News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by turnsout on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:19PM (#43485161)
Yeah, but the calculator analogy is apt. In the past, anyone who went to grade school could answer 6 * 7 off the top of their head, and do basic mental math. We've pretty much lost that.

With that said, I do worry that losing the ability to craft sentences (or code) is more problematic than losing the ability to do mental math.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:30PM (#43485284)
Losing the ability to do mental math is probably not actually a big deal

Losing the ability to do calculations by hand on a piece of paper with a pencil probably actually is a big deal

When I went to school we still had to do a lot of calculations by hand on paper. Thus, if I use a calculator to get an answer, I'm capable of reproducing the answer by hand if necessary

With math, at least when I was learning it, we seemed to understand that the calculator is a useful tool that doesn't replace the need to develop underlying skills

I'm seeing the exact opposite behavior and mentality from the AI crowd. "You don't need to learn how to do that correctly anymore, you can just have the AI do it"

"Vibe Coding", literally the attitude that you don't need to understand your code anymore. You just have the AI generate it and go off vibes to decide if it's right or not

Yeah, I don't know how my car engine works. But I trust that the people who engineered it do, and the mechanics that fix it when it breaks do. There's no room for "Vibe Bridge Building" in reality

Anyone advocating for "Vibe coding" is an admission that it doesn't actually matter if the thing they build works or not

Unfortunately that seems to be a growing portion of software

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by rqtwteye on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:07PM (#43485741)
“ Losing the ability to do mental math is probably not actually a big deal”

I think it’s a huge deal. I see a lot of people do some financing stuff and they have no idea what a 20% interest rate really means. So they just go ahead and do it because taking out a calculator is too tedious. I find it pretty crazy how many can’t figure how much a 20% or even 10% is. A lot of financial offerings take advantage of the fact that people can’t do even basic math.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:12PM (#43485803)
If taking out a calculator is too much of a burden when we all have smartphones with built in calculator apps, then the problem is not the lack of mental math skill.

Edit: At best, it shows that the person doesn't really know how to calculate that even with a calculator

At worst, it shows that the person lacks of any kind of give a fuck at all

Either way, they probably would not likely have learned the mental math required to do this regardless of if it were being taught at school or not

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by pessimizer on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:36PM (#43486168)
> At best, it shows that the person doesn't really know how to calculate that even with a calculator

What it shows is that 10% means nothing to them. It's just another number that a calculator will spit out. It's not "one out of ten" or "shift everything to the right." They have no ability to evaluate what the number means on the fly. They just plug it into the calculator and check if they have that much. They can't have a reasonable discussion about the number without stopping and calculating every interest rate they can think of, writing them down on a piece of people, and writing the budget next to them.

A calculator here, of course, leads to more work, not less. I bet the vast majority of the time that somebody too lazy or anxiety-ridden to learn how to calculate 20% in their head is also going to be too lazy and bothered to take out a calculator every time they need to know, rather than just trying to bluff their way through conversations until they can get to a calculator.

Calculators are of no benefit to students who have no clear concept of the calculation. Just learn your times tables, they're one of the first things we teach kids.

The pragmatic pro-calculator "nobody needs to calculate those numbers in real life" school I think gets most of its support because constructivists often fail entirely to teach things that have been until now best learned by rote, hoping that an instinct for multiplication and division will naturally and precisely arise from children's mathematical souls. The fact that it doesn't is proof that doing arithmetic is bad and a waste of time actually. They love abstractions, but only vague ones that can't be reliably tested.

> Either way, they probably would not likely have learned the mental math required to do this regardless of if it were being taught at school or not

That's the law of averages. It is not a law.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by marinmania on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:25PM (#43486005)
I wonder if people that were writing code in assembly complained that people learning more modern languages didn't really know how the 0s and 1s work.

I'm not sure where the line is, but there is a point where the abstraction works so well you really don't need to know how it works underneath.

