "the great replacement", but what if the next guy is shooting over Biden's immigration policy? Does he get a pass now because "The Biden administration really are evil", on the basis that "they're putting immigrants ahead of Americans" or whatever?

>We can't have a standard applies to both real political grievances and fake lunatic ones.

I'm so glad that there's a universal standard of what counts as a "real political grievances" that everyone can agree on!

Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by aaomidi on Sunday March 30, 2025 @09:06PM (#43529573)
There isn't a universal standard.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by ElevenLathe on Monday March 31, 2025 @11:25AM (#43536128)
Right, we're not doing politics on a frictionless infinite plane though. At some point, somebody has to make a judgment about the actual content of the complaint. Should we do single payer to prevent violent wingnuts from offing people in broad daylight to the tearful applause of millions? Yes, probably. Should we turn up the horror on the southern border even more to appease your uncle who is complaining about Qanon in the Craigslist "missed connections" section? Probably not. Why? We thought about it and decided the former is a good idea related to a real problem but the latter is just pointless cruelty that doesn't solve anything, not even getting people to stop complaining (since they'll just pick some other made-up problem). If you disagree, you're my political enemy and we have to work it out, hopefully without violence.
Re:Luigi Mangione-Inspired Ballot Initiative Targets Health ... by lolinder on Sunday March 30, 2025 @08:33PM (#43529330)
Truth doesn't matter when the question is what kinds of tactics we want to officially endorse for moving the political needle. Any tactics you adopt become fair game for your opponent, and if we start seeing laws named after Luigi we will start seeing laws named after the next conspiracy theorist killer.