I'm also not sure if a car mechanic needs to know how an engine works. I'm assuming almost none of them could design a car engine from scratch. They know just enough to know which parts needs to be replaced.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @04:00PM (#43486507)
> there is a point where the abstraction works so well you really don't need to know how it works underneath

There is a point where most people might not need to know

There is never a point where no one needs to know

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by jdlshore on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:34PM (#43486145)
They did complain. But the key part is “the abstraction works so well.” It doesn’t, and I suspect it can’t.
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by balamatom on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:41PM (#43486238)
It can abstract over human agency.
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by rqtwteye on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @06:48PM (#43488349)
"I'm also not sure if a car mechanic needs to know how an engine works. I'm assuming almost none of them could design a car engine from scratch. They know just enough to know which parts needs to be replaced."

That's why, when your car has a problem, a lot of mechanics just blindly replace parts with the hope that something will fix it. You are much better off with a mechanic that understands how the car works. And you will save a lot of money.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by marinmania on Friday March 28, 2025 @07:10PM (#43510885)
I disagree that any car mechanic working a local auto body shop knows engines well enough to design one. They just know which parts are broken.

Similarly we reach a point in coding where you don't really need to know how every API or language you use operates beneath the hood, you just need to be able to see where its broken.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by throwway120385 on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:56PM (#43485590)
Not to mention the absolute pile of "mathematics problems" that can't be solved except by pushing symbols around a page, which a calculator is absolutely useless at. So sure I can have a calculator "calculate" an approximation for 4/3 but it can't help me manipulate the symbols around the improper fraction that i need to manipulate to calculate the radius given the surface area of a sphere. And it's of zero help in understanding the relevance of that "pattern" to whatever phenomenon I'm using the mathematics to reason about. That all requires human intelligence.

There are a lot of calculators and other tools that can push the symbols around and many that can even apply some special high-level mathematical rules to the symbols. But whether or not those rules are relevant to the task at hand is entirely a matter for a human to decide.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by turnsout on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:58PM (#43485613)
My feeling is… just give it 6-12 months. All the low-quality apps that were "vibe-coded" will start to break down, have massive security breaches, or generally fall apart as new features are added.

Brace yourself for a wave of think pieces a year from now, all wringing their hands about the death of vibe coding, and the return of artisanal handmade software.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:04PM (#43485688)
I have a similar feeling, but there's also a little voice in the back of my head trying to convince me that I'm just trying to cope with the fact I'm going to be made obsolete by a software industry that actually doesn't care if software breaks down and has massive security breaches as long as the AI furnace keeps getting coal
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by rqtwteye on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @06:50PM (#43488368)
I think both are true. The vibe-coders will run into massive problems. But AI will also improve a lot and probably be better than humans at some point.
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by BeetleB on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:21PM (#43485938)
> We've pretty much lost that.

In the US :-)

And those skills are entirely context dependent. You're likely saying this from a SW engineer's point of view. Whereas I've worked in teams with physicists and electrical engineers. When you're in a meeting, and there is a technical discussion, and everyone can calculate in their head the effects after integrating a well known function and how that will impact the physical system, while you have to pull out a calculator/computer, you'll be totally lost.

You can argue that you could be as productive as the others if you were given the time (e.g. doing this on your own at your own cubicle), but no one will give you that time in meetings.

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by wiseowise on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:25PM (#43486013)
> In the past, anyone who went to grade school could answer 6 * 7 off the top of their head, and do basic mental math. We've pretty much lost that.

Source?

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by turnsout on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:34PM (#43486135)
Observing people around me
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by belter on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:23PM (#43485203)
Would love to see eighth grade students of today, try this test from 1912...I sense disaster....

https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/13jhckh/...

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by BeetleB on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:28PM (#43486041)
These would have been quite doable by my 8th grade education.

But I am older than many. :-)

Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by fwip on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @02:50PM (#43485505)
Why? I'm pretty sure my public school education prepared me for all of these questions by 8th grade, excepting some notation that we no longer use and some specific history questions that are now less relevant.
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by turnsout on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @03:05PM (#43485704)
PS, if you're downvoting this, can you explain why?
Re:Microsoft Study: AI Makes Human Cognition "Atrophied and ... by askonomm on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @08:17PM (#43489045)
Must be a place with a pretty bad education system if people can't answer 6 * 7 off the top of their head